Mired
Published Feb. 12, 2014 • Read time: 6m
February 12, 2014
1. Mired
2. Dispatches
———
1. Mired
State of the Union speeches have a tendency to disappear rapidly into irrelevance, with the president ticking off a laundry list of worthy-sounding initiatives that are either never implemented or never have any impact. Barack Obama's latest State of the Union speech is more irrelevant than most because without Democratic control of the House, and with his agenda mired in the quagmire of ObamaCare, the president has no ability to promote new legislation.
Which is why Obama declared in his speech that he will bypass Congress by issuing a lot of executive orders. Commentators on the right have warned against this attempt by the president to wield arbitrary, unilateral power, and certainly the idea does President Obama no credit. But while his dream of rule by executive order is nefarious, it is also unrealistic. The president will find that, as much as he stretches his executive authority to the limit and beyond, there really isn't all that much of consequence he can do. Our whole system is designed to prevent it, and the system hasn't quite been broken yet.
Take the initiative which, as far as I can tell, is the only Obama proposal to survive his speech: a new kind of retirement savings vehicle called the "myRA." This is almost a parody of the kind of cloyingly cutesy name the government always gives to a program in an attempt to shout at you, "we're from the government, and we're here to help." It is clearly intended to rhyme with "IRA," reminding us of a very successful government program for tax-free retirement savings—though in practice it will almost certainly be pronounced "Myra," like the name of a elderly Jewish lady in Boca.
And that is not the only way the program will be disappointing when put into practice. At MarketWatch, Chuck Jaffe explains why the program is basically useless as a retirement vehicle.
"The basic details released to this point make it clear that myRAs will be backed by a security that looks and feels like a savings bond, backed by the government and with the same variable-interest-rate return offered by the G Fund, the Government Securities Investment Fund in the federal employees’ Thrift Savings Plan....
"The G Fund in 2012—the latest year for which numbers are available—returned 1.47%, and has an annualized average return from 2003 to 2012 of 3.6%. The problem is that inflation in 2012, as measured by the Consumer Price Index, was 2.08%, which means that in real-return terms, G Fund savers lost ground. The value of their account was up, but their purchasing power was diminished.
"Obama is introducing his program just as interest rates appear to be coming off the bottom, and at a point where many observers expect an increase in inflation going forward. If the myRA can’t generate more in returns than inflation, even if it succeeds in getting people to save, they won’t be saving well."
But it gets worse: "The myRA program has a $15,000 limit.... Reach the $15,000 limit and you must transfer the funds, so your government guarantee of a protected investment is gone."
Suffice to say that $15,000, enough to sustain one person for one year at roughly the poverty line, is not a significant amount of retirement savings. Yet it is precisely at this point that individuals are required to transfer their money out of the myRA system.
Since it is useless for actual retirement saving, what will the myRA actually be used for?
"The G-Fund payout of 1.47% in 2012 is a far sight better than most savers could have gotten from a bank account at that time. Let’s assume that trend continues; with the myRA having no penalties for withdrawal, it can be used as a better alternative to a savings account for people trying to keep an emergency fund in an account that is government-insured against loss.
"That’s not the intention of the program, but Americans have shown a knack for taking advantage of programs for personal benefits, and not necessarily as the framers of those programs intended."
The whole program is par for the course for Obama: a retirement savings program designed with no apparent knowledge of how saving, investment, and retirement planning actually work—all based on the arrogant presumption that government can do things so much better than a vibrant and innovative private sector.
At RealClearMarkets, Hester Pierce points to a further example of this kind of arrogance: a proposal to offer a whole new set of government-backed, government-run financial services by way of the US Postal Service. And why is the post office so eager to jump into financial services? Because they're losing money and are on the verge of going belly-up. Which obviously qualifies them to offer financial services to the rest of us.
That's exactly the kind of motive behind the myRA plan. Obama is using it to distract from the real impediment to the average person's ability to save: our moribund, low-growth, low-employment economy. As one financial professional tells Jaffe: "The litany of retirement-savings options already out there are plentiful. What is not plentiful is the money to put into them."
Obama has always yearned to be a "consequential" president, like Ronald Reagan. The myRA is a transparent attempt to copy the IRA, a Regan-era initiative—passed with the approval of Congress, by the way—that really did transform how the broad American middle class saves for retirement.
But as with so much else this president does, it will prove to be consequential only in providing another cautionary tale about the hubris of government.
———
2. Dispatches
We've been warning for decades that someday the middle-class entitlements are going to swallow the entire federal budget. Well, that day is here.
The next ObamaCare fiasco: "Doc Shock."
If President Obama thinks diplomacy is so important, how come he is selling diplomatic appointments to unqualified campaign donors?
What's left of Occupy Wall Street is collapsing into infighting.
Here's one of the best, most succinct refutations of the notion that the Civil War wasn't really about slavery. Apparently, the Confederate leaders who started the war didn't get the "it's not about slavery" memo.
———
—Robert Tracinski
The Daily Debate
edited by Robert Tracinski
Brought to you by RealClearPolitics.
Robert Tracinski is also editor of The Tracinski Letter.
Follow meon Twitter.
Send comments or suggestions to [email protected].
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






