Interview with Secretary Panetta & Gen. Dempsey
Published Feb. 3, 2013 • Read time: 18m
CROWLEY: Joining me now Leon Panetta, secretary of defense, and General Martin Dempsey who of course is chairman of the joint chiefs of staff.
Gentlemen, thank you both for being here.
We had some very interesting hearings on Thursday for your replacement. I want to play you just a little from those hearings.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
HAGEL: As to the Iranian red line, Persian Gulf, some of the Iranian questions you asked. I support the president's strong position on containment.
By the way, I've just been handed a note that I misspoke. We don't have a position on containment.
REP. CARL LEVIN, (D) MICHIGAN: Just to make sure your correction is clear we do have a position on containment, which is that we do not favor containment.
HAGEL: We do not favor containment.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
CROWLEY: I'm sure you've seen the criticism of the nominee for your new job, and your old job and your new boss. How did you think Mr. Hagel did?
PANETTA: Well, you know, these hearings are tough, and especially when everybody is targeting you. I guess I was really disappointed that a lot of that hearing focused on the past as opposed to the challenges that a secretary of defense has to confront.
CROWLEY: You know Capitol Hill, though, if you got a record? I mean, what else do you move on?
PANETTA: No, I understand. But you also ought to talk about what a secretary of defense is going to have to face -- war on Afghanistan. We've got sequester problems and budget problems. We got serious problems in dealing with the challenges in terms of the Middle East on cyber. I mean, there are a number of areas that simply were not that well covered that deal with what a secretary of defense has to do and that concerned me.
CROWLEY: But nothing concerned -- this will be -- this man will be your new boss replacing Secretary Panetta. Is there anything in that hearing that concerned you? There are a lot of folks who thought he just doesn't seem prepared?
DEMPSEY: No, I had the same reaction Secretary Panetta had, which was I was more surprised about what wasn't discussed than what was. And in my context with the senator, Senator Hagel, and his preparations, I found him to be very thoughtful and very well prepared and very interested. And so if he's confirmed, I'm sure that we'll establish a very close working relationship.
CROWLEY: So you all thought he seemed well prepared?
PANETTA: I think -- I know Chuck Hagel. And I think he's got good experience with regards to public service. He understands the issues of the Defense Department. I think he'll be a great secretary of defense.
CROWLEY: I'm going to ask you about signals in Washington. General Michael Hayden, who I think probably both of you know is a former director of the CIA, was talking about incoming Secretary of State John Kerry, incoming if he is confirmed Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel and here is what he had to say about the new team.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
MICHAEL HAYDEN, FRM. DIR. CIA: I think the new team thinks more like the president thinks when it comes to foreign policy. This is going to be a team that might not push back as much with regard to cuts or withdrawals or smaller footprints or reluctance to have big footprints into new areas.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
CROWLEY: So, I want you to tell me what your reaction is to that. Do you see a new team coming in with a different attitude toward the president's policies?
PANETTA: No, I really don't. I mean, after all, the president is the person who makes policy with regards to foreign affairs and defense policy.
CROWLEY: Sure. But this was about pushback. And the suggestion, I think, is that you all do push back and this team might not.
PANETTA: Well, I've got to tell you, anybody who knows John Kerry and anybody who knows Chuck Hagel, and I've been with him in meetings and I've been with them in conferences, and I've been with then on issue debates, and they push back. Believe me, they push back on the issues. And I think that in the situation room, everybody has to give their honest views. And I think they won't hesitate to give their honest views.
CROWLEY: One of the things where there might be pushback, where we sort of looking ahead, is we're now hearing from senior types in the White House that they might not want any troops to remain in Afghanistan after 2014. Right now, as you're looking at the situation, and you trained troops in Afghanistan, for both of you, but general since you trained troops over there, we never hear very good reports. I think the last sort of official one we saw was that one Afghan battalion of all of them was able to work without U.S. ground or air support.
Are Afghan troops and is Afghan security, including the police, going to be ready in 2014 to have no U.S. support? DEMPSEY: Well first of all, I've never heard anyone suggest -- no one has ever suggested zero to me. And I think that the ultimate number will be based on the mission and how deeply we want to be involved with their continued development, and also what they want. I mean, literally what the sovereign nation of Afghanistan wants.
