
Pentagon Hegseth
Hegseth Survives the Lame Duck With More Drama Ahead
Published Nov. 11, 2026 • Read time: 12m
The day began with a warning. Before any questions about impeachment were asked, the Pentagon chief was already on the warpath.
On Tuesday, reporters were waiting for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s first news conference in six months. A member of his security detail told reporters they would be physically removed if they did not maintain decorum and act professionally. The warning came after a year of tight restrictions at the Pentagon, where a right-leaning press corps has replaced most media outlets that gave up their credentials rather than accept Hegseth’s conditions for covering the Department of Defense.
Then Hegseth stepped up to the podium and went on the attack.
He didn’t sound like a man with a shaky hold on his job. President Trump was reportedly weighing whether to replace him after a midterm drubbing that Trump acknowledged had likely been impacted by the Iran war. Hegseth still seemed emboldened. He dismissed the articles of impeachment as a sham and called their author, outgoing GOP Rep. Thomas Massie, a “disgruntled, defeated congressman.”
“This is not patriotism,” he said. “This is sabotage.”
The charges, he argued, were policy disagreements, not crimes. He noted that no defense secretary had ever been impeached for carrying out lawful military operations. When asked about Democrats trying again once they hold the majority, he replied: “I’ll see you there.”
By evening, Republicans had come through for him, if narrowly. The House voted 211-204 to send Massie’s eight articles to the Judiciary Committee, effectively killing them. Massie was the only Republican who voted with Democrats.
Revenge politics
The feud goes back to May, when Hegseth traveled to Kentucky on the eve of the GOP primary to campaign against Massie. Massie lost to Trump-backed former Navy SEAL Ed Gallrein, who won the heavily Republican district in last week’s general election, and Hegseth rubbed it in Tuesday.
Massie was “ironically defeated by a Navy SEAL, I might add,” Hegseth jabbed while arguing that he was happy to “litigate” Trump’s “America first agenda.” In a video released Thursday, after Massie announced his plans, Hegseth had vowed to stay and fight. “We don’t back down,” he vowed.
It was Massie’s second run at Hegseth. In September, the congressman read a 34-page impeachment resolution on the House floor, and GOP leaders avoided a vote by sending members home until after the election. After Democrats swept the midterms, Massie offered one way out. “There is one contingency in which I won’t reintroduce the articles of impeachment,” he wrote. “Hegseth resigns.”
Hegseth stayed, and Massie refiled Monday. “We’re not indicting him for being bad at his job,” Massie said.
Massie predicted that “several” Republicans would join him. All declined, including Reps. French Hill of Arkansas and James Comer of Kentucky, who had sounded open to the idea beforehand. Speaker Mike Johnson had vowed to defeat the resolution “one way or the other.” Once Trump signaled strong backing for Hegseth, GOP lawmakers fell in line, at least for now.
Tuesday’s vote protected Hegseth for the time being. It didn’t settle whether Trump will keep him. The obvious precedent is 2006. President George W. Bush announced Donald Rumsfeld’s resignation the day after Republicans lost Congress amid anger over the Iraq War. Trump has so far leaned the other way, at least publicly.
Over the past week, the president has campaigned for his defense secretary. On Monday night, Trump called Massie a “loser” on Truth Social and described Hegseth as “perhaps the most popular and successful military official in the country.” By Tuesday morning, he was grading the news conference: Hegseth gets an “‘A’ PLUS, PLUS, PLUS” for his defense, he wrote. After the vote, Trump declared Hegseth exonerated.
“Every single Republican, except Thomas Massie, a major LOSER, voted in favor of Pete,” he wrote.
Previous presidents would have dropped Hegseth by now, Keith Whittington, a Yale Law School constitutional scholar who studies impeachment, told RealClearPolitics.
“Most presidents would say, ‘Okay, I don’t need the headache of a serious impeachment effort aimed at my secretary of defense. Why don’t we just get rid of the secretary of defense and cut that off and move on?’” Whittington said in an interview.
But Trump is not most presidents, he said. He may decide that the fight serves his political interest, and Hegseth seems happy to take it on.
Privately, the picture looks less settled. CBS News reported that Trump has been asking advisers whether Hegseth should stay. The morning after the election, Vice President JD Vance wrote that the war was the reason Republicans lost. Outgoing GOP Sen. Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who has repeatedly bucked the administration, has urged Trump to replace Hegseth.
