Misplaced Furor Over Sixth-Grade School Trip

Misplaced Furor Over Sixth-Grade School Trip

By Edward Schumacher-Matos - September 24, 2010

BOSTON -- The absurd fear about Muslims in America has come to this:

A sixth-grade class from a public school in the affluent Boston suburb of Wellesley took a field trip last May to a Boston mosque as part of its course "Enduring Beliefs and the World Today." The class had already attended a gospel music performance, visited a synagogue and met with Hindus -- all trips chaperoned and approved by parents.

During the midday prayer service at the Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center, five boys -- on their own -- emulated the worshippers and got on their knees. One of the mothers apparently came with her own agenda and videotaped the visit, though all that can be seen is a blurry image of the boys as they stand up across the room.

The tape, released last week by an anti-Islamic group with the Orwellian name of Americans for Peace and Tolerance, has caused a firestorm of accusations here that impressionable children were being proselytized.

In addition to the depressively expected outpouring of hate on the Web and radio, the anonymous videotaper is threatening through a lawyer to sue the school, the superintendent has needlessly apologized, and a lot of otherwise open-minded First Amendment and Jewish groups darkly warn that a line between church and state has been violated.

"It's very important that public schools not put students in a position where they feel obligated or pressured to participate in worship and that they never be subject to proselytizing," Joe Conn, a spokesman for Americans United for Separation of Church and State, a Washington, D.C., education group, told the Boston Globe. "The bottom line is the school fell down in its responsibility."

All because of five curious boys on a sixth-grade field trip? Come on.

I was raised Catholic, have shared in Protestant communions, worn yarmulkes and sung in Jewish services, lit joss sticks and bowed in Buddhist temples, clasped my hands and left donations before Hindu deities and, yes, got on my knees and put my head on the floor in mosques -- all as attempts at respect and understanding.

Sure, we can't allow religious proselytizing in public schools, but the gross overreaction -- beyond the haters -- surely has as much or more to do with the fact that it was the Muslim religion involved. Who wants to bet that the students didn't sing to the gospel music?

Unlike nuts such as the Florida pastor who almost burned a Quran, these new critics, because of their educated mien and seeming rationality, are perhaps more insidiously dangerous to religious tolerance in America, whether intentional or not. They legitimize the hate.

Consider from the last three weeks alone:

Martin Peretz, editor-in-chief of the liberal New Republic, blogged that "Muslim life is cheap" and "I wonder whether I need honor these people and pretend that they are worthy of the privileges of the First Amendment." He later retracted the second comment, but stuck by the first. Yet, this weekend Harvard University will honor Peretz, a wealthy investor and former assistant professor, by inaugurating an undergraduate research fund in his name.

Cal Thomas suggested in his popular, religiously conservative syndicated newspaper column that no more Muslim immigrants be let in the country and that all mosque construction be banned or curtailed. "We must purge the evil from among us, or else," he wrote.

Newt Gingrich, my former high school classmate and a supposed intellectual Republican leader, warned that the United States is threatened by Muslims who are secretly "stealth jihadis" out "to replace Western civilization with a radical imposition of sharia."

None of these heavyweights offers any real proof. There are indeed Muslim-specific ills in some countries, but most Muslims here have proved themselves to be democratic and tolerant.

The parents of most of the Wellesley students may be setting the best example. They defended the field trip. "They (the students) weren't being indoctrinated," Marijane Tuohy, who went with her daughter on the trip, told the Globe. "If anything, it was just the opposite."


Copyright 2010, Washington Post Writers Group

Edward Schumacher-Matos

Author Archive

Follow Real Clear Politics

Latest On Twitter