
New York State of the State
Thankfully for NY GOP, Dems Still Haven't Learned Their Lesson
COMMENTARY
Published May 28, 2025 • Read time: 4m
Last week, the national Democratic establishment voided the election of David Hogg as vice chair of the Democratic National Committee. Rather than punishing those who challenge the status quo, you’d think Democrats rebuilding their party would be heeding their base. Fortunately for Republicans, they are not.
In fact, New York’s Democratic establishment has taken a similar approach by changing state election law to enhance their control over the primary process. The new budget permits candidates for governor and lieutenant governor to run together in a primary (instead of running separately) and appear as an endorsed ticket on a primary ballot – and as an endorsed ticket with a prime ballot spot if they win the majority of a vote at the state party’s convention. This change, backed by Gov. Hochul herself, is a deliberate attempt to rig the Democratic gubernatorial primary in her favor – despite her unpopularity among voters. If Democrats continue their embrace of anti-democratic measures, Republicans will retake New York for the first time in a generation.
Hochul faces a tough election season in 2026. With an abysmal approval rating of 36%, recent polling shows she’d win only 24% of the vote, and she recognizes the danger. Her potential challengers, Congressman Ritchie Torres and Lt. Gov. Antonio Delgado, would likely be able to capitalize on her unpopularity and win the Democratic gubernatorial nomination. However, changing the law to allow prospective governors and lieutenant governors to run as a ticket – something that has not previously been allowed in the Empire state – can help her eliminate some competition by permitting her to strong-arm one of her potential opponents into becoming her lieutenant governor. Further, her governor status gives her a stranglehold over the New York Democratic Committee, improving her chances of winning the party endorsement (and prime ballot spot) at the convention. This blatant attempt to rig the primary will not go over well with the general electorate.
Democratic voters are sick of the Democratic establishment ignoring them, and it’s no wonder why. There has not been a contested Democratic primary for president since 2008. Think about it: In 2016, superdelegates (i.e. party insiders who are not voted onto the ballot) effectively handed the Democratic primary to Secretary Hillary Clinton when they pledged to support her. In 2020, the Democratic establishment coalesced behind Joe Biden before the South Carolina and Michigan primaries, resulting in a Biden primary victory. Finally, in 2024, the Democratic establishment ignored the will of 15 million voters by forcing Joe Biden to drop out of the race and installed Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee without any kind of public primary process. Notice that in 2016 and 2024 Democrats lost the presidency, and in 2020 Republicans overperformed down ballot by gaining seats in the House and numerous state houses.
David Hogg’s voided election further illustrates how the Democratic establishment handles dissent – even outside of presidential primaries. The move reeks of retaliation against voters for supporting a candidate who challenged incumbents and called out the party’s issues with men. Voters clearly don’t like being ignored by party elites – something reflective of the Democratic Party’s abysmal national approval rating.
Democratic leaders’ apparent disregard for voter approval displays some hubris: Do they imagine Republicans could never take over a safe blue state like New York? Hochul is vulnerable – even President Trump is more popular in the Empire State than she is. New York Republicans have a slew of strong potential gubernatorial candidates who can capitalize on Hochul’s unpopularity and win the governor’s mansion. Polling shows that Nassau County executive Bruce Blakeman, Congressman Mike Lawler, and Congresswoman Elise Stefanik are all within 8% of beating Hochul, meaning they are all viable Republican challengers. Because all three candidates are so strong, the new law may encourage two of them to team up and run together instead of running in a costly primary. This would bolster Republicans’ chances of winning in November of 2026.
New York Republicans benefit from Democrats’ disconnect from the public. Their continued embrace of undemocratic measures has sullied their party’s image and made voters distrust them. Even now, Gov. Hochul’s meek attempts at maintaining power will harm her reelection chances. Should Republicans pick a well-funded candidate with great name recognition and ties to key interest groups, they will win in November 2026 – all thanks to Democrats’ unforced errors.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






