VP Selection Scenarios; Cruz in NYC; Terrorism and Baseball; Why We Fight
Published March 24, 2016 • Read time: 5m
Join the Conversation
0Good morning. It’s Thursday, March 24, 2016. In the wake of the Belgium terror attacks, Hillary Rodham Clinton went into the heart of Silicon Valley yesterday with the twin goals of sounding like a future commander-in-chief while simultaneously eviscerating the two leading Republican presidential candidates for their mucho macho responses.
HRC is a practiced pol who knows how to do two things at once, but a third goal of her speech was to enlist America’s great technological minds in the war against Muslim terrorists. This was a harder sell: Industry leader Apple, to general applause in the tech community, has demonstrated that it wants no part of this fight. The company has fiercely resisted helping the government look for evidence in the iPhone of the San Bernardino mass murderers.
Here, the former secretary of state fell back on her experience as a diplomat to try and seek middle ground.
“The tech community and the government,” Clinton said, “need to stop seeing each other as adversaries and start working together to protect our safety and our privacy.”
This is an interesting approach, with a long historic precedent: What Americans have learned over the centuries is that when we march to war we don’t fully know what we’re fighting, or why, and can be surprised by what transpires on the battlefield.
Certainly, that was the case on this date in 1863 when a Union Army major named Hiram Underwood labored for three hours to help some escaped slaves cross the James River to freedom.
I’ll have more on his motivations in a moment. First, I’d direct you to RealClearPolitics’ front page, where we aggregate stories, polls, videos, and commentary spanning the ideological spectrum. We also have a complement of original material from RCP reporters and contributors:
* * *
Open Convention Could Upend VP Selection Process. Rebecca Berg examines possible scenarios as the GOP drifts toward uncharted waters.
In NYC, Cruz Tries to Unite Anti-Trump Forces. Caitlin Huey-Burns reports on the Texas senator’s appearances yesterday in the city whose values he has ripped during GOP debates.
Pros & Cons of a Stop-Trump Third Party Bid. Sean Trende has this assessment.
Politics, Terrorism, Cuba, and Baseball. Tom Bevan considers the criticism leveled by Ted Cruz and John Kasich at President Obama for attending a baseball game in Cuba after the Brussels bombings.
The Campus Affluenza Epidemic. Heather Wilhelm was dismayed to hear about a student protest at Emory University involving -- who else -- Donald Trump.
Israel’s “Sorrow of the Left.” Peter Berkowitz explores the widening rift between the nation’s hard-liners and liberals, who feel increasingly marginalized, in a conversation with Tel Aviv media dean Yaron London.
Help Distressed People, Not Distressed Cities. In RealClearPolicy, Adam Millsap offers this prescription.
* * *
From time to time, a cataclysmic event forces Americans to assess the state of race relations in this country. Sometimes, such as last June when a domestic terrorist went into a venerable African-American church in South Carolina and murdered nine people with the goal of starting a race war, that self-examination includes a discussion about why the Civil War was really fought.
This is an important conversation, but the answer is always the same.
In response to 19th century Southerners’ professed love of liberty, Abraham Lincoln noted caustically that “the perfect liberty they sigh for [is] the liberty of making slaves of other people.”
By the time Lincoln took occupancy in the White House, secession was an accomplished fact. In his first inaugural address, the new president succinctly described the battle lines: “One section of our country believes slavery is a right and ought to be extended, while the other believes it is wrong and ought not to be extended.”
For the most part, the men who mustered in the respective armies of North and South knew it, too. As for the hoary debate about whether the war was fought over freeing slaves vs. keeping the United States intact, those were never mutually exclusive aims.
One Union soldier, Elisha Hunt Rhodes of the 2nd Rhode Island Volunteers, summed up all the reasons he was fighting in a passage of a letter he wrote home.
“I thank God that I have had an opportunity of serving my country, freeing the slaves and restoring the Union,” he wrote.
Hiram Underwood, at least initially, wasn’t so sure. Underwood, an officer in the 2nd Michigan Infantry, made known his resentment toward the politicians who’d led Americans into war over the question of slavery -- and Underwood wasn’t thought by his troops to be too kindly disposed to the blacks whose condition in human servitude had forced the question.
Those perceptions changed on March 24, 1863, as the 2nd Michigan marched toward Richmond and came across escaped slaves, called “contrabands,” in Union Army parlance. A young enlisted man named Charles B. Haydon recorded in his diary what happened next:
“Major Underwood has always been very bitter on the Abolitionists, but tonight he worked more than 3 hours in water up to his waist to help 20 contrabands across the river & on their way to Paradise at Fort Monroe,” wrote young Private Haydon. “He said they looked so frightened that he had to help them.”
Carl M. Cannon
Washington Bureau chief, RealClearPolitics
@CarlCannon (Twitter)
[email protected]
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






