
Virus Outbreak The Vulnerable Rural America
Meet the Other Kevin McCarthy, Political Orphan
COMMENTARY
Published Oct. 4, 2023 • Read time: 3m
I had a chance to sit down with Kevin McCarthy a few months after the last speaker debacle. Oh not that Kevin McCarthy. My conversation was with a Winnebago Co., Ill., board member whose real job is as a morning DJ.
A loyal Republican, he was flummoxed watching the January carnival show playing out on national TV.
“Nationally, oh my gosh. When you have to vote over and over again. Swallow your pride. Let’s go on to do the business. The 20 holdouts vote once or twice,” he said. “Why did it take that long? That was the aggravating part. Just make it work … here’s a vote. Here’s another vote.”
Our discussions were part of my new podcast called “Lost in the Middle: America’s Political Orphans.” Forty-four percent of Americans self-identify as centrists. That’s 71 million voters who are bewildered by Washington’s food fights.
Winnebago County is an interesting place. It’s voted for the winning president in seven of the last eight elections. In 2016 Hillary Clinton broke the streak winning by a landslide 77 votes. Its largest city is Rockford, a tired manufacturing town that has seen better days, surrounded by farm land and purplish suburbs.
“We work great on the county side. After the county board meetings we’ll go out for drinks,” McCarthy said. “There are 20 county board members and often on votes we will get 20, sometimes 18.”
You may be a political orphan, too. You most certainly know one. And as 2024 presidential politics gears up, you should know that you are not alone.
Increasingly they and people like you are rejecting the political extremes, the incivility, the fighting.
They are looking for some kind of reasonable mix. A Washington Post survey from earlier this year found 66% of voters think the political extremes are a threat to America, and four out of 10 find their own party is too extreme. Centrists are feeling ignored and frustrated.
“I think that the current state of the country is quite disappointing,” said Alexandro Ramos, recently graduated from college in Connecticut. “And it's sad for someone that has studied political science and someone that hopes to one day run for office. I would go as far as saying disgusting that we can't sit at a table and talk about things without being at each other's throat.”
I agree. I’m lost in the middle too. There are a lot of us out there. I was a Republican congressman from deep-blue Madison, Wis. in the 1990s.
So what can we do about it?
Listening to each other might be a place to start. You might be surprised to learn there are people all over the country trying to change the current political zeitgeist.
I think another thing we can do is highlight success stories of ordinary citizens who are pushing back:
A Utah woman tried to launch a civility index. Her effort failed, but lessons were learned.
A Palm Springs editor conducted a bold experiment to deflate partisanship.
A Georgia voter embraced ticket splitting.
Election reforms are a possibility, and new systems are being tested in Alaska, New York City, and Maine.
In August, independents became the largest bloc of voters in Nevada. One of out of two voters say they will consider voting for an independent candidate for president.
Many people are afraid to talk about politics. We all walk on eggshells. But nothing will change unless the political orphans listen and talk to each other. And look for common ground.
It’s time for we political orphans to take back our country.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






