US national security advisor H.R. McMaster said the West has "failed to impose sufficient costs" on Moscow for its aggressive behavior in remarks this week at the Atlantic Council Baltic Summit Dinner. These are reportedly McMaster's last public remarks before he leaves his post in the Trump administration.
McMaster spoke at a dinner hosted by the Atlantic Council for the leaders of the three Baltic states just hours after President Trump warned they "will find out soon" if he and Putin are going to "get along."
"Revisionist and repressive powers are attempting to undermine our values, our institutions, and our way of life," McMaster said to an audience including Baltic heads of state Kaljulaid, Vejonis, and Linkevicius, clearly referring to Russia. "A clear-eyed view of the brutal nature of repressive governments and ideologies is central to the President’s National Security Strategy."
"Since taking office, the President has repeatedly told the truth about these murderous regimes and oppressive doctrines," he also said.
“Russia employs sophisticated strategies deliberately designed to achieve objectives while falling below the target state’s threshold for a military response," he said, listing "infiltrating social media, spreading propaganda, weaponizing information, and using other forms of subversion and espionage."
"For too long, some nations have looked the other way in the face of these threats," he also said. "Russia brazenly and implausibly denies its actions and we have failed to impose sufficient costs. The Kremlin’s confidence is growing as its agents conduct their sustained campaigns to undermine our confidence in ourselves and in one another."
As prepared for delivery by LTG H.R. McMaster on April 3, 2018.
H.R. MCMASTER: Thank you General Jim Jones. And thank you for your work with Fred Kempe and Damon Wilson to organize this wonderful event tonight and host all of us for dinner.
President Kaljulaid, President Vejonis, Minister Linkevicius, distinguished guests and colleagues from the United States and our allies, it is an honor to address you this evening on the historic occasion of the U.S.-Baltic Centennial Summit.
I want to congratulate Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania once again on their 100th Anniversary of Independence.
We are thrilled to have the opportunity to celebrate this important milestone with you in Washington D.C., as we begin 100 years of Renewed Partnership among our nations.
As the President said earlier today, the United States has never ceased to recognize the independence of the Baltic Republics.
In 1940, when the Soviet Union invaded your nations, U.S. Acting Secretary of State Sumner Welles issued the famous Welles Declaration.
In that declaration, Welles confidently wrote that the American people opposed “any form of intervention on the part of one state, however powerful, in the domestic concerns of any other sovereign state, however weak.”
In the absence of respect for sovereignty, Welles continued, “the basis of modern civilization itself cannot be preserved.”
After Welles’ bold and historic declaration, through the decades of Soviet occupation that followed, the United States continued to affirm the sovereignty of the Baltic Republics.
Throughout that entire period, we confidently displayed the flags of independent Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania alongside our own.
Tonight, we celebrate this proud history at a critical moment for our nations and the world—critical because we are now engaged in a fundamental contest between our free and open societies and closed and repressive systems.
Revisionist and repressive powers are attempting to undermine our values, our institutions, and our way of life.
To preserve our sovereignty and prevail, we must renew the same confidence that inspired Welles and empowered the people of the Baltic nations through decades of Soviet occupation.
Armed with this confidence, we will triumph over new threats, including those posed by Russia’s increased aggression around the world.
Since the denial of service attacks against Estonia in 2007 and the invasion of Georgia in 2008, Russia has used old and new forms of aggression to undermine our open societies and the foundations of international peace and stability.
Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania have all been targeted by Russia’s so-called hybrid warfare, a pernicious form of aggression that combines political, economic, informational, and cyber assaults against sovereign nations.
Russia employs sophisticated strategies deliberately designed to achieve objectives and still fall below the target state’s threshold for a military response. Tactics include infiltrating social media, spreading propaganda, weaponizing information, and using other forms of subversion and espionage.
For too long, some nations have looked the other way in the face of these threats. Russia brazenly and implausibly denies its actions, and we have failed to impose sufficient costs.
The Kremlin’s confidence has grown, as its agents conduct their sustained campaigns to undermine our confidence in ourselves and in one another.