Trump can brush off critics he considers disloyal, but he can’t disregard the calendar. The easiest moment to replace Hegseth is now, while Republicans still control the Senate, although even then a successor might not be confirmed before the year ends. If Trump waits until January, any nominee faces a Democratic Senate, though Whittington noted that Trump has relied heavily on designating “acting” appointees. If he keeps Hegseth, a Democratic House will have the votes to impeach him on its own. Conviction would still take 67 Senate votes, far more than Democrats will have.
Even so, Democrats are eager to rake Hegseth over the coals, and the new Congress will usher in two years in which he runs a war while lawmakers investigate him.
In a video posted on X last month, Hakeem Jeffries, the presumptive next House speaker, said Democrats would “run Pete Hegseth out of town.” Rep. Pat Ryan of New York, an Army veteran, was blunter: “Hegseth and crew better buckle up and lawyer up.”
Rep. Adam Smith, a Washington state Democrat in line to chair the House Armed Services Committee, plans to examine military operations, politicization of the armed forces and potential corruption in Pentagon contracting. Smith says he has had every defense secretary’s cellphone number for nearly 16 years, but “Hegseth does not speak to me.”
Former aides expect early hearings and subpoenas if the Pentagon doesn’t cooperate. Testimony under oath could cover the boat strikes, the Tomahawk missile that preliminary military investigations say hit an Iranian elementary school on the war’s first day, the ouster of senior officers, and the cost of a war now more than eight months old. Democrats will also write the Pentagon’s budget, including a record $1.5 trillion request.
The Democrats’ dilemma
For Jeffries and Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer, Hegseth is an easy target, but it doesn’t come without risk.
For most of the 2026 midterm campaign season, Jeffries steered his colleagues and Democratic candidates away from theatrical moves against Trump and instead tried to keep the focus on economic issues. But that changed after the election – he now faces a potential battle for the speaker post with so many new progressives elected to the House. In April, “Fox News Sunday” asked him whether impeaching Trump would be his top priority, and he answered, “Of course not!” But after last week’s blue wave Jeffries tacked with the prevailing winds, saying Sunday he was a “hard yes” on impeaching Hegseth. Schumer, the more vulnerable of the two leaders with several incoming senators saying they won’t back him for majority leader, went further on the Senate floor Monday.
“The Senate needs to put Pete Hegseth on trial, so we can remove him for his catastrophic failure in Iran,” said Schumer, who is facing his own leadership challenges from his left flank.
Tuesday showed the limits of that approach. Party leaders backed the effort but didn’t whip votes for it, according to Democratic Caucus chair Pete Aguilar. Eleven Democrats didn’t even show up to vote. As for what may happen in 2027, it might be worth noting that many of the incoming members who delivered the new majority come from battleground districts and won by promising lower prices, not impeachment. A Senate trial would also take floor time Democrats want for affordability and health care.
Republicans are ready to cite Schumer’s own record. “We’ll just dismiss it like Schumer dismissed the Mayorkas one,” said Sen. Ron Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican and Trump ally.
The law: War Powers vs. Commander in Chief
Three of Massie’s impeachment articles concern Iran: helping start the war without authorization, continuing it despite congressional demands, and missing statutory deadlines to withdraw forces. They rest on the 1973 War Powers Resolution, which generally requires troops to be withdrawn within 60 days unless Congress authorizes the fighting.
Massie says the war has gone on for 256 days without authorization, and the House passed resolutions in June and July directing Trump to end it. He also accuses the Pentagon of an “absurd ruse” to reset the 60-day clock by treating the fighting as two wars divided by a short ceasefire.
The administration argues that the president’s power as commander in chief is enough. It’s an argument that has been made successfully, going back decades. Article I of the U.S. Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war; Article II makes the president commander in chief. Congress passed the War Powers Resolution over Richard Nixon’s veto, and presidents of both parties have questioned its constitutionality ever since. They have often avoided the deadline by defining “hostilities” narrowly, as the Obama administration did in Libya in 2011. The Supreme Court’s 1983 INS v. Chadha decision also cast doubt on Congress’ power to order a withdrawal without the president’s signature.
Frank Bowman, a University of Missouri law professor emeritus and impeachment scholar, rejects the idea that this precedent gives Hegseth cover. The administration never got congressional approval after 60 days, he said, and never asked for the 30-day extension the law allows.
