Trumka and Kucinich on "Piers Morgan Tonight"
Published Sept. 6, 2011 • Read time: 20m
MORGAN: Good evening.
President Obama hard at work today on the speech that America is waiting for, his address to a joint session of Congress Thursday night laying out his jobs plan. The stakes couldn't be higher for what may be the make-or-break moment of the entire Obama presidency. And it comes in the midst of a perfect storm for the White House. The president's approval ratings are lower than they ever been. More than six of 10 Americans give him a failing grade on how he's handling unemployment. And today, challenger Mitt Romney said this.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
MITT ROMNEY (R), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Growing our economy is the way to get people to work and to balance our national budget. The right answer for America is not the grow government or to believe that government can create jobs. Growth is the answer, not government.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MORGAN: Joining me now, this country's top leader, Richard Trumka, president of the AFL-CIO.
Mr. Trumka, thank you for joining me.
RICHARD TRUMKA, PRESIDENT, AFL-CIO: Piers, thanks for having me on. I appreciate it very much.
MORGAN: It may be a question for you and you're the most relevant guy to ask right now. Do you think President Obama is going to announce anything on Thursday which will get America back to work?
TRUMKA: I think he's going to announce a number of projects, a number of things that will put America back to work. I think that he'll talk about infrastructure, and the need for us to rebuild the country. Our infrastructure is crumbling. It will make us more competitive and will create jobs.
I think he'll talk about the FAA authorization, getting our airports and our transportation back into shape so we can compete around the world. He'll talk about a number of things like that, all of which will have to be taken together as a package to actually get the job done.
MORGAN: How much involvement have you had in terms of the speech? You seem to be very well-informed on what the president may be saying?
TRUMKA: Well, I haven't had any involvement in the speech, itself. But we have had numerous opportunities to communicate with the members of the administration and with the president, himself, about the things that need to be done to create jobs. He knows our position.
And what we need right now is more than anything else, Piers, is for the president to be a leader, to be bold, and to be aggressive and let the workers know that he's going to fight for them.
MORGAN: I mean, I couldn't agree with you more. I think that everyone is waiting for the president to stand up and be counted on this issue. Clearly, as we head towards election year, the clock is ticking, isn't it? I mean, he's going to go on with this. TRUMKA: Well, it's ticking everyday for people out there. We have 35 million people that are underemployed or out of work. They've been out of work for a long time.
They need somebody who's going to fight for them. They need hope. They need our politicians to lead rather than doing the radical-type politics that we've been seeing in the past that drive us up to brinksmanship and prevent anything from getting done.
MORGAN: I mean, the president has always stood for audacity -- audacity of hope, the change, and so son. Do you think that he has it in him to come up with a plan which is going to be big enough, radical enough and effective enough to really transform this jobs crisis?
TRUMKA: I mean, look at the background. When everybody told him that he ought to should let the auto industry go by the wayside, he stepped up and took some very, very bold action, saved the auto industry, put hundreds of thousands of people back to work, saved a lot of communities from pain. When it came to the health care bill, he was willing to stand up.
I mean, he didn't get much help from across the aisle and they did everything they could to negotiate it down so that it wasn't effective, but he stood up for that.
When it came to the stimulus package, he stood up and said, we have to help Americans get back to work.
So, he has done some bold things in the past, but we need him to be bold again. We need him to be a leader again. We need him to be aggressive again and singularly focus on creating jobs, jobs, jobs and more jobs, and actually steam roll anybody who gets in his way.
MORGAN: Do you think that if you were being critical that President Obama has left this far too late, and should have dealt with this almost the moment he took over as president, because he put a lot of time and energy into things like his health care plan and into sorting out Iraq and Afghanistan and so on -- almost everything but jobs. Many criticize him for not focusing on the one thing which is probably the most relevant to the lives of ordinary Americans.
TRUMKA: You know, I think he did focus on it, I think he had a number of problems he had to deal with. He was dealt a pretty bad hand. He didn't ask for Iraq and Afghanistan in a number of other things, he had to deal with them, and he didn't have a choice.
I think where he did make a strategic mistake was whenever he confused jobs with the debt discussion, because they got in the way of one another. We don't have a debt crisis in this country, and we really have a jobs crisis in this country.
MORGAN: Mitt Romney called the Chinese a bunch of cheats today. Did you agree with that?
