
Supreme Court Crisis Pregnancy Centers
Pro-lifers Should Emphasize Assistance for Pregnant Women
COMMENTARY
Published Sept. 14, 2022 • Read time: 4m
In the wake of the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade, pro-life advocates would be wise to acknowledge the country’s mood. Millions of Americans have lived their entire lives when their opinions on abortion had little impact on its legality. The Dobbs case changed that. For the first time in generations, the people’s views – and votes – will have a real impact on the law. But after half a century of court-imposed abortion on demand, many Americans are skeptical of sweeping limits and pro-life Republicans’ intentions.
Since the high court’s June decision, the importance of abortion as an issue in the upcoming midterm elections has increased significantly. An impressive 83% of Democrats and 53% of independent voters say the ruling would make them more likely to vote in November, according to a recent Wall Street Journal poll. For Republicans, the number was 31%.
Pro-lifers recently saw the impact of this trend in Kansas when voters overwhelmingly rejected a ballot initiative stating that there is no right to abortion in the state’s constitution. Democrats were able to frame the initiative as an effort by pro-life “extremists” to open the way to a total ban without exceptions such as for rape, incest, or to save the life of the mother. As a result, it failed.
Republicans need to get better when talking about abortion. It does not help when they run away from the issue – or worse, speak insensitively. If they are to avoid Democrats’ effectively using abortion as a political cudgel, Republicans must factor in the mindset created by half a century under Roe while also expressing compassion for the needs of women facing unexpected pregnancies.
This is certainly not a stretch. Over the past 50 years, the pro-life movement has built a network of some 3,000 pregnancy centers and maternity homes that provide crucial resources, typically at no charge and mostly using private donations. A growing number of states now fund Alternatives to Abortion programs. Texas’ program, for one, has a $100 million budget. But pro-life leaders holding and seeking elective office can and should do more to demonstrate their commitment to walk alongside women and families.
The options are numerous. For example, advocate for increasing the quality and availability of prenatal and postnatal care and for increasing assistance for single moms so that finances are not the driving force to opt for an abortion. Republicans should renew their offers to work across the aisle to make adoption an easier, more affordable, and more acceptable option for women who make that choice. Support programs to effectively reduce teen pregnancies. Propose therapeutic support for pregnant mothers struggling with drug addiction and treatment for children who suffer the consequences of that addiction.
These efforts will be much more effective if they are bipartisan. We would hope that at least some Democrats will sign on as co-sponsors to Sen. Marco Rubio’s Standing With Moms Act. The bill would create Life.gov, a federal clearinghouse for life-affirming resources, services, and information for pregnant and parenting mothers.
The Biden administration has already launched a website to promote its own point of view on abortion, so let’s try and even the playing field – as a way of at least offering a counter-narrative to Democrats such as Sen. Elizabeth Warren, who keeps dispensing vitriolic and hostile rhetoric about “cracking down” on pregnancy centers, which are popular with both pro-life and pro-choice Americans.
Republicans should also invite their Democratic colleagues to support Sen. Lindsey Graham’s compassionate, common-ground legislation to limit late-term abortions after 15 weeks, a point by which the science shows unborn children feel pain. Americans of every background – women and men, Republican, Democrat or independent – have voiced their approval of such policies and rejected the no-limits-until-birth agenda favored by so many leading Democrats.
Finding consensus on legislation that is achievable now does not in any way diminish pro-life Republicans’ core beliefs or their commitment to protecting the lives of all innocent unborn children, and they should be clear about this. But these efforts can and should also meaningfully address the issues that impact women facing unexpected pregnancies.
Roe did 50 years of damage to comity in American politics. Both parties should now employ empathy rather than the anger and animosity that has come to typify this debate. Republicans particularly should confirm their pro-life convictions while calling on their Democrat opponents to work with them to serve women, support real choices, and find solutions that ease suffering while saving lives. This is both morally right and politically smart.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






