Jonathan Turley: Ilhan Omar Has Done Nothing To Put Questions About Her Background To Rest
Last updated 6:15 PM ET
George Washington University law professor and FOX News contributor Jonathan Turley weighs in on the controversy surrounding Rep. Ilhan Omar's background.
"The question is whether she could be stripped of her citizenship," Turley said. "That would obviously mean she couldn't be a member of Congress. But also, it's true that if she was elected on false pretenses, if she violated federal election law, that would also put her seat in danger. We just don't know. And we didn't get any closer after this interview. And that's what's so concerning here is that Representative Omar has the ability to put many of these things to rest. She's had that ability for years, and she really has done nothing but give these denials without offering anything to put them to rest."
BILL MELUGIN, FOX NEWS CONGRESSIONAL CORRESPONDENT: A new controversy is really starting to brew over Ilhan Omar concerning whether or not that's even her real name. Fox News Digital reporting that court documents identify the Minnesota Congresswoman as Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, also known as Ilhan Abdullahi Omar. U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro sounding off on this bombshell discovery.
U.S. ATTORNEY JEANINE PIRRO: Her real name is Ilhan Nur Said Elmi. You had it absolutely right. Her sister is Sahra Nur Said Elmi, and her sister actually wrote a book and talked about the fact that Ilhan is her sister. So that is her name... The question is, you know, who is Ilhan Omar, and has she followed all of the laws as it relates to naturalization and immigration?
MELUGIN: And in the meantime, Omar's office is firing back. They're saying, quote, this is completely false. Ilhan Omar is her real name, end quote. Joining us now to talk about this, FOX News contributor Jonathan Turley, a law professor at George Washington University. Jonathan, good morning to you. Good to see you on this Friday. Thanks for joining us.
JONATHAN TURLEY, GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY LAW PROFESSOR: Thank you. Good morning.
MELUGIN: So, in fairness to Congresswoman Omar, she hasn't been charged with any crime yet, but a D.C. federal judge did sign off on this federal search warrant, and there has to be some element of probable cause in order to do that. If Ilhan Omar isn't her real name, and she's been using some kind of an alias, what's the significance behind that?
TURLEY: Well, it's very significant, and the fact is that you have to have your real name on passports, on filings for campaign, for official offices, for as a member of Congress. All of those types of filings come with a representation that they are true and accurate, and that can create potential legal problems. Now, obviously, we don't know what her name is in terms of her legal name, assuming she hasn't changed it.
Now, what's curious is she sat for an extended interview with MSNOW, and they rather nimbly avoided asking her any direct question on these outstanding questions that have been lingering for many years. Now, this name business is something relatively recent, but we have had years of controversy. And Representative Omar often gives interviews in which she just denounces these as racist or Islamophobic, but what she doesn't do is offer her own exculpatory evidence, her own direct responses, and we saw none of that in this recent interview.
AISHAH HASNIE, FOX NEWS WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Jonathan, really quickly a follow-up on that before we get to the was she married to her brother controversy. The president last night at that rally in Iowa said that if she truly that wasn't her real name and she was sworn into Congress to serve as a congresswoman, that she would have to resign because that would have basically been canceled out. Is that true?
TURLEY: Well, it could be true. You know, we have to look at, you know, the question is whether she could be stripped of her citizenship. That would obviously mean she couldn't be a member of Congress. But also, it's true that if she was elected on false pretenses, if she violated federal election law, that would also put her seat in danger. We just don't know. And we didn't get any closer after this interview.
And that's what's so concerning here is that Representative Omar has the ability to put many of these things to rest. She's had that ability for years, and she really has done nothing but give these denials without offering anything to put them to rest.
HASNIE: Okay. Really quickly, I want to go to this. This is the president yesterday telling me what he thinks of Ilhan Omar's curious answer, you can call it that, to whether or not she married her brother. Watch this. I think that she didn't just say no.
PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Well, if you ask me that same question about, let's say, my sister, I would say no. She said not to my knowledge. That tells you a lot right there. No, she's I've never been a big fan of hers. I'll be honest. Let's see how it all works out. But that statement tells you a lot.
HASNIE: Her team says, Jonathan, that she was being sarcastic. Some folks out there are saying, well, that was that's not a very attorney like lawyer like answer.
TURLEY: Yeah. The interview didn't strike me as a sarcastic answer, but I'm not going to put a whole great deal of emphasis on how she answered that. It was an odd answer to make. The real question is to ask her very clearly about some of these issues. You know, people have been asking for a DNA test for years. She could have easily offered DNA evidence and said, look, OK, here you go. Let's let's let's put this one to bed. But she did not. And so these these questions have been lingering.
But there's also lots of questions about the original filings for citizenship. Was she, in fact, 17, like her father stated, or was she 18 where she would have had to file for herself? There's questions as to her father's representations, who was a colonel in a rather brutal regime in Somalia.
And there was a there's a lot of concern that he did not reveal those facts when he himself became a citizen. So these are all snowballing. And the response from Representative Omar, rather baffling that she's really not addressing those specifics. And she certainly wasn't asked for specific answers in that recent interview.
MELUGIN: We don't know what the feds have. They haven't shown their cards yet. But The New York Times editorial board, they're not waiting to find out. We got to leave it here, Jonathan. But they just put out a an opinion piece today saying the Trump administration is similar to Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union for conducting this investigation. So we'll see where it goes. We'll see if that search warrant eventually gets unsealed. As always, great to see you. Thanks for taking the time with us today.
TURLEY: Thank you both.
Latest Videos

Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Hakeem Jeffries: Musk And Others Behind Trump Administration "Carnage" Will Answer For Their Actions
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News

Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House
Megyn Kelly: Republicans Are "No Longer Interested In The Trump Show" And Are "Over The Grift"
World News
Bill Maher To Critics Of Trump Dinner: "I Did It Again, B*tches. You Know What? F*ck You. I Like These Dinners"
Real Time
NC Mom Challenges School Board on LGBTQ Issues: Schools Are "Not a Counseling Session"
Campaign Ads
Gov. Sherrill: Get Rid Of The Electoral College, One Vote In New Jersey Is Worth 1/5 Of A Wyoming Vote
World News








