Branstad Opens Gates for Iowa Straw Poll Criticism

Branstad Opens Gates for Iowa Straw Poll Criticism

By Scott Conroy - November 22, 2012

On the 13th of August last year, Rep. Michele Bachmann won Iowa’s quadrennial pre-caucus beauty contest known as the Ames Straw Poll.

The Minnesota congresswoman netted an impressive 4,823 votes out of the 16,892 cast by the state Republican activists who either paid a required $30 entry fee or, more commonly, had one of the GOP presidential hopefuls pay it for them -- literally buying their votes. (The candidates also paid for many participants’ transportation to the event, food for the day, and an array of entertainment options.)

Among the hundreds of journalists from around the world who had gathered in Ames that day, the results prompted unbridled gushing about Bachmann’s “meteoric rise” and newly earned status as the “clear favorite” to win the Iowa caucuses.

Basking in her triumph, Bachmann allowed herself to think far beyond the January caucuses on that promising, summer afternoon.

“Now it’s on to all 50 states!” she shouted to the media throngs who jostled to get a glimpse of the victor.

In the end, Bachmann wouldn’t even make it to New Hampshire. A day after finishing dead last in the January caucuses, in which she earned just 1,223 more votes than she had received 4½ months earlier in Ames, Bachmann ended her campaign and became a footnote to the 2012 presidential contest.

The straw poll, long billed as the most important early barometer of the race for the Oval Office, had once again predicted nothing.

In a Wall Street Journal interview published Wednesday, Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad voiced out loud what had long been clear to most observers of Republican presidential politics: “I think the straw poll has outlived its usefulness. It has been a great fundraiser for the party, but I think its days are over.”

In many ways, Branstad was merely stating the obvious. After all, since the first iteration was held in 1979, the Ames Straw Poll has been won by only two candidates who went on to become the nominee the following year -- Bob Dole in 1995 and George W. Bush in 1999 -- and both of them had already been widely viewed as front-runners.

The most recent iteration not only proved useless as a predictor, it was also largely overshadowed by the much-anticipated launch of Rick Perry’s campaign, which the Texas governor announced on the same day and a thousand miles away in South Carolina.

But among Iowa Republicans who have for decades relied on the poll as a lucrative one-off fundraiser -- and a key component of a statewide industry that relies upon early and intense national interest in the nominating process -- Branstad’s remarks were a major affront.

“I believe the Iowa Straw Poll is possibly the best way for a presidential campaign to organize (put in place county and precinct leaders & activate them) for Iowa's First in the Nation Caucus,” Iowa Republican Party Chairman A.J. Spiker posted on his Facebook page. “I think it is detrimental for any campaign to skip the opportunity presented in Ames and I disagree with Governor Branstad about ending our Iowa Straw Poll. The State GOP and the presidential campaigns will determine if there is an Ames Straw Poll come 2015.” (Spiker helmed Ron Paul’s 2012 campaign in the state and has clashed repeatedly in the past with establishment Republicans in Iowa.)

1 | 2 | Next Page››

Scott Conroy is a national political reporter for RealClearPolitics. He can be reached at Follow him on Twitter @RealClearScott.

Scott Conroy

Author Archive

Follow Real Clear Politics

Latest On Twitter