
Mideast Wars Three Years
Dara Horn's Wise Counsel on Countering Antisemitism
Published Nov. 8, 2026 • Read time: 9m
The surge in antisemitism in America following Iran-backed Hamas’ Oct. 7, 2023, massacre in southern Israel – in which the jihadists killed 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251, mostly civilians – shocked American Jews.
The outpouring of antisemitic opinion and conduct at the nation’s leading colleges and universities – supposed bastions of liberal education – following the worst attack on Jews since the Holocaust intensified the shock.
In itself, criticism of Israel is not antisemitism or, to speak plainly, hatred of Jews. Criticizing Israel based on standards applied to no other country does express antisemitism.
Double standards drive the demand that Israel, alone among nation-states, justify its right to exist. Double standards inform the wildly disproportionate time and energy that international institutions, starting with the United Nations Human Rights Council, devote to recklessly accusing Israel of war crimes while ignoring the manifest war crimes other countries perpetrate. And double standards undergird the common accusation that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. The Jewish state embraces the laws of war while defending itself against Hamas, which openly proclaims its genocidal intentions and flagrantly violates the laws of war by slaughtering Israeli civilians and by militarizing its own urban areas to use Palestinian civilians as human shields.
Before the blood dried in Israeli communities along the country’s Gaza border, many American students and some professors at mainly but not exclusively selective colleges and universities reveled in the jihadists’ barbarous assault. Left-wing social justice warriors and Islamists cheered on Hamas’ savagery as if Israelis deserved it, as if slaughter, rape, maiming, and mutilation could ever be just. They chanted their hopes that those same jihadists and their Iran-backed network of Islamist militias would conquer the entire land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea – that is, wipe out Israel. And they called for globalizing the intifada, which would mean expanding the Islamists’ war of elimination against the Jewish state to the United States and the West.
Popular right-wing commentators led by Tucker Carlson sprang into action, too. Carlson contended that the United States lacks shared interests with Israel, which is a legitimate if mistaken political view. He also maintained falsely that Israel connives to drag America into misbegotten wars, that the Jewish state deliberately bombs Christian churches in Gaza, and that Christian Zionists exhibit a “brain virus” (a statement for which he later expressed regret). These claims amplify antisemitic tropes.
Amid the vicious rhetoric directed at Israel after October 7, violence against Jews in the United States skyrocketed. In the following year, the Anti-Defamation League reported, upwards of 10,000 antisemitic incidents occurred in the United States – double the previous year’s total. These included harassment and intimidation on campuses, more than 1,000 bomb threats against Jewish institutions, and more than 150 physical assaults across the country. According to FBI data, in 2025 – the third-highest year on record for anti-Jewish hate crimes, after 2024 and 2023 – 63% of religiously motivated hate crimes in America targeted Jews, who represent about 2% of the U.S. population.
Since October 7, antisemitism has also risen substantially in Argentina, Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, and Germany. In 2025, Germany recorded nearly 70 antisemitic incidents for every 1,000 Jewish residents, the highest rate among the seven countries tracked by the J7, a task force of major Jewish organizations. Much of the antisemitism could be traced to Islamists, the hard left, and hard right-wing nationalists.
Countering antisemitism confronts a dilemma.
The preferred approach consists in educating about the scourge’s long and sordid history. Early Christianity ascribed collective guilt to Jews for the crime of deicide. Medieval Europe excluded Jews from crafts, trades, and professions while whipping up deadly enmity by promulgating the blood libel that Jews murdered Christian children and used their blood to make Passover matzo. In the 18th and 19th centuries, European nationalism fomented the suspicion that Jews were disloyal outsiders. And in the 20th century, Adolf Hitler and the Nazis institutionalized racial antisemitism, vilifying Jews as a distinct and parasitic race. To protect the Aryan master race or nation and in pursuit of world domination, the Nazis exterminated 6 million Jews.
Amazon
But today the great American grievance sweepstakes presents a crowded field. Numerous minorities jockey for position, competing for public sympathy, preferential treatment, and government largesse. From K-12 schools to college and graduate and professional education, courses highlighting tales of oppressor and oppressed overload the curriculum and saturate young citizens’ sensibilities.
Consequently, countering antisemitism by showing that Jews, too, are victims faces a steep uphill struggle.
