Top Videos
Related Topics
economy
2008 Polls NationalIowaNew HampshireGeneral Election
GOP | DemGOP | DemGOP | DemHead-to-Head

Send to a Friend | Print Article


Policy and Economic Denial

By Brian Wesbury

Last week, the world's monetary policy literati attended their annual retreat in Jackson Hole, WY. The markets were waiting for news about the future course of interest rates, but were disappointed.

Nonetheless, there were continued signs that the world's intellectuals remain in serious denial about which policies create wealth and higher standards of living.

Greg Ip reported on "Jackson Hole's Sleeper Hit," a speech by Paul Collier of Oxford University titled the "The New Economic Geography." Mr. Collier's speech, according to Ip, "made a persuasive case that nowhere more than in Africa has geography undermined economic progress." Collier theorizes that small, landlocked and resource-poor countries can't keep up and lag behind.

This is not a new theory, but it is still wrong-headed. Freedom, not geography, drives growth and wealth creation. Switzerland, Austria and the Czech Republic are all landlocked and relatively small, but are clearly not poor. On the other hand, many African nations have vast resources.

Another idea reported by Mr. Ip, was shared by Arminio Frago, a former governor of Brazil's central bank. Mr. Frago "noted that Brazil and South Korea once had the same per capita GDP. Now, South Korea's is twice that of Brazil's. By way of explanation, he noted that the average Korean has 13 years of school, while in Brazil the figure is six years."

This idea that Asian economies owe their success to education is also wrong-headed. While education is important for individual success, if you happen to live in a country with high taxes, burdensome regulations, and unstable monetary policy, education and the entrepreneurial spirit are stifled.

But is it really true that, because of geography, African nations have no hope? And is it true that if government educates more people, wealth automatically follows? No. The Wealth of Nation's are not determined by geography or education, but freedom. While there are many who want to reject the teachings of Adam Smith, Ludwig von Mises, Frederich Hayek, Milton Friedman, and others, denial does not negate the truth.

Many are also in denial about the underlying strength of the US economy. While some economic data has been weaker than expected, underneath the headlines, the economy remains robust. The housing market has fallen precipitously, but in reality has only returned to the trend that was in place for a decade before the Fed cut interest rates to absurdly low levels between 2002 and 2004. Housing is normalizing, not collapsing. Moreover, initial claims remain low and "core" durable goods orders are still rising at double-digit rates.

This week's economic data is going to be hard for the pessimists to explain. Second quarter real GDP growth will be revised upwardly, consumption data will reflect 3.5% to 4.0% real growth in the third quarter, purchasing managers survey's will reflect continued expansion, and the August employment report is highly likely to accelerate from recent months. In the face of this data, denying a continued recovery will be harder than ever.

Brian Wesbury is the Chief Economist for First Trust Advisors in Chicago, IL.

Email Friend | Print | RSS | Add to Del.icio.us | Add to Digg
Sponsored Links

Brian Wesbury
Author Archive