John Allen has got a very well thought out campaign plan. As we look at the different options for both presence after '14 and how we get from here to '14. We're basing it on keeping three things in equilibrium. The campaign objectives which are very laid out in Chicago and Lisbon with our NATO allies. Retrograde, we have got a pretty significant challenge of getting ourselves out of Afghanistan in terms of equipment and force protection. And we'll keep those three things in equilibrium.
CROWLEY: 66,000 troops there now. What sounds to you all like a reasonable number at the end of 2014? What should the Afghan government be able to do with how many U.S. troops?
PANETTA: Well, look, the most important thing that's happened is that the Afghan army has become operational. They have developed their ability to provide security. We couldn't make a transition in the areas that need add transition, which involves over 75 percent of the Afghan population right now is in under Afghan control and under Afghan security.
We couldn't do that if there weren't an Afghan army that was becoming much more capable of doing their job.
If we maintain a 352,000 number, which is what we're trying to achieve, if we maintain that...
CROWLEY: For their forces.
PANETTA: And they become good, that is going to determine, then, the level of enduring presence that we will have once we reach the end of 2014.
CROWLEY: What's your feel for it now?
DEMPSEY: Well, my feel for it now is that the missions that we've accepted post '14 with the Afghan government and our NATO allies, which largely relate to the counter-terror mission, continuing to keep pressure on transnational global terrorism as well as the continued development of the Afghan security forces. My instinct that their development is moving at a pace and their acceptance of responsibility is moving at a pace that our numbers after '14 can be modest.
CROWLEY: What's that? Can you give me a number? What's modest?
DEMPSEY: No, I can't give you a number, because first of all, I'm not going to announce a number on CNN on Sunday afternoon.
CROWLEY: Why not?
DEMPSEY: Because I don't know the number. CROWLEY: Sounds reasonable to me.
DEMPSEY: No, I really don't.
Look, we're in the business of negotiating with ourselves. And John Allen, the mission and how best to accomplish it, trying to look two years into the future. We really don't have a number selected yet.
(END VIDEOTAPE)
CROWLEY: When we return, lingering questions about the attack in Benghazi.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
DEMPSEY: You can't be every place. And I might remind you, it was 9/11 elsewhere in the world not just in Libya.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
CROWLEY: And we are back with Secretary Panetta and General Dempsey.
Again, thank you, gentlemen, for being here. Let me ask you about Benghazi. First, you'll be testifying on Capitol Hill before you leave office?
PANETTA: We're working on that right now. Obviously they have asked us to testify and we're happy to do that. So we probably will have that opportunity.
CROWLEY: So one of the outstanding questions out there has been, why wasn't there someone to come help? Why didn't you -- we know that you did move ships closer. We know that the air base in Sicily, you brought in a strike force. Why didn't you -- in a seven-hour timeframe that this took place, why couldn't the strike force have said, even if you didn't know what was going on, just get closer, go as though you're going to go there and we'll let you know what we find out?
PANETTA: Because very frankly, intelligence did not provide any warning that this, in fact, was going to happen. I mean, we deployed. We knew there were problems there. We moved forces into place where we could deploy them quickly if we had to. They were ready to go.
But very frankly by the time we got the information as to what, in fact, was taking place there, just distance alone made it very difficult to respond quickly. That's just the nature of dealing with the Middle East.
CROWLEY: But when did you learn, if this was a seven-hour battle, we don't know when people died, and there when the ambassador died, but if this was a seven-hour battle, a U.S. strike force couldn't have gotten there in time to be of some service?
DEMPSEY: You know, it wasn't a seven-hour battle. It was two 20-minute battles separated by about six hours. The idea that this was one continuous event is just incorrect.
And the nearest -- for example, the nearest aircraft -- armed aircraft, happened to be in Djibouti, the distance from Djibouti to Benghazi is the distance from Washington, D.C., to Los Angeles.
There is some significant physics involved. And the time available, given the intelligence available, I have great confidence in reporting to the American people that we were appropriately responsive given what we knew at the time.