TRUMKA: Well, in many ways they don't play by the rules. They manipulate their currency. They don't play by the rules, and so, the Chinese have a ways to go.
But I have to say this, unlike George Bush, this president really has tried to enforce the trade laws. He is going through a number of cases. In fact, one of the ones on rubber tires which is finalized today, the Chinese lost their last appeal and we'll have the opportunity to correct those situations. That is hurting this economy.
Them not playing by the rules gives them an unfair advantage over every producer in this country, and we have tried to get it stopped. I think the only thing that they understand is, if we actually get serious about it.
MORGAN: I mean, you can use the word cheat pretty liberally and people are in dealing with China. They have also been incredibly competitive some would argue and just out-businessed America in business. And that's one of the problems.
You know, I throw back at you perhaps responsibility for the employers. Take Apple, one of America's great success stories. They employ 25,000 people in America. The company that makes their computers employs 450,000 people in China.
So where does employer, American employer, responsibility kick in here?
TRUMKA: They have a significant responsibility that they haven't been taking up. Of course, our trade laws help them, and our tax laws reward them for taking jobs overseas. We ought to be creating laws and working together to send products overseas and not our jobs overseas. And I think that employers can do that.
They are taking advantage of when China cheats, they get an advantage of that cheating if they are located in China. They should be working with us to create a level playing field, help us to create jobs here, because I believe when the American workers are given a level playing field, they can compete with anybody in the world.
MORGAN: Obviously, Jim Hoffa had some rather harsh words to say about the Tea Party. Let's listen to what he said.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
HOFFA: We got to keep an eye into battle that we face, the war on workers, and you see it everywhere and it is the Tea Party. And you know, there is only one way to beat and win that war, and the one thing about working people is we like a good fight.
President Obama, this is your army. We are ready to march. Let's take these sons of b*tches out and give America back to America where we belong.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MORGAN: So, Mr. Trumka, Tea Party, sons of b*tches?
(LAUGHTER)
TRUMKA: I probably would not have chosen the adjectives he used. But I think Jim Hoffa is speaking for the anger that millions of Americans have. These people are taking and playing political brinkmanship and not being willing to help us create jobs, not being willing to help us get the country moving. Some of them even announced they want the president to fail in his attempts to get the economy right.
That's wrong. They shouldn't be doing that. And they don't have the right to say that they are truly the only patriotic ones out there when they want the country to fail and 25 million people not to get back to work.
So, I think Jim Hoffa was probably speaking about the anger. And what he was saying is that all politicians that don't stand up for jobs, all politicians that don't help us get back to work and right this economy, we ought to take them out of office. That's what he was saying.
MORGAN: Tell me, what is the mood amongst your members and indeed members of other leading unions? I'm detecting that from what I am hearing and reading that there is a cooling of President Obama and that must concern him, because he's going to need their votes.
TRUMKA: Well, I would say there is a cooling towards politicians in general and to Washington, D.C., because not enough is getting done. I mean, the strategy of the Republicans to not let anything get done to fix the economy has had some effect.
But our members really understand what's happening. It's not that they are saying that we're going to vote for a group of people that are anti-worker and pro-business. What they are saying is, we want more leadership from the elected officials. That includes the president. We want elected leadership from our Senate, from our House, from our governors, from our state and local bodies to actually start focusing on creating jobs, and putting people back to work.
Look, Piers, we are the richest nation on the face of the earth, and one of five children right now are living in poverty. That's growing. The inequality is growing. The joblessness is growing, because they are not focusing on creating jobs.
It's not that we can't do it, it's that they choose not to do it for political reasons. And that's what has angered Americans.
So, they want somebody to lead. And the president has a chance. And if he leads on Thursday night, which I hope and think he will, and he says, singular, our purpose is going to be creating jobs, I think that the American people will stand up and support him, because they want to work. That's what they want to do.
They don't want to get unemployment checks. They need them when they are unemployed, but they want to work, because that's what defines us. MORGAN: And, also, I think that one of the reasons that the mood perhaps of your members on President Obama has cooled is that he did of course go back really on his promise to withdraw those tax breaks for the rich, and we now have this farcical scene of Warren Buffett, one of America's richest people, almost begging to be taxed more. When you heard him say that -- I mean, why doesn't President Obama just come out and say, you know what? Warren Buffett is right. Everyone over $1 million a year, I'm going to tax the hell out of you, because we need revenue, we need this economy back on its feet?
