
It's Zero Hour for Senate Immigration Bill
Published June 10, 2013 • Read time: 10m
Join the Conversation
0The most sweeping overhaul of the nation's immigration system in nearly three decades finally arrives on the Senate floor this week.
Leaders in the upper chamber are aiming for passage by July 4 of a measure that would open up a road to citizenship for millions of undocumented immigrants living in the United States. A bipartisan group of four Democrats and four Republicans spent several months crafting the bill, and the Senate Judiciary Committee put the finishing touches on it last month.
But with zero hour at hand, the fate of reform legislation is uncertain.
Florida Sen. Marco Rubio helped write the bill, but now says he will not vote for it unless border security provisions are strengthened. Many lawmakers share his view, and will offer amendments. But as with any bill of this magnitude, proposed changes can either help the measure swim -- or drown it.
RealClearPolitics examines where the measure goes from here, and what its passage (or failure) means for Congress and the White House.
What is the goal of reform?
Democrats have been pledging to pass immigration reform for years, but haven’t been able -- or willing -- to deliver. As he began his second term, President Obama called for a comprehensive bill that included a pathway to citizenship for the estimated 11 million illegal immigrants living in the United States. Senate Democrats, though, have been concerned that any legislation with the president’s fingerprints on it would turn off their Republican colleagues. For Democrats, the opportunity for citizenship is the pillar of reform. They have agreed that citizenship must be conditioned upon a more secure border, but they want to make sure those provisions aren’t so stringent that they make access to a green card unattainable.
Republicans generally see the passage of a reform bill as a gateway to Latino voters, whose lack of support for GOP presidential candidates has played a role in Democratic wins the last two elections. But not all party members share this goal. There is little appetite among House Republicans for one comprehensive bill, and the citizenship provisions will be particularly contentious for lawmakers who fear reprising the amnesty law of the 1980s.
What is in the bill?
The centerpiece is a 13-year pathway to citizenship that would begin roughly six months after the law is enacted. During those six months, the Department of Homeland Security would evaluate whether border security benchmarks mandated by the bill are being met. If the answer is yes, illegal immigrants would then be granted legal status and be able to work lawfully in the United States. They would have to pay fines and back taxes and would have to wait 10 years before applying for a green card. During this time, they would not be eligible for subsidies for the federal health care plan or for welfare and entitlement programs like Medicaid. The law mandates that employers use the E-Verify background check system to validate the status of immigrant employees. There would also be new provisions on high-tech and low-skilled worker visas.
If the DHS determines that border security benchmarks are not being met, the above steps cannot be triggered.
What kind of amendments will we see?
Among the most contentious provisions are the border security requirements. Many Republican lawmakers, including Rubio, aren’t convinced that the current measures are tough enough. Texas Sen. John Cornyn, for example, will put forth an amendment that would mandate monitoring of 100 percent of the southern U.S. border and an apprehension rate of at least 90 percent of those crossing illegally; installation of a biometric exit tracking system; and implementation of E-Verify nationwidel before illegal immigrants can be eligible for citizenship.
Rubio has also said that many lawmakers on his side of the aisle simply do not trust the administration to implement such enforcement provisions, even if they were to pass. The Florida senator is proposing that Congress, instead of DHS, be responsible for formulating the border strategy regulations.
In addition, Joe Manchin, who is among the most conservative Democrats in the Senate, has said he will propose an amendment requiring the children of undocumented immigrants to obtain a college degree or serve in the military before they can be eligible for citizenship. Some of the more liberal Democrats may push for same-sex couples to be covered by the law. (Judiciary Chairman Pat Leahy dropped this amendment from the bill during the committee markup out of concern that it would prevent passage.)
Conventional wisdom has it that the GOP lost the Hispanic vote so badly in 2012 that it is in the party’s self-interest to pass reform. Do Republicans agree?
South Carolina’s Lindsey Graham told reporters last week that his party will pay a heavy price for a failure to act. If Congress “cannot pass immigration reform in 2013 -- and it’s the Republican Party’s fault -- we’re dead in 2016,” he said.
Many Republicans shared that concern earlier this year when the reform effort got underway. Arizona’s John McCain said at the time he and other members of the so-called Gang of Eight released the framework for their bill that the climate on Capitol Hill had changed since a failed 2007 reform effort, largely because of the past two presidential elections.
But several months have passed since then, and many lawmakers, particularly those in the House, are starting to make the 2014 midterms their priority. And lagging Latino support in national elections doesn’t necessarily translate to congressional districts. While many House Republicans say they want to fix a broken immigration system, the imperative to pass a comprehensive bill this year isn’t as strong in the lower chambers as it is among national party leaders.
What are Republicans afraid of?
Two negative possibilities occur to Republicans -- one political, and the other a policy matter. First, with Latinos and Asians breaking heavily for Democrats in the last two national elections, some GOP strategists worry about the effects of minting 11 million citizens whose demographic profile seems to benefit Democrats.
