
Israel Iran Mideast Wars
Humane, Flourishing Middle East Needs Redrawn Borders and Population Moves
Published June 25, 2025 • Read time: 7m
Will the Middle East emerge from its disastrous post-Ottoman century? With Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon all weak, the region’s reconstruction in ways that permit peace, stability, and human flourishing is finally possible.
Such a future must reject the inhumane status quo that European powers imposed after winning World War I. It must embrace instead the techniques that allowed Europe to stabilize after centuries of warfare: redrawn borders and population exchanges. Both are controversial. The latter is brutal and unjust – yet far superior to any alternatives.
The world is a better place with nation-states than it was with empires but the shift from one global order to another imposed costs. Population exchanges are an inherent cost of the nation-state system. Even at their best, they’re messy and painful. The alternatives – mass casualty battles, brutal authoritarianism, genocide, and forever wars – are far worse.
The region’s tragic century is a direct outgrowth of the incoherent dismemberment of the Ottoman Empire. When it became clear that the longtime “sick man of Europe” was unlikely to survive the aftermath of the First World War, two coherent proposals emerged, one imperial and one nationalist:
In 1915, Sherif Hussein of Mecca wrote to the British on behalf of all Arabic speakers between Egypt and Persia offering to support their war effort in exchange for a reduced empire, with leadership shifted from Constantinople’s Turks to Mecca’s Sunni Arabs (i.e., him). Events rendered that proposal moot.
Romantic nationalism, which entailed freeing captive nations to enable widespread self-determination, fared slightly better. Early maps envisioned autonomy (if not full independence) for Jews, Christians, Druze, Alawites, and Kurds, amidst Sunni Arab regional dominance.
Parts of that vision survived but the overall concept did not: The Mandate for Palestine called for Jewish self-determination; Lebanon was carved out of the mandate for Syria to empower Christians. All other minorities were ignored, as their shared Arabic language swamped faith, customs, historical connections, or traditional identities.
With the region’s borders drawn, the Arab states began exiling Jews within their borders, and hardly in a humane manner. Many flocked to Israel, bolstering the new state’s Jewish population and enhancing its prospects for success.
Israel did not respond in kind. Viewing the exiling of the Arabs of western Palestine as inhumane and provocative, Israel acceded to an even more inhumane international effort to trap them as permanent refugees and a source of intentional, perpetual instability. Decades later, they remain a leading regional irritant and fertile breeding ground for radicalism and terror.
Nor did the Arab states drive their Christians towards Lebanon. They simply oppressed them, discriminated against them, overran them with occasional pogroms, and encouraged their emigration. Meanwhile, Lebanon’s non-Christian populations grew large enough to destabilize the state.
In the Arabian Peninsula, the British recognized the claims of powerful sheikhs. Their stable tribal societies have since developed into stable, tribally based states with relatively few minority citizens (or subjects) – a lesson providing guidance for other parts of the region.
Nothing, however, ever held together the Levantine “Arab” states other than brute force. Totalitarian Baathist dictatorships, Iranian irregulars, and occasional internal atrocities (i.e., Syria’s Hama and Iraq’s Halabja) kept the order.
Saddam’s 1991 invasion of Kuwait invited a slow-motion U.S. takeover of Iraq, removing him from power in 2003. The 2011 Arab Spring weakened Assad, who finally fell in 2024. Iran’s proxy war launched against Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, has severely degraded its regional power projection. Freed from those chokeholds, the region’s people elevated their deeply held traditional identities above fidelity to the artificially imposed twentieth century states.
The net result is a region held together by very little other than a map drawn by outsiders. Those clinging to that status quo seek to perpetuate the pain and suffering of the region’s people. The humane alternative is to redraw borders and shift populations.
A predictable chorus of “experts,” pundits, and activists will pretend that the region’s future can emerge organically and calmly, entirely from within. It can’t. The tension across the Levant is precisely that each group seeks to control its own fate; the strongest among them also seek to dominate their neighbors.
The currently weak central governments of Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon cannot hold their countries together without both internal oppression and external support. Nor can any of the smaller groups – with the possible exception of the Kurds – declare and sustain their independence without help. Hopes and prayers aside, the question is not whether there will be further violence; it’s whether it’s possible to minimize the violence and work toward a better future.
Moving forward and deciding whether to sustain the status quo or to alter it will motivate those living in the region to seek external allies. Turkey, Iran, Israel, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Qatar are all jockeying to influence that future. Outside powers will certainly weigh in.
The naysaying chorus will argue that the U.S. should decline a seat at the table. The far wiser position – and the one that puts America first, to use a phrase in vogue again – would be to claim a seat that leverages minimal obligations to gain maximal voice. That means empowering and mediating among our regional allies, a list that currently includes all players other than Iran. It also means putting a thumb on the scales in favor of freeing the region’s natural, felt, historic identities rather than favoring the artificial states.
Nothing can happen overnight, and nothing will arise through peaceful consensus. It is, however, possible to express a vision for a better future – shattering the Overton Window as President Trump has done in so many other places – and nudging regional players toward it.
A stable Middle East would push the region’s Christians towards Lebanon, turning it into a genuine safe haven, protecting them from the predations of their neighbors, and likely preventing a recurrence of the genocide begun under ISIS.
It would also consolidate the Druze population to create a free enclave in nearby southern Syria.
It would empower Israel, which would like nothing more than peaceful co-existence and integration with true regional allies, to guarantee their own safety and independence.
The fourth generation “refugees” living in Gaza, Judea, and Samaria, in turn, would resettle throughout the Arab world. A mere fraction of the international aid that’s been expended trapping them as pawns should provide more than ample compensation and resettlement funding.
Under current circumstances, American statements favoring all of these solutions is possible.
Enclaves for Alawites and Kurds remain trickier, in large part because of their proximity to, and enmity with, Turkey. Should the Islamic Republic collapse into chaos, parallel challenges may emerge for the minorities of northwest Iran. American mediation efforts may prove the only thing capable of preventing massive bloodshed.
Of all the world’s still-captive nations, the Kurds may have the strongest case for self-determination in part of their historic homeland. Whether that’s possible given Turkish opposition and current strength remains an unanswerable question.
The region’s vast interior, and its dominant Sunni Arab population, pose the greatest challenge of all. Where tribal structures remain intact, the successes of the Gulf states point the way. Overall, the question remains whether leadership will pursue deradicalization or Islamism. The answer will depend on the sources of that leadership, and the U.S. can play the leading role there.
Among America’s allies, the UAE and Saudi Arabia appear committed to deradicalization. Turkey and Qatar promote Islamism. American policymakers must determine whether that promotion is ideological or transactional.
Ideological Islamists are irredeemable enemies of the United States, of human flourishing, and of regional stability. Transactional Islamists can be redirected as incentives shift. The world would become a far safer place if Turkey and Qatar determine that their current Islamist orientations entail unacceptable costs.
One way or another, a new Middle East will emerge. Its conception will be far from immaculate. It will involve further pain and suffering, war and death. The best that can be achieved is minimizing that pain while laying the groundwork for a stable and prosperous future.
Those who cling to status quo maps are dooming the region to another bleak century. Only redrawn borders and population shifts can promise a brighter future. Americans should not be debating whether we have an interest in moving the region in a positive direction; we clearly do. We should debate only how to maximize our influence with minimal direct involvement.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