PANETTA: Candy, the answer to these things -- and, you know, we've learned some lessons, obviously, from what happened in Benghazi. But the answer is you have to develop host country capability there. Every embassy we have, the host country has to provide good security.
CROWLEY: But you knew Libya was really not capable at that point?
PANETTA: No, I understand that. But you have to be able to rely in part on their capability to provide security. Secondly, you've also got to be able to harden the facility so that, you know, it is well-protected. And thirdly, if none of that works, then obviously you've got to have a response team that's ready to respond.
But to do that, you've got to have intelligence that tells you this is trouble. There's a risk here. We can't -- this is not...
CROWLEY: You had an ambassador telling people that it was trouble.
PANETTA: This is not 911. You cannot just simply call and expect within two minutes to have a team in place. It takes time. That's the nature of it. Our people are there. They are in position to move, but we've got to have good intelligence that gives us a heads up that something is going to happen.
CROWLEY: The base in Italy is closer -- the air base in Italy would have been a closer team to send, a strike force, you know, right? So, again, why wouldn't you -- knowing that there had been an attack, not knowing how long it was going to go on, why wouldn't you, say, get on a helicopter, get on a plane, get on -- you know, I mean, you know, and I realize these are sort of basic questions for you. But I think people are looking and saying, couldn't they have sent something there?
DEMPSEY: Well, I'm sure we'll have a chance to answer these exact questions on Thursday when we testify. But the fact is we did exactly what you said. As soon as we knew something happened, the secretary gave us vocal instructions to begin moving forces to a higher alert posture and to make them with aircraft necessary to move them, and then, including the transit time to give him an estimate of how quickly we could have something there. We did exactly what you just said. But you can't be every place. And I might remind you it was 9/11 elsewhere in the world, not just in Libya.
CROWLEY: Sure. Would you agree that the consulate in Benghazi was woefully under-protected?
PANETTA: I think the secretary of state has indicated that they should have had more security there.
CROWLEY: Would you do anything different militarily knowing now what you know about what went on?
DEMPSEY: Well, we actually have. We have taken the Accountability Review Board results. We've partnered with the secretary of state in a review of embassy security around the -- especially around that part of the world, and we are taking steps.
CROWLEY: And would you now though in hindsight say we should have, could have, would have sent this group there, we might have been able to do some good if we had done X, Y, or Z?
PANETTA: No.
CROWLEY: So nothing, you would change nothing?
PANETTA: Look, and you know, I think in these situations, you have got to look at what we were facing, what we knew, what intelligence we had in order to respond. Admittedly, better intelligence about what was taking place there would have given us a heads up.
CROWLEY: Why isn't there better intelligence? It's not like the intelligence community is underfunded. And it seems like any time we come into something where it has been a tragedy, it's always the intelligence community. You've been there.
PANETTA: Yes, I know. I was director of the CIA.
CROWLEY: Yes, exactly.
PANETTA: I say this...
CROWLEY: So it seems like it's always the CIA's fault.
PANETTA: I say this without, you know, demeaning our efforts at intelligence, but the fact is we -- you know, there are areas in the Middle East where we do not have the kind of intelligence we should have in order to give us a heads up about these kinds of attacks. That's a reality. We've got to do better at that.
DEMPSEY: And you're discounting the number of things we do avoid with good intel.
CROWLEY: Well, obviously for a lot of reasons we don't always hear about those. So let me ask you about the Israeli strike deep into Syria. Did you know about that in Advance? And did anyone say bad idea, good idea? Or was it just -- I know that you were meeting with the head of the Israeli intelligence forces. Were you all informed?
PANETTA: I'm not going to discuss the details of that, of what happened or didn't happen there. What I will say is this, that we are concerned about the danger of sophisticated weapons like SA-17s and CBW, chemical and biological weapons, falling into the hands of terrorists. That is something we're concerned about.
And we do planning every day to try to make sure that we're in a position where we can make sure that doesn't happen.
DEMPSEY: The Israeli officer about whom you speak was in my office in preparation for a meeting with my counterpart from Israel, Lieutenant General Benny Gantz, and not in any way related to that incident that was reported.
