
Iran War Strait of Hormuz
Containment That Causes Iran To Capitulate or Crumble
ANALYSIS
Published Sept. 13, 2026 • Read time: 6m
President Trump has seemingly settled into a new long-term strategy against the Islamic Republic of Iran after the United States has fallen short of strategic success through military and diplomatic means. The new strategy hinges on economic asphyxiation, supported by the military, to contain and isolate the Iranian regime.
The logic of such a strategy is based on pressure – increasing it on the regime and decreasing it on the United States and the global economy. The blockade and additional sanctions are intended to strangle the regime, eliminating the resources necessary for them to repress internally and threaten externally. Iran faced dire economic conditions even before the 12-day war in 2025, and their current situation is significantly worse.
On the other hand, relaxed pressure on friendly interests has been facilitated by improved flow of resources through or around the Strait of Hormuz. Despite Iran’s malign intent, experts suggest that the friendly flow might be up to two-thirds of prewar levels. Combined with the economic isolation of Iran, it provides a strategic calculus that favors U.S. interests. But at what cost and to what purpose?
There are two notable shortcomings of the strategy provided by Operation Economic Outcast. Both are related to the timeline. First, while the current situation contains the regime, there is no promise for quick strategic success. Vice President Vance acknowledged that challenge late last week.
With a nebulously long timeline, the second shortcoming is based on the significant burden placed on the U.S. military and the associated opportunity costs on U.S. global interests and commitments. In order to defend itself and U.S. interests against Iran, enforce the blockade, and ensure maximum friendly flow through the Strait of Hormuz, a large force presence is required. Thus, 50,000 brave American military members will remain in harm’s way for the duration of such a strategy, and a major portion of U.S. military assets will be tethered to the Middle East. It is the indefinite cost of containment until the strategy yields something more.
Other than preventing Iranian nuclear weapons capabilities, which was largely accomplished by seven B-2 bombers in Operational Midnight Hammer, what should be the objective in Iran? Containment is in itself a partial strategic success, cutting off resources that would otherwise be used to fulfill Iran’s malign intent, limiting their ability to threaten U.S. interests, and preventing the reconstitution of a previously potent Iranian military force.
Yet, as we’ve seen after previous rounds of containment pressure on Iran in the last several decades, a scrappy evil regime will likely exploit gaps and seams of pressure to regain its foothold in the region. Thus, anything short of regime capitulation or crumbling will fail to realize long term success. The only way to hope for such an outcome through a containment strategy is with proper follow through in a few key areas.
Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent announced Operation Economic Outcast nearly three weeks ago, with the promise of creating crushing economic pressure. He committed to sharing the details of implementation and suggested that some cases were imminent. Thus far, no significant secondary sanctions have been announced.
While the blockade is substantially hurting the regime, the lack of full follow-through on secondary sanctions diminishes U.S. credibility while allowing trade and exchange related resources to continue to ease the pressure on the regime. A failure of implementation would also take away the multi-faceted diplomatic pressure on Iran that would come from other nations facing hardships due to secondary sanctions. The United States needs to doggedly pursue a full range of economic pressure to truly contain and isolate Iran, and to further pave a pathway towards capitulation and crumbling.
Through it all, the enemy gets a vote. Iran will continue to lash out at the United States and our allies and partners, striving to increase the costs and the risks of the United States containment strategy and erode our willingness to stay on track. In addition to necessitating continued U.S. resolve, such strikes by Iran offer an avenue of strategic opportunity through deliberate and precise escalation by the United States.
In the many rounds of provocation during the five-month ceasefire period, the United States has been limited and proportionate in its response. Iran has been enticed rather than deterred, proven by their willingness to keep striking out while rebuffing attempts to negotiate a real settlement. While President Trump is wary of large-scale escalation in part due to diminished weapons stockpiles, there is a way to shape escalation to better capture the attention of the regime and further U.S. interests.
Instead of emphasizing proportionality in response to any counter-containment actions by Iran, their strikes provide a pretext for the United States to do something far more to restore deterrence and regain the initiative. Responsive and precise U.S. strikes designed to impact the regime permanently and irreversibly would complement containment. The oil infrastructure at Kharg Island tops the list of the types of targets with disproportionate and lasting impact. Striking Kharg would harm the regime’s ability to fund itself for the long term maybe more than any other singular site, and U.S. strikes on those targets would capture their attention, erode their will, and deter their provocations.
Additionally, it has been several months since Iranian internal security locations have been targeted. During active combat operations it had been an area of emphasis for the Israel military with an eye towards neutering the regime – likely with a vision for an end state that would cause the regime to capitulate or crumble. It’s a target set that never became a priority for the United States. Now is the time to revisit that omission in response to any Iranian strikes on U.S. interests in the region.
Will these types of strikes properly complement containment and yield subsequent strategic results? Will they further the aims that would see the regime capitulate or crumble? Minus coordination with an opposition force that could replace the regime, a pathway to lasting strategic success against Iran is unclear. Yet, as the United States sees the benefits of containment while paying its costs, it is important to also pursue mechanisms that could result in regime capitulation or crumbling to achieve an end state of lasting strategic success.
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
Contributing to RealClear Politics through the RealClear Media Foundation supports essential initiatives that drive meaningful change.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






