
Clinton: 2016 Landscape May Favor Immigration Reform
Published Aug. 5, 2016 • Read time: 6m
Join the Conversation
0Hillary Clinton fielded eight questions from journalists Friday, which was news all by itself for the famously press-wary Democratic nominee.
With her poll numbers on the rise and coming off a strong Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia last week, Clinton seized an opening to speak to hundreds of African-American and Latino journalists meeting in Washington at an annual convention.
She used her hour with the media to juggle questions about her trust deficit with voters and her email troubles, and to explain how she would implement her economic and immigration reform initiatives, if elected, in contrast with Donald Trump, whom she derided as wrong for America.
“I think journalists have a special responsibility … at a time like this,” Clinton said, while describing the high stakes in what she called “a crossroads election.”
“I hope you’ll keep calling it as you see it,” she added, before describing her jobs plan and government-centered policies aimed at helping minorities.
Clinton, who said she planned to host unnamed Latino leaders at her home in Washington Friday night to seek their support, said she is “optimistic” that comprehensive immigration reform legislation that includes a pathway to citizenship could be enacted if she is president. She said Trump’s defeat in November could send a wake-up call to Republicans that the policies they championed with voters in 2012 and 2016 failed to make the GOP a national party that could capture the White House.
Advisers inside Clinton’s campaign believe Trump’s policy prescriptions and rhetoric could prove toxic enough to compel Republican lawmakers and party leaders to once and for all abandon their enthusiasm or tolerance for anti-immigrant policies, if the GOP loses decisively in the fall.
The theory is similar to President Obama’s prediction four summers ago, while seeking re-election, that the 2012 contest against Mitt Romney would “break the fever” among conservatives, clearing the way for a more centrist Republican path toward immigration reform and other policy collaborations during the president’s second term.
Obama’s prediction proved to be incorrect. He defeated Romney among Latino voters by 71 percent to 27 percent, the highest share of the Hispanic national electorate won by a Democrat since 1996, yet efforts to pass bipartisan immigration reform died under intense political opposition. Republican House Speaker John Boehner eventually quit in frustration, unable to steer his divided conference through a host of contentious issues. The Senate had shifted to GOP control in the 2014 midterms, further isolating the White House. And a crowded Republican presidential primary field this year, including candidates who favored immigration changes, gave way to Trump.
Clinton said she has already consulted some of her former Senate colleagues about how immigration reforms could pass in 2017.
“This will be fast-tracked,” she said. “I think the outcome will be very different this time.” She said she based her optimism on projections that Democrats have a “good chance” to take control of the Senate and are on a trajectory to “pick up House seats.”
“I view the political landscape as favorable,” the Democratic nominee told the audience at a joint convention of the national associations of black and Latino journalists, known as NABJ and NAHJ.
“I think the chances, once we win, improve dramatically,” she said. “I’m hoping that the outcome of the election, which I am working hard to ensure [is] a victory, will send a clear message to our Republican friends that it is time for them to stop standing in the way of immigration reform.”
Clinton repeated her pledge, even while pursuing legislation, to maintain Obama’s controversial deportation waiver programs, known as DACA and DAPA, for eligible undocumented immigrants and their families living in the United States. Obama’s program for the children of undocumented immigrants is in effect, but his expansion of deportation protection to parents of the so-called DREAMers has been blocked in court.
“We are not going to be deporting,” Clinton said. “That is how I would direct DHS [Department of Homeland Security] to act.” She stopped short of promising to go farther than Obama’s enforcement waivers, which she has done during past campaign appearances.
Republicans, including Trump, describe Obama’s executive enforcement decisions as illegal and unconstitutional. The GOP nominee has said his administration would seek to deport an estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants from the country.
During her afternoon Q&A with journalists, Clinton was again asked to clarify her remarks last week during a Fox News interview rebutting the FBI’s determination that as secretary of state she was “extremely careless” with classified information on her private email system.
During that interview with Chris Wallace, Clinton made false statements, assessed by newspaper fact-checkers to be cherry-picked from House testimony from Director James Comey, following an FBI investigation examining the security of classified information transmitted on Clinton’s private email server.
The former secretary of state did not budge off her earlier defenses, but said she and Wallace may have been talking past one another during the interview.
“I may have short-circuited, and for that I will try to clarify,” Clinton said, glancing down to read notes as she haltingly attempted once again to tamp down the email controversy that has dogged her for a year and a half.
Clinton’s explanation Friday remained confusing to any listener, and was similar to her statements to Fox News, which were widely challenged in the media. She repeated that her answers to the FBI had been “truthful” and were “consistent” with what she told the public on numerous other occasions about sending and receiving emailed material marked as classified.
In fact, Comey said Clinton was truthful during her interview with the FBI, but he directly challenged some of the former secretary of state’s public assertions during his day-long testimony, in which he described the FBI’s independent findings.
Clinton began her explanation Friday by saying that “using two email accounts was a mistake,” but moments later said, “I regret using one account.” In the past, she has confirmed she set up one personal email account on a personal server for all work-related and personal communications while she was secretary of state.
Asked how she would win the support of voters and lead the country in the face of so many Americans who tell pollsters they distrust her, Clinton assured her audience she has not dismissed the vulnerability. “I take this seriously,” she said. “It doesn’t make me feel good.”
The Clinton campaign is working to play up Trump’s similar trust deficits and unpopularity, as measured by months of polling, in hopes of turning the election into a referendum on him. At the same time, Clinton has wrapped herself in detailed policy plans, eager to transform commitments to voters into trust builders.
“I’m going to work my heart out,” she said, “to produce results for people.”
Clinton’s Brooklyn team announced Friday the candidate will return to the battleground state of Florida, where her edge over Trump is less than 3 percentage points in the RealClearPolitics average, to campaign Monday in St. Petersburg and Orlando, and in Miami on Tuesday.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