“Unless one accepts that [the law is unconstitutional], and I don’t, and it’s certainly never been held to be unconstitutional, then he’s plainly in violation of the act, and Hegseth, as his deputy, is in violation of it as well,” Bowman said. “So, I think that’s a really lousy defense.”
Whittington is more skeptical of the statute and warned that a case built on it would lose many conservatives. He expects the debate to end up where it always does: the scope of the president’s Article II powers.
Courts have usually stayed out, treating war powers disputes as political questions. That’s why impeachment matters in this case. It’s the one place Congress decides the question itself, and the Constitution never defines “high crimes and misdemeanors.”
Hegseth’s fallback is that he carried out the president’s orders. Massie’s articles argue that knowingly carrying out unlawful orders is itself a violation. But Republican strategists privately note the weak spot: Trump is commander in chief, and the decision to attack was ultimately his. Impeaching Hegseth would put the war on trial without putting the president on trial. For Democrats that’s the appeal. But it may be seen as too cute.
Whittington said that framing could backfire by pushing the debate straight back to Trump.
“If your real target is Trump, then go after Trump. If your real target is Hegseth, then you want to design it in a way that can cut Hegseth loose from Trump,” he said. In his view, a stronger case would focus on decisions Hegseth made himself, such as how drug boat strikes were carried out.
The other articles go beyond Iran. They cover strikes on the suspected drug boats, failures to protect civilians, the January operation that captured Venezuela’s Nicolás Maduro, the 2025 campaign against the Houthis in Yemen, and retaliation against Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly.
Belknap and Mayorkas
If impeached, Hegseth would be only the third Cabinet secretary in American history to face that fate. Neither of the first two was removed.
William W. Belknap was President Ulysses S. Grant’s secretary of war, the same title Hegseth now uses. In 1876 Belknap was caught taking kickbacks from a lucrative military trading post at Fort Sill. He resigned hours before the House vote, and the House impeached him anyway, unanimously. A majority of senators voted to convict, but the vote fell short of two-thirds. Most of those who voted to acquit said they did so only because he was already out of office.
The Mayorkas example is more timely. In February 2024, House Republicans impeached Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, 214-213, over the surge of migrants at the southern border. His defenders, including several Republicans who voted no, argued that a policy dispute was being presented as a crime. The Senate, led by Schumer, agreed and threw out both articles as unconstitutional without a trial, the first time it had ever done so.
Now the roles are reversed. When Hegseth calls the charges policy disagreements, he is repeating the Democrats’ defense of Mayorkas. Rep. Nick LaLota of New York, who voted to impeach Mayorkas, said Tuesday he didn’t believe Hegseth had committed an impeachable offense.
Massie and the Democrats say the two cases are different in kind. Mayorkas was accused of enforcing the law badly. Hegseth is accused of breaking specific laws: carrying on a war past the 60-day limit, ignoring House votes to end it, and ordering lethal strikes without legal authority.
Professor Bowman testified during the Mayorkas case that the charges did not amount to high crimes. He sees Hegseth differently.
“It [has], at least to this point, not been thought to be impeachable to simply competently carry out policies of the president with which the opposing party happens to disagree, which was really what happened in Mayorkas,” he said. “What’s different about Hegseth is that he’s not being charged simply with competently carrying out otherwise legal, constitutional policies.”
Tuesday’s resolution is dead, but the effort isn’t over. Democrats can revive it when the new Congress convenes Jan. 3.
Massie won’t be there to see it, but at least some of the questions he raised will be. If Trump continues to stand by Hegseth despite the steady drumbeat of negative headlines, Jeffries will face pressure to bring impeachment to the floor. Senate Democrats will have to decide whether they want an early stretch of their new majority taken up by a war trial instead of efforts to show real Democratic results when it comes to gas and grocery prices.
Even some of Hegseth’s fellow Republicans doubt he can outlast the new Congress. Sen. Ted Cruz, speaking on his podcast the day before the House shelved Massie’s articles, laid out only three ways this could end.
“Either Hegseth is going to step down, either he will resign voluntarily, or Trump will fire him,” Cruz said. “Or, if that does not happen, I think it is extremely likely, if not certain, that the House will impeach him because, on the face of it, the votes are there.”
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
Contributing to RealClear Politics through the RealClear Media Foundation supports essential initiatives that drive meaningful change.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






