Debates Are Last Chance for Conversation We Deserve

By Carl M. Cannon - October 3, 2012

‹‹Previous Page |1 | 2 |

It’s an open question, as Brookings Institution senior fellow William Galston has observed, whether the American people are truly prepared for honest talk about the grim realities of entitlement spending. But the rhetoric coming from the DNC, we can stipulate, is not helpful in this regard.

The nadir of the 2012 campaign -- at least so far -- was probably an Obama super-PAC ad featuring a familiar Romney-bashing steelworker who maintained that Bain Capital had essentially killed his wife by buying GST Steel, looting it, and then closing it down, thus depriving his family of medical care. A “short time after that,” the steelworker claims, his wife died of cancer that was late in being diagnosed because the family lacked insurance.

The ad was dishonest in its overall implication and all of its particulars: First, GST Steel was purchased by Bain in 1993, and not closed down until 2001. Second, one cause of the closure was a strike by the plant’s unionized workers. Third, Romney was no longer running Bain when GST went bankrupt. Fourth, the steelworker’s wife had her own job, and her own health insurance, and wasn’t covered by GST Steel. Fifth, she lost that job for reasons having nothing to do with Bain, Romney, or GST Steel. Sixth, her illness was diagnosed in 2006, five years after bankruptcy, when Romney was running the state of Massachusetts.

This is perhaps the single most mendacious political hit piece ever produce by a presidential campaign -- and make no mistake, the super PAC that produced it is run by Obama cronies and confidants. When Obama campaign officials were called on the deceptions in the ad, they dissembled some more, claiming that they had no knowledge about the steelworker’s claims, even though the Obama campaign had used him as a surrogate speaker -- on a conference call with the media, no less.

In a spoof that should have embarrassed the president’s handlers, the satirical news site The Onion blared out a headline: “Romney Murdered JonBenét Ramsey, New Obama Campaign Ad Alleges.”

A presidential campaign can be a teachable moment for the nation, especially one in which the political players have been deferring action on budget, tax, and entitlement program policies that are bankrupting the nation. Americans have not been getting that campaign in 2012, but there is still a chance in the series of debates that begin tonight.

“No one will confuse the dialogue taking place this year with the Lincoln-Douglas debates,” former Indiana Sen. Evan Bayh, a Democrat, told RCP this week. “It’s all been tactical. But in the debates, maybe they will rise to the occasion. The first debate is supposed to be about the role of government. Maybe they will engage that subject in a serious way.”

Former Michigan Gov. John Engler, shortly after appearing with Bayh at a bipartisan forum at the Ronald Reagan Building Tuesday night, echoed that thought. “I hope the debate moderator will get these candidates to tell us precisely what they have in mind when it comes to addressing the massive national agenda before us,” he said. “There is work to be done.”

It’s an optimistic thought, perhaps over-optimistic, and the question remains about whether Americans have been conditioned to listen to such a discussion, whether the media would report it that way even if the candidates cooperated, and -- mostly -- whether these candidates or their stage managers are even inclined toward serious discourse.

Maverick political consultant Mark McKinnon notes that in a tight race, the impulse is usually to play it safe, which means sticking to the script. “In a campaign that everyone expected to be very close, I think decisions were made by both camps that telling hard truths and proposing bold solutions would be risky,” McKinnon said.

The Washington Post is right -- we do deserve better. These candidates are always invoking God’s blessing on the United States of America. But they could do their part by gracing us with a mature discussion of the challenges ahead. 

‹‹Previous Page |1 | 2 |

Carl M. Cannon is the Washington Bureau Chief for RealClearPolitics. Reach him on Twitter @CarlCannon.

Mitt Romney for Mayor
Carl M. Cannon · November 16, 2014
A President Who Is Hearing Things
Richard Benedetto · November 12, 2014
Bret Stephens' Call for Robust U.S. Foreign Policy
Peter Berkowitz · November 16, 2014

Latest On Twitter