CROWLEY: OK. But you all can't tell what -- I mean, I'm assuming if you weren't informed you would tell me, so...
DEMPSEY: Yes, we're not...
(CROSSTALK)
CROWLEY: ... the reverse is true, OK.
So you talked about the groundwork being laid. I mean, everyone talks about how Assad surely will fall at some point. And when that happens, how does the U.S. make sure that al Qaeda, or other terrorist organizations that might be loosely affiliated, don't get a hold of chemical weapons, don't begin to snap up all the weapons that are already there, as what happened in Libya in some cases? What is that groundwork like?
DEMPSEY: Well, I think what you'd want to -- what you'd expect us to be doing is teaming, collaborating, planning with our partners in the region. We have a NATO partner in the north in Turkey. We have a very strong partner in Jordan. And, of course, you mentioned Israel to the west. All of whom share common interests in making sure that these spillover effects don't affect them.
And that's what we're doing. We're planning. We've got options for any number of military contingencies. And we're maintaining both a deterrent and a preparedness posture.
CROWLEY: Do the military contingencies include U.S. forces or is there something that you see as a regional thing, securing the ground, as it were, in Syria?
DEMPSEY: Well, we are better when we operate with partners, especially in that part of the world. But of course any option we would probably be asked to provide at least the capabilities, no one else has. And we have some pretty extraordinary capabilities. CROWLEY: And intelligence gathering certainly would be one of them. But what about the use of force? Or the use of forces, I guess, at that point.
PANETTA: You know, a lot depends on what the situation is.
PANETTA: If Assad suddenly comes down, is it a permissive situation where there's a kind of peaceful transition to another form of government, which would be a very different situation than a hostile situation where there's chaos.
So we've got to be able to plan for every contingency in order to be able to ensure we are taking steps to protect that CBW so it doesn't fall into the wrong hands and try to ensure that these other weapons don't fall into the wrong hands.
CROWLEY: Let me talk to you about Niger really quickly, because North Africa becoming suddenly, at least to us suddenly, such a hot spot. I was talking to someone in the intelligence community recently who said, what we don't know is whether this is the last refuge of al Qaeda or whether this is a beachhead. Which is it, is this where al Qaeda is beginning to gather? Are we paying enough attention? Or is this sort of a last gasp, like the last place they can go. Have they been pushed there?
PANETTA: I think -- you know, you have got to look at the whole picture on al Qaeda. We've gone after core leadership of al Qaeda in the Fatah in Afghanistan. We've gone after them in Yemen. We've gone after them successfully in Somali. We were always aware there was AQIM in North Africa. And now we're focused on AQIM as a result, obviously of the French action. But we were also anticipating that we would have to move into North Africa to go after al Qaeda.
Wherever they are, we have to make sure they have no place to hide. Bottom line here is al Qaeda is our enemy and we have to make sure we go after them.
CROWLEY: And let me just finally -- I want to play you something from your predecessor as he was leaving office.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
ROBERT GATES, FRM. DEFENSE SECRETARY: Any future defense secretary who advises the president to again send a big American land army into Asia or into the Middle East or Africa should have his head examined as General MacArthur so delicately put it.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
CROWLEY: So first of all, do you agree with your predecessor on that? And second of all, give us your final thought as you prepare for your last month or so of your tenure. PANETTA: My sense is that the defense of this country has to be prepared to respond to any contingency. And I wouldn't rule out any action the president of the United States might decide needs to be taken against any crisis. So while I understand the concerns that Bob had, I just would not rule out any option in today's world.
We face a lot of threats today. I feel as secretary of defense I've been honored to serve at the Department of Defense. We have the strongest military power on Earth, and we're dealing with a lot of threats in today's world. The biggest concern i have quite frankly right now is the budget uncertainty on Capitol Hill, because if the sequester is allowed to go into effect, I think it could seriously impact on the readiness of the United States and that's a serious issue.
CROWLEY: And I would assume you agree with those parting words.
DEMPSEY: I couldn't agree more.
We face a true readiness crisis.
CROWLEY: OK, gentlemen, thank you so much for being with me. Thank you both very much.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