Last month, Russia used a military-grade nerve agent in an attempted murder that endangered the lives of over 130 people, including several children.
This attack was the first offensive use of a nerve agent in Europe since the Second World War. It was an assault on the United Kingdom’s sovereignty. And any use of chemical weapons by a state party is a clear violation of the Chemical Weapons Convention.
Russia has also conducted numerous cyber attacks against free nations. On March 15, the Trump administration released a report condemning the Russian government for malicious cyber intrusions that targeted U.S. critical infrastructure, including our energy sector.
And, we also know that Russia was behind the recent NotPetya cyberattack that caused billions of dollars in damage around the world.
Further, over the past year, Russia has conducted numerous intercepts of U.S., Allied, and partner aircraft and vessels, including in the Nordic-Baltic region, threatening freedom of navigation and unnecessarily endangering our personnel.
Mr. Putin may believe that he is winning in this new form of warfare. He may believe that his aggressive actions—in the parks of Salisbury, in cyberspace, in the air, and on the high seas—can undermine our confidence, our institutions, and our values.
Perhaps he believes that our free nations are weak and will not respond to his provocations.
He is wrong. Russian aggression is strengthening our resolve and our confidence.
We might all help Mr. Putin understand his grave error.
We might show him the beaches of Normandy, where lingering craters and bullet holes demonstrate the West’s will to sacrifice to preserve our freedom.
We might bring him to our concert halls and theaters, where the music and art of our people reveal our freedom to create, imagine, and to dream.
We might take him to our universities, where the free exchange of ideas among young men and women displays our freedom to learn, to speak, and to achieve our highest aims.
We might lead him to the stately buildings here in Washington, where inscriptions carved deep into stone proclaim that we are free to worship, equal under the law, and opposed to “every form of tyranny over the mind of man.”
We might introduce him to the people of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, who endured the devastation of the Second World War, decades of Soviet occupation and communism, and emerged proud, strong, sovereign, free, and prosperous. These are three of the most creative and innovative nations on Earth.
And, Mr. Putin might also then consider how the Russian people’s aspirations connect his own population to us, despite the Kremlin’s efforts to sow dissension abroad and repress freedom at home.
In the room tonight are elected officials, public servants, intellectuals, and leaders from the private sector. We converse without fearing that our opinions will lead to imprisonment, torture, or the death of a loved one.
We might ask others around the world a simple question: Would you rather be part of a small club of autocrats that might rotate their meetings between Moscow, Tehran, Damascus, Havana, Caracas, and Pyongyang?
Or, would you rather be part of our club of free peoples, who respect sovereignty, individual rights, and the rule of law?
I think our club is better.
It is time we expose those who glamorize and apologize in the service of communist, authoritarian, and repressive governments—regimes who torture, enslave, oppress, and murder their people.
Even in the United States and in other free nations, some journalists, academics, public officials, and saddest of all, young people, have developed and promulgated idealized views of tyrannical regimes.
A clear-eyed view of the brutal nature of repressive governments and ideologies is central to the President’s National Security Strategy.
Since taking office, the President has repeatedly told the truth about these murderous regimes and oppressive doctrines.
We heard this truth at the United Nations. We heard this truth in Riyadh. We heard this truth in Warsaw. We heard this truth in Seoul. And, we heard this truth in the seat of our democracy, as Mr. Ji Seong-ho raised his crutches high above the chamber in defiance.
The history of repression and authoritarianism is one of theft, torture, murder, and immense human suffering. And, it is not a phenomenon of the past.
We are presently engaged in competitions with repressive and authoritarian systems to defend our way of life—to preserve our free and open societies.
We must be confident. We must be active. We cannot be passive, and hope that others will defend our freedom.
The call to compete, to cooperate with others who share our principles, and to catalyze positive change is also central to the President’s National Security Strategy.
And, over the past year, the United States, our allies, and our partners have acted to defend our institutions and our liberty.
Last week, in response to Russia’s nerve agent attack, nations around the world—including the United States and the Baltic Republics—announced the coordinated expulsion of Russian officials from their countries. The United States helped catalyze a response by NATO and like-minded nations. The number of expelled officials is growing.
