
Experts: Trafficking Law Not Only Reason for Border Surge
Published July 29, 2014 • Read time: 6m
Signed by President Bush during the final month of his presidency, a little-known law with a long-winded name -- the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act -- has morphed from obscure statute to major discussion topic in recent weeks. The reason: It has been largely identified as a root cause of the recent surge of immigrant children across the U.S. southern border.
But experts say the 2008 law -- though a significant contributing factor -- is not the sole reason for the wave of minors arriving from Central America.
Michelle Mittelstadt of the Migration Policy Institute ascribes the cause of the crisis to a “perfect storm” of converging factors. Along with the so-called “push” elements in the children’s homelands -- negative conditions such as high rates of violence, gang activity and poverty -- juvenile immigrants are being drawn here by “pull” factors. Among them is their accurate understanding that they will at least get a hearing in front of a judge, with a good chance of remaining in the U.S.
The latter stems from the Wilberforce Act, but Mittelstadt also cites the Reno v. Flores Supreme Court decision from 1993. That ruling upheld an Immigration and Naturalization Service policy stipulating that detained alien juveniles can only be released to a parent or lawful guardian except in “unusual and extraordinary cases.” She also points to provisions of the 2002 Department of Homeland Security Act, which further codified processing of minors in ways friendly to their interests.
“There is increased knowledge [as to] what the law is” and “how children will be treated when they reach the border,” Mittelstadt said.
As word spreads about the slack in U.S. immigration policies, families have increasingly taken to paying smugglers to transport their children across the border, she said.
Jon Feere, a legal policy analyst for the Center for Immigration Studies, also pointed to President Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) executive-action memorandum as encouragement for the juvenile migrant wave.
Under DACA, children who meet a set of criteria -- including arriving in the U.S. before their 16th birthday and continuously residing in the country since June 15, 2007 -- can request authorization to defer legal action against them for two years, and may be eligible for employment authorization.
The White House has defended the memorandum, contending that newly arriving minors are not eligible for DACA since they have not been in the U.S. long enough. But Feere argues that such technicalities “aren't reaching” those in the surge:
“Really, this is largely an issue of messaging. If he wanted to discourage more people from risking their lives in the desert, President Obama would cease all public discussions about amnesty and the legalization of illegal aliens and instead send a message … that the United States will defend its sovereignty and will not welcome those who seek to violate it.”
Regardless of the cause, the numbers have been spiking during Obama’s presidency. According to figures from U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the number of Unaccompanied Alien Children (ages 0-17 years old) from El Salvador has risen from 1,221 during Fiscal Year 2009 to 13,301 in FY 2014. Guatemala and Honduras saw increases during that period of 1,115 to 14,086 and 968 to 16,546, respectively.
As of June 30, 57,525 UACs were apprehended at the southwest border in FY 2014, more than twice the number apprehended the year before, according to CBP.
Despite the substantial increase, deportations for youths under age 18 have dropped significantly since the Wilberforce law was signed. The total number of youth deportations decreased from 8,113 in 2008 to 1,169 in 2013, according to data from Immigration and Customs Enforcement obtained by the Center for Immigration Studies. From El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras specifically, the number decreased from 2,275 in 2008 to 496 in 2013.
The Wilberforce Act contains a provision that minors from countries non-contiguous with the U.S. who are found to be subjected to “a severe form of trafficking” be placed in the custody of the Department of Health and Human Services rather than DHS. They are then placed in “the least restrictive setting that is in the best interest of the child.” Options include foster care or staying with a relative already residing in the U.S. -- possibly illegally.
At that point, the minors wait -- sometimes for several years -- as their case moves through the immigration court system. According to the Brookings Institution, children wait an average of 578 days before getting a hearing.
Feere contends the 2008 law is aimed at victims of trafficking, not those engaged in smuggling operations, and is therefore currently being misapplied. He points to the ICE distinction between the two terms: “Human trafficking and human smuggling are distinct criminal activities, and the terms are not interchangeable.”
According to ICE, trafficking involves the exploitation of a person “for labor or services, through the use of force, fraud or coercion.” Smuggling almost always involves voluntary participation in the “importation of people into the United States involving deliberate evasion of immigration laws.”
What’s more, Feere argues that most of the children at the border do not even qualify as UACs. He says federal law defines a UAC as a person who "has no lawful immigration status in the United States," "has not attained 18 years of age" and does not have "a parent or legal guardian in the United States.” He notes that 90 percent of those in HHS custody are released to a parent or guardian already in the U.S.
This improper application, Feere argues, is helping to fuel the surge: “The administration is applying a law in a way that encourages people to come here illegally.”
A number of other solutions have been pushed to address the influx at the border. Doris Meissner, director of the U.S. immigration policy program at the Migration Policy Institute and former INS commissioner, called for faster adjudication of unaccompanied minor cases.
“Upfront hearings would mean that unaccompanied children would no longer be released to family members pending a decision on their eligibility to remain here,” Meissner wrote in an op-ed in the Dallas Morning News. “Those whose claims for relief from return are denied would be repatriated expeditiously; those with successful claims would be released to relatives or other sponsors.”
Similar legislation has been proposed in Congress. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, and Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Texas, introduced the Helping Unaccompanied Minors and Alleviating National Emergency (HUMANE) Act earlier this month. The legislation would allow minors to make their claim for safe harbor before an immigration judge within seven days of completing an HHS screening.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






