The Humanitarian with the Guillotine
Published Feb. 3, 2014 • Read time: 5m
February 3, 2014
2. Dispatches
———
1. The Humanitarian with the Guillotine
I was sick for a week and on vacation for a week—fortunately for me, not the same week—so I've got a couple of weeks' worth of news that I want to get through in the next couple of days.
Let's start with a story that's been bubbling in the background for a while but which I haven't commented on.
The legalization of marijuana is basically a done deal. Marijuana has been legalized, not just for "medicinal" use but for "recreational" use—i.e., it's OK to spark up just because you like getting high—in Colorado and Washington. The experiments in these states are likely to lead to legalization elsewhere. There is some movement in that direction from California to New Jersey. It won't happen right away in Kansas, I suppose, but marijuana could soon be legalized in enough states that potheads everywhere will pretty much be able to get what they want.
What capped off this trend was an interview in which President Obama—who ought to know a thing or two about marijuana, given his past as a high-school pothead—declared that it was no worse than alcohol. Since prohibition of alcohol has long been rejected, the obvious implication is that prohibition of marijuana should be dropped.
Dave Weigel excerpts the relevant passage.
If you read the whole interview, you see that he also hedged his statement and "nimbly argued the other side," as interviewer David Remnick put it. He segued into the question on marijuana from a question on gay marriage, a subject on which Obama had previously "evolved." Remnick notes: "When I asked Obama about another area of shifting public opinion—the legalization of marijuana—he seemed even less eager to evolve with any dispatch and get in front of the issue." Barack Obama is, after all, a politician, and not a particularly courageous one.
But embedded in Obama's answer is the key to why marijuana is being legalized, and also what this implies about the rest of the drug war. The case for criminalizing marijuana has been falling apart because the harm the state is inflicting on hapless potheads is so obviously greater than the harm they are doing to themselves.
It is a classic case of "the humanitarian with the guillotine," a phrase Isabel Paterson used to describe Robespierre's claim that he wanted to improve the lot of humanity, by means of cutting their heads off, one at a time—and to describe all of Robespierre's many successors. The War on Drugs is a milder version, promising to prevent people from ruining their lives, by means of throwing young people in jail and giving them permanent criminal records.
In the case of marijuana, the punishment has come to be viewed as too severe to justify any good that might be done. It has also come to be viewed as too capricious and unequal. As President Obama put it, "Middle-class kids don't get locked up for smoking pot, and poor kids do. And African-American kids and Latino kids are more likely to be poor and less likely to have the resources and the support to avoid unduly harsh penalties."
That's why this movement will be limited for now to marijuana and won't extend to the harder drugs. The president follows the logic of this argument.
"I also think that, when it comes to harder drugs, the harm done to the user is profound and the social costs are profound. And you do start getting into some difficult line-drawing issues. If marijuana is fully legalized and at some point folks say, Well, we can come up with a negotiated dose of cocaine that we can show is not any more harmful than vodka, are we open to that? If somebody says, We've got a finely calibrated dose of meth, it isn't going to kill you or rot your teeth, are we O.K. with that?"
He doesn't answer the question, in order not to "evolve" too far and "get in front of the issue."
Incidentally, just as everyone is accepting that marijuana is not a "hard" drug and shouldn't be banned, potheads have come up with a harder, concentrated form of marijuana which is more addictive and more destructive.
This may seem to undercut the case for legalization, but I think it just indicates the futility of prohibition. If people want to block out reality and destroy their own lives, ultimately you cannot stop them. Consider the case of Philip Seymour Hoffman, a talented and very successful actor who relapsed into drug addiction and was found dead with a needle in his arm at the age of 46. If he would rather have a temporary high than see his kids again, how is he going to be deterred by the prospect of breaking the law?
All the government can do is to substitute its own form of destruction in place of the addict's preferred form of self-destruction. The public is beginning to follow that logic in the easiest case, with marijuana, which is why the moment for legalization has arrived.
———
2. Dispatches
The ObamaCare death spiral begins.
Meanwhile, as predicted, more companies are dumping their employees onto the government exchanges. If they liked their plans, they couldn't keep them.
The full Communist agenda is trying to come back from the dead.
I wasn't surprised to discover that there is Atlas Shrugged "fan fiction." In fact, I'm a little surprised there isn't more of it. I was surprised, however, to discover that there is Atlas Shrugged-Harry Potter crossover fan fiction. It doesn't work.
———
—Robert Tracinski
The Daily Debate
edited by Robert Tracinski
Brought to you by RealClearPolitics.
Robert Tracinski is also editor of The Tracinski Letter.
Follow me on Twitter.
Send comments or suggestions to [email protected].
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