TRUMKA: We do need the revenue. It will put us back on our feet. And as Warren Buffett said, it wouldn't hurt them.
There is something fundamentally wrong about a system that taxes a hedge fund operator that makes $1.5 billion a year at half the rate that his or her secretary makes. There's something fundamentally wrong about that. They haven't been paying their fair share and they need to.
And we hope that the president in the months and the years to come will stand up and say that.
Look, if the Bush tax cuts were allowed to expire in January, 50 percent of the deficit that everybody keeps screaming about, at least the Republicans keep screaming about, will go away.
A surtax on millionaires has 70-some percent of the American public supporting it. It's not like it's a political downside. You have to wonder why they aren't. Every politician isn't jumping up saying, you know, you asked for shared sacrifice, workers did. They took cuts in their pay. They took cuts in their pension. They lost their homes. They lost their jobs.
You're not doing anything different. It's your turn to share a little bit.
If he did that, I think he'd be a folk hero.
MORGAN: Couldn't agree more. Richard Trumka, thank you very much indeed.
TRUMKA: Piers, thanks for having me on again. I really appreciate it.
MORGAN: Coming up: could President Obama face a tougher challenge from his own party, (INAUDIBLE) from Republicans? I'll ask Democratic Congressman Dennis Kucinich.
(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
OBAMA: There's work to be done and there are workers ready to do it. Labor is on board. Business is on board. We just need Congress to get on board. Let's put America back to work.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MORGAN: That was President Obama in Detroit yesterday, previewing his jobs plan, a plan that may not be bold enough.
My next guest, Congressman Dennis Kucinich, says America is ready for a second New Deal. He says Washington needs to spend more to create jobs. And Congressman Kucinich joins me now.
Congressman, you're not very impressed then by what you think may be coming?
REP. DENNIS KUCINICH (D), OHIO: We want our president to succeed. But, frankly, we have to go beyond the minimalism that has characterized most of the Obama administration's programs when it comes to job creation. So, I'm hoping that the president when he speaks to Congress on Thursday will talk about big plans on the scale that FDR had when he brought the New Deal forward.
We have 14 million people unemployed. It's very important that we are mindful that just small steps aren't going to do it anymore.
MORGAN: And if you were the president, how big are we talking about? What kind of thing has President Obama got to come out with to really make a difference here?
KUCINICH: Well, I would hope that the president would call on the government's capacity to be able to spend money into circulation, just like the Fed, to create money out of nothing to quantitative easing. The government has the capacity to spend the money into circulation to meet the infrastructure needs of the country. The American Society of Civil Engineers said there's about $2.3 trillion in infrastructure needs that must be met.
We should be creating more -- spending for the purpose of getting all of our employees back to work. You have at least half a million jobs right now that could find funding with the help of the federal government, and we should be looking at the green revolution in terms of funding it.
NASA has enormous capacities to be able to help serve as an incubator for jobs in the private sector, being the creation of the concept, design engineering and lending the private sector running with ideas to help create millions of jobs. I mean, we don't have a lack of resources, truly. We have a lack of imagination, and I'm hopeful that our president will seize the moment, and recognize that the American people are ready for big plans.
MORGAN: One of the problems is that the Republicans, it is not in their interest to support President Obama, because if he does well, and gets America back to work, then he is going to be winning the next election. If he does badly and unemployment goes up, America has got a few months for this to evolve, then he may get booted out of office.
So, where is the incentives of the Republicans to not play partisan games here? KUCINICH: Well, your conventional political analysis is spot-on. However, there are Republicans as well as Democrats who are out of work. The Republican businesses who are suffering from a lack of demand right now, and the only way that you increase the demand is to be able to make sure people have jobs. And so, it's in the interest of the Republicans to come forward and support large big plans, because it helps all of America.
We have to close ranks now as Democrats and Republicans in recognizing that it's unemployment, not the deficit, which is the major economic challenge of our times. And we must meet this challenge, and I'm hopeful when the president comes forward on Thursday, he'll have such a plan to do that and will challenge the Democrats and Republicans alike to pass it.