On the policy side, many recall the bill Ronald Reagan signed into law in 1986, which automatically legalized 3 million undocumented immigrants. The worry here is that that law did not stem the flow of illegal immigration, and that two decades from now lawmakers will be looking at the same issue again, though with perhaps 30 million undocumented immigrants in the country.
“I don't think there's a trust . . . in the administration to enforce the current laws that are on the books as they relate to much of immigration. And not just this administration -- it has been previous administrations as well,” Rep. Tom Price, a Georgia Republican, told reporters last week at a breakfast sponsored by the Christian Science Monitor. “The first step in regaining that trust is living up to the promise that was made to the nation back in 1986, and that is controlling and securing the border.”
Who are the key senators to watch this week?
Under Senate rules, the bill needs 60 votes to pass, but supporters are aiming for 70 under the theory that broad support for a bipartisan bill will pressure the House into action. The 60-vote threshold might be hard enough to attain. Republicans might not sign on if they sense that it would be shelved in the House, thus risking their vote for something that may not have a future.
New Hampshire’s Kelly Ayotte, a key Mitt Romney surrogate in 2012, endorsed the bill on Sunday in an interview with CBS's “Face the Nation,” calling the legislation "a thoughtful, bipartisan solution to a tough problem."
Still, some of Ayotte's colleagues are standing in the way. Republican Sens. Ted Cruz of Texas, Jeff Sessions of Alabama, Mike Lee of Utah and Chuck Grassley of Iowa are leading the charge against the bill. These four lawmakers, who serve on the Judiciary Committee and voted against the measure there, wrote a letter to colleagues saying the bill rewards lawbreakers and fails to secure the border. “Americans expect their government to end the lawlessness, not surrender to it,” they wrote.
Many lawmakers and their staffs are still sifting through the 800-page bill and have not voiced support or disapproval. There are several to watch. One is Tennessee Republican Lamar Alexander, who has been meeting with the president and other senators (including Democrats) on budget issues and has expressed concern about problems with the current immigration system. Libertarian-leaning Rand Paul of Kentucky, a possible 2016 presidential contender, has expressed openness to a comprehensive bill. Utah’s Orrin Hatch helped pass the bill out of committee, but that doesn't necessarily mean he will support the final version.
South Carolina Republican Tim Scott, a newcomer to the Senate, is also still weighing his options; his state colleague Graham helped write the bill and has been campaigning for it in their state, but Scott’s predecessor, conservative think tank head Jim DeMint, is leading the outside charge against it. Members of the leadership team like John Thune (South Dakota), Roy Blunt (Missouri) and Jerry Moran (Kansas) will also bear watching.
Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who has applauded Rubio in the past, said he will not block debate on the bill. Eyes will of course be on Rubio himself, since he has expressed concerns about his own legislation. Conversely, Democrat Bob Menendez, another sponsor of the measure, will be closely watched to gauge whether liberals are still on board with border security changes. And, as with every big vote this Congress, the spotlight will fall on red-state Democrats too, including Mary Landrieu of Louisiana, Mark Pryor of Arkansas, Mark Begich of Alaska, and Kay Hagan of North Carolina.
If the Senate does pass a bill, how will the House respond?
Speaker John Boehner says his chamber would not take up the Senate bill as written, but instead would work on its own version. A House bipartisan group has been focused on legislation for years, but is continually on the verge of collapse. Last week, Republican Rep. Raul Labrador of Idaho, among the most conservative members of his conference, left the group over a disagreement about access to health care for illegal immigrants. Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte said he would like to see a step-by-step approach to reform and that one large bill is unlikely to come out of his committee.
The House could pass a series of small measures to address the various issues, then could conference on the Senate bill and arrive at some kind of final product. If they are unable to reach agreement on their own legislation, Boehner could bring the Senate bill to the floor for a vote, but that would require big help from Democrats. Boehner has been criticized by his members for doing this in the past.
Last week, the GOP-controlled House passed a bill stopping an executive order by the president that deferred deportations of illegal immigrants’ children. The legislation, an amendment to a DHS spending bill, was sponsored by Iowa Rep. Steve King, a staunch opponent of reform efforts. The vote fell mostly along party lines and stands little chance in the Senate, but it signaled the difficulties immigration legislation faces in the lower chamber.
What happens if Congress doesn’t enact reform this time?
Proponents of reform want to get the bill passed out of both chambers by the end of the year, before midterm politics kick in and complicate the chances of passage. Lawmakers could return to it at the beginning of 2014, but they risk it becoming a campaign issue. Republicans may decide to wait until after the midterms if they think they can gain a majority in the Senate and keep their majority in the House, thus helping them push through a more conservative bill. But Democrats would likely cite the failure of reform to beat up on Republicans in the elections. Obama would likely use his bully pulpit and blame the GOP. Floor speeches putting lawmakers on record would likely be used in campaign ads.
Completing anything during a midterm year is difficult, as every vote is in the spotlight and majority dynamics could shift. Also by then, any momentum now propelling the bill would probably have waned.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