In her outstanding book, “The Final Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living,” Dara Horn offers a compelling alternative. Education remains indispensable, but she recommends shifting attention from the evils of antisemitism to the Jewish people’s inspiring history. Lesson plans and courses should focus on how Jews around the world have for thousands of years studied and prayed, rejoiced and mourned, suffused daily life with righteousness, built families and communities of love and devotion, and steadfastly preserved and courageously transmitted their sacred heritage. Even absent antisemitism, liberal education in America ought to highlight the Jewish tradition because the Hebrew Bible represents a root of the American experiment in ordered liberty and of Western civilization.
Horn is a proud Jew, a married mother of four, a holder of a Harvard B.A. and Ph.D., a scholar of Hebrew and Yiddish literature, and an award-winning novelist and essayist. She brings to her task keen appreciation of the Jewish tradition, extensive experience as a public speaker, and labors in the trenches as a disgruntled member of the ineffectual Antisemitism Advisory Group assembled by then-Harvard University President Claudine Gay. In 2024 Horn founded, and serves as president of, The Tell Institute, a nonprofit that counters antisemitism by teaching “about Jewish civilization, the dynamics of antisemitism for over 2,200 years, and the ideas that shape free pluralistic societies.” Her love of the Jewish people and of America, ability to confront harsh realities while holding firm to common-sense decency and the imperatives of justice, and mordant sense of humor serve her well in exploring the West’s oldest hatred and fashioning proposals for containing it.
In her post-October 7 lectures and conversations throughout the nation, Horn has encountered many Jews who have been compelled to reconsider their cherished belief that the American experiment is different. Across the centuries, majority populations eventually turned on flourishing Jewish communities – in Berlin, Warsaw, Madrid, Moscow, Odessa, Baghdad, and elsewhere – harassing, hounding, and expelling them. But American Jews embraced the belief that fair and equal treatment was built into the structure of American government and woven into the spirit of the nation. As President George Washington affirmed in his celebrated 1790 letter “To the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, Rhode Island,” other countries offered toleration grudgingly if at all, while America, whose founding principles repudiated bigotry, welcomed Jews as fellow citizens.
American education’s skewed priorities and deep-seated prejudices obstruct the adoption of Horn’s proposals to counter antisemitism by incorporating the Jewish tradition and the principles of American pluralism into the nation’s curricula. According to Horn, her alma mater, which sets the tone for American education, reinforces the system’s vices.
It wasn’t always so.
During her Harvard undergraduate years in the late 1990s, Horn found classmates “who responded to thorny problems, big and small, not by complaining about them, but by earnestly trying to solve them.”
In 2024, however, Horn encountered a different Harvard. “In this place where I’d once encountered so many people who were excited and curious about figuring out real solutions to real problems, mobs of students were now eagerly chanting, ‘There is only one solution: intifada revolution!’” she writes. “Despite Harvard’s bottomless resources and its ability to handpick whomever it wanted to populate its campus, there was now only one solution, which was that I had to walk across campus with an armed guard.”
Horn readily affirms the legitimacy of protesting Israel’s actions. But “Harvard College students celebrating Hamas’s massacre of Israelis” (emphasis in original) were another matter. “Students,” one administrator told her in understated words echoed by Harvard President Alan Garber, “are just unprepared to engage with ideas.” Among other deficiencies, the administrator stressed, students arrive at Harvard gripped by an ideology that elevates “lived experience” above reasoned argument.
Horn was aghast:
Why, I wondered, would Harvard students hold such a belief? Was it not evident that any “lived experience” could be contradicted by billions of other equally lived experiences, or even different interpretations of the same experience? Wouldn’t this observation emerge from, say, reading more than one book? Come to think of it, wasn’t it clear even from reading a single book? Wasn’t this the most basic concept of literature and narrative beyond characters, setting, and plot: the unreliable narrator? Did these superstar students not understand how storytelling and rhetoric worked? Did they just believe whatever they were told, by whoever happened to tell them first?
Countering antisemitism in America is inseparable from reclaiming liberal education in America. American colleges and universities often infantilize students by encouraging them to believe that their interpretation of their experience is infallible – if they belong to select minorities. American colleges and universities often turn students against their country by enforcing the view that the United States amounts to little more than the sum of its iniquities. And American colleges and universities often dispose students to embrace ideological fads and fashions by dogmatically insisting that reason and evidence are social constructs contrived by oppressors to keep the oppressed in their place. Such pedagogical malpractice does more than deprive students of a liberal education. Infantilization, scorn for America, and the disposition to embrace ideological fads and fashions nourish intolerance and bigotry.
The renewal of liberal education at the nation’s colleges and universities would provide a remedy to all forms of hatred, including Western civilization’s oldest.
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
Contributing to RealClear Politics through the RealClear Media Foundation supports essential initiatives that drive meaningful change.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