As of last Friday, nearly 30 countries had acted to expel more than 150 Russian officials. These actions represent the largest collective expulsion of Russian intelligence officers in history.
In the United States, President Trump ordered the removal of dozens of Russian intelligence officers, and the closure of the Russian consulate in Seattle. This action will also help protect our democratic institutions and processes, as these Russian officers orchestrate Russia’s sustained campaign of propaganda, disinformation, and political subversion.
In April of last year, the United States joined eight other nations in establishing the new European Center of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats to defend against new forms of aggression and subversion.
Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, nations that experienced the first blows from Russia in cyberspace and on social media, are all lending their invaluable expertise to the center.
The Trump administration also continues to impose sanctions and other penalties on Russian entities for targeting our cyber security, attacking our infrastructure, and otherwise infringing on the sovereign rights of the United States and our allies.
And, the United States is substantially increasing funding for the European Deterrence Initiative, or EDI, which provides billions of dollars to U.S. military and Allied forces in Europe to deter Russian aggression and prevent conflict.
So, we are acting, but we must recognize the need for all of us to do more to respond to and deter Russian aggression, especially in four critical areas.
First, we must compete across all arenas to counter so-called hybrid warfare—this new form of Soviet-era active measures and Maskirovka.
We must reform and integrate our military, political, economic, intelligence, law enforcement, and informational instruments of power to deter and defeat threats to our sovereignty.
Second, we must catalyze change. We must invest in our cyber infrastructure to ensure that we protect our data, innovation base, and infrastructure against espionage and theft. To deter adversaries, we must be prepared to impose a high cost in response to cyber aggression.
Third, we must all cooperate to share responsibility in these and other security efforts.
Even as the United States has committed nearly ten billion dollars to the EDI, many NATO countries, unlike the Baltic nations, are still not honoring the Wales Pledge to spend at least 2% of their GDP on defense.
Our mutual security requires everyone to contribute.
Finally, we must realize that all of our actions depend on preserving our strategic confidence—our will to advance our values and defend our way of life.
In that 1940 declaration that affirmed the Baltic nations’ independence, Sumner Welles was clear: “the people of the United States are opposed to predatory activities no matter whether they are carried on by the use of force or by the threat of force.”
Welles’ noble text forever bound Americans to our Baltic brothers and sisters in a partnership based on respect for sovereignty, freedom, and the rule of law.
As President Kaljulaid said earlier today, as long as we remain confident in these foundational principles, proud of our history, and faithful to our values, our nations will remain strong, secure, and free.
It has been a privilege to serve the United States for 34 years. Tonight, at my last public engagement, it is an honor to address an audience that fundamentally understands what is at stake for our free and open societies.
I am confident that freedom will triumph over repression. But, we must strengthen our resolve, cooperate to share responsibility, catalyze positive change, and compete effectively in new arenas.
The victory of free societies is not predestined. There is no arc of history—or so-called “end of history”—to ensure our success.
Brave men and women have fought for our liberty. They’ve fought with their pens, as Sumner Welles did in 1940. They’ve fought with their swords, as your brave independence fighters did in 1918.
And, today, the survival of our free and open societies and our way of life continues to depend on our confidence in our values, on our pride in our heritage, and on our will to defend our freedom.
Thank you for the privilege of being with you this evening. It has been a true honor. Thank you.
Event information: ATLANTIC COUNCIL
100 Years of US-Baltic Partnership
Reflecting on the Past and Looking to the Future
On April 3, US President Donald J. Trump and the Presidents of Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia met for the first time together in Washington, DC marking the historic US-Baltic Summit. Following the day’s meetings, this private high-level dinner serves as a celebration of the US-Baltic partnership on the centennial of the Baltic State’s independence. The discussion highlights the accomplishments and incredible transformation of the Baltic States from “captive nations” to frontline allies and as key members of the transatlantic community. The dinner includes keynote remarks from US National Security Advisor, Lieutenant General H.R. McMaster, as well as a moderated conversation with President Dalia Grybauskaitė of Lithuania, President Raimonds Vējonis of Latvia, and President Kersti Kaljulaid of Estonia.