MORGAN: Mr. Kucinich, when you see what's going on with the Republicans and you see the split between the Tea Party and the more moderate end of the party, what do you think is going to happen then? Because -- is it going to be a shoo-in for the president do you think when it comes to it, because no one is quite sure what the GOP stand for?
KUCINICH: All right. It's going to be about the economy. If President Obama is successful in getting millions of Americans back to work, then I would expect that he would be re-elected. However, if he is not successful in doing that, then people will be looking for change.
And so, this is all about the economy. We have to get people back to work. There are over 6 million people who are still in danger of losing their homes. We have to help people save their homes. We have to protect people's retirement security. These are all things that the president must be concerned about.
And if he's able to address those to the satisfaction of the American people, he'll stay in office. And if he's not, then you're going to be looking at an extremely close presidential race in which the Republican nominee would have a pretty fair shot at it based on the economy.
MORGAN: Can you see a situation where anyone challenges President Obama from within his own party? I mean, you, yourself, have run for the White House a couple of times, and made a couple of bids. Could you see a situation where you or somebody else thinks he knows something we need to have a different face here?
KUCINICH: Well, I'm not a candidate. Can I see someone coming forward to challenge President Obama from the ranks of the Democratic Party? I suppose it's possible. There again, it's going to be about the economy and that's what it should be about.
We have to get America back to work. And frankly, we have to stop wasting money on these wars that is causing us to be able to lose the resources that we need to be able to focus on things here at home.
So, should President Obama have a challenge? I say he should. I think it would make him a better president if he received a Democratic challenge in a Democratic primary. Will I be that candidate? No.
MORGAN: Do you feel that President Obama needs to beat his chest a little bit? Do you feel disappointed like many Democrats do that he's been, I don't know, a little bit tame in the way he's dealt particularly with the Republicans, being pushed around too much, and even down to when he can make a speech? It's a little bit demeaning. Why doesn't he say, you know something, I'm the president of the United States to John Boehner and if you want to move your thing, you move it?
KUCINICH: Well, there is something to what Kipling wrote about if you can keep your head while those about you are losing theirs and blaming it on you, there is something to that.
On the other hand, American people are looking for the kind of dynamic leadership which we believe that President Obama is capable of providing, but that's not just in the rhetoric. The rhetoric has to be matched by action.
That's why I talk about the big plans, about something that will put millions of Americans back to work, that will prime the pump of the economy, that will see our roads, bridges, water systems, sewer systems rebuilt. That will see our young people having a chance at college education, that will do something about the inequities in our society that are growing because people don't have a job.
So, President Obama if he can focus on it with a Rooseveltian panache, I think that we have an opportunity to see a different President Obama emerge. The times call forth from each leader the potential they have. And we all think that President Obama has the potential. The question is whether he'll do it or not, and whether he does it, whether he's able to deliver on the jobs issue is going to determine whether or not he is re-elected.
MORGAN: Without being too dramatic about it, I mean, could the prospect of a second term of office for Barack Obama hinge on this speech on Thursday?
KUCINICH: Hinge on the speech, no. But can -- will his re- election hinge on the speech? No. But will his re-election hinge on his ability to create millions of jobs? Yes.
We really have to recognize that we're in a moment in American history where the same old minimalism that has guided the government's response in the last couple of years is just not going to be substantive enough to be able to meet the challenges of rebuilding our economy. We need to create over 300,000 new jobs every month for the next couple of years just to get back to a level of unemployment that we had a few years ago.
MORGAN: I mean, slightly rephrasing then, my previous point -- if those jobs are not created, and in fact, if there is continued unemployment and the figure goes up, it is going to be almost impossible, isn't it, for President Obama to win the election?
KUCINICH: It would be very difficult. But I will say this. His destiny politically is within his control. And I want to add this, if people will say -- well, you know, he doesn't have the votes. Go to the American people, and get the votes. Rally the American people for jobs, and they will respond and Congress will follow.
MORGAN: Is it time for a bit of audacity and hope?
KUCINICH: Yes. I wish I had thought of saying that, but I would say yes, it is time for the audacity that is creative, that calls forth new possibilities simply by reaching out to people, touching their hearts and imaginations and say this is the way America is going to move forward, and now, let's move together.
MORGAN: Yes, I'm with you, Congressman. Thank you very much for your time.
KUCINICH: Thank you, sir.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






