Sean Trende: Both Parties Have Fractured Coalitions That Winning Elections Won't Fix
Last updated 1:43 PM ET
RCP senior elections analyst Sean Trende explained why the 2026 election results aren't predictive of 2028 or later, during a post-election panel hosted by AEI:
JOHN FORTIER: Let me ask Sean. Another thing we heard you say on election night was—and obviously we’re all saying this was a very big win—but you said something like, “This is the end of the Republican coalition.” Maybe you don’t remember saying this. What do you think about the Republican coalition going forward? What does this mean for that?
SEAN TRENDE: It was a long night.
CHRIS STIREWALT: Let me put it to you this way. Your point about 1974—you could say the same thing about 1946. There are other elections like this that were about something or someone that were not necessarily pointing to a reshaped coalition.
Your point I take absolutely: When you look at 2010, you can say, “Oh, this was a wave, but it was a wave that would deposit these shells up on the beach, and they were going to stay there.” Should we bother, Sean, thinking about—1946 maybe told us some stuff about what was going to happen with Dwight Eisenhower. Maybe it told us some stuff that was going to happen, but ultimately it wasn’t that useful. 1974 was ultimately not that useful about looking forward. Is there something that we’re going to learn from this?
SEAN TRENDE: I saw someone had a Substack that Trump is thinking of firing Pete Hegseth.
CHRIS STIREWALT: Soon-to-be senator from Tennessee Pete Hegseth.
SEAN TRENDE: But to get to blowing up the Republican coalition, Donald Trump has done something to offend almost every fragment of the coalition. He’s burned up a lot of his goodwill.
I’m thinking about this, and I’m like, “That’s actually a very difficult decision,” because if he fires Hegseth, it looks good to more establishment suburban Republicans. Put someone in there with more governing experience or whatever. But MAGA is going to lose its mind because MAGA still loves Pete Hegseth.
I follow some of the more MAGA accounts on Twitter, and someone, Data Republican, had posted two days ago, “Pete Hegseth is the most important person in Washington,” trying to figure out how to get a presidential run together for him. This is someone who has Elon Musk’s ear.
Because there’s been so much damage done, anything you—and these factions all have countervailing interests—anything you do is going to make someone really mad right now.
I don’t think generally that midterms or wave elections tell us much about the next presidential. What tells us something about how hard the next presidential is going to be is the fact that everyone in the Republican Party hates each other right now. It’s going to be really hard to get them together again.
...
SEAN TRENDE: I don’t think it’s going to be the Reagan party. That coalition is just gone.
My point is, I think it’s going to be tough. I keep hearing, “Well, this is a lot like 2006. We’ll get 2008.” I’m thinking to myself, “Well, I know why you got 2008, and I hope we avoid that financial collapse,” which helped.
The other thing is, whoever wins the presidency has to govern. It’s the “Hamilton” line, if you’ve seen the musical: “Winning’s easy. Governing’s harder.”
Whoever wins the presidency, congratulations. You get to deal with Social Security going bankrupt in 2032. It’s not the type of thing that you can just sit back and do nothing, because it’s a 20% across-the-board cut in everyone’s benefits if you do nothing. Good luck. King George saying to President John Adams, “Good luck.”
Because then you’re going to have a bunch of progressives like, “Well, this is easy. We’ll just remove the Social Security payroll tax cap. It’s super easy. We’ll just put a 12.5% flat tax on everyone making above $180,000 a year.”
Well, guess what? You have suburbanites as a core portion of your coalition. Now, a good chunk of those are going to see that 12.5% flat tax apply to them. Even then, now the top rate for millionaires in California is up to 66.5%, all in.
Well, there are a lot of other things that progressives are expecting out of a Democratic administration that have to be paid for. You’re going to take the top rate up to 80% when you figure in state and local taxes? Good luck.
It’s just hard.
Here is the full conversation from AEI's post-election panel titled: "Election Watch 2026: Where Are We, and Where Are We Headed?"
Latest Videos
In The News

Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Warner: "These Are Not Coordinated Cyber Attacks"--AI Improving Existing Systems Faster Than They Can Handle
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Halperin: Government's Cyberattack Response Is A "Dress Rehearsal And A Failure"
Special Report
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News
Megyn Kelly Reacts To Vance's Iran War Timeline: "They Don't Know How To Get Us Out Of There"
World News
Most Watched

Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House
Megyn Kelly: Republicans Are "No Longer Interested In The Trump Show" And Are "Over The Grift"
World News
Bill Maher To Critics Of Trump Dinner: "I Did It Again, B*tches. You Know What? F*ck You. I Like These Dinners"
Real Time
NC Mom Challenges School Board on LGBTQ Issues: Schools Are "Not a Counseling Session"
Campaign Ads
Gov. Sherrill: Get Rid Of The Electoral College, One Vote In New Jersey Is Worth 1/5 Of A Wyoming Vote
World News











