
Daily Life Kansas
In Praise of Old-Fashioned Dads
COMMENTARY
Published June 18, 2022 • Read time: 3m
The other day, The Washington Post, in an attempted paean to fatherhood, went out and asked fathers what it means to be a man. The answers were hardly enlightening. They were mostly cliché-filled attempts to be thoughtful, wise, and correctly sensitive.
The underlying lesson we were expected to come away with is that fathers today are so much smarter, cooler, and better than fathers of yesteryear.
For example, one man said, “There is no one way to ‘be a man.’ However, all ways ought to include showing emotion, admitting when you are wrong, respecting others (especially women) …”
Pure malarky.
The article reminded me of a Father’s Day piece I wrote back in 1992 – 30 years ago – when the news media were off on a toot in praise of “modern dads” who changed diapers, helped with the housework, and even cooked meals.
Wow! Aren’t they cool? The implication of the articles was that these so-called modern dads were somehow better than older-generation dads who worked all day and never changed a diaper, read a bedtime story, or cooked a meal for their kids.
But even more outrageous was the underlying theme that these so-called modern dads love their children more than those of earlier generations. That concerned me, and still does.
Here is part of what I wrote:
When I grew up, most of the fathers I knew were the old-fashioned kind. Most of the mothers were housewives. Division of labor was usually clearly marked: Men went to work, took care of home repairs and maintenance, and tried to sandwich in a little “quality time” with their kids whenever they could.
Some had to work two jobs to make ends meet, often telling their kids, “I want you to get an education so you don’t have to work as hard as me.”
But by their hard work, firm discipline, frank honesty, and simple kindness they served as solid role models for their children. They must have done something right if many of them, the “modern dads” of today, are so concerned about being good fathers.
I guess my father would qualify as an old-fashioned dad. I remember him cooking dinner one night when my mother was ill. He mistakenly poured Mr. Clean instead of cooking oil into the frying pan. I can still smell that acrid blue smoke.
Back in the days when I was wearing diapers, I am sure my father wished he could have changed a few. But instead, like thousands of other “old-fashioned” dads, he was busy spilling his blood on the sands of Iwo Jima. And I remember him telling me when I grew up that he went to war so that I would not have to.
And don’t tell me about how sensitive and empathetic these “modern men” are. I knew two old-fashioned dads, men who would do anything for their children, but seldom, if ever, changed their diapers. Yet, each was forced to stand by helplessly and watch one of their children die.
The pain I saw in the eyes of those fathers as they tried to be brave for the rest of their families is something I will never forget. It made me realize that there is no greater tragedy that can befall a parent. A little bit of those men died with their kids. But they picked up the pieces and carried on.
I have no argument with the very admirable quality of men wanting to be more involved in child rearing. Just do not tell me that they are somehow better fathers than those who came before them.
To all the old-fashioned dads out there, Happy Father’s Day!
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






