March 1, 2006
By Bruce Thornton
Coming hard upon the heels of the cartoon riots and the election
of the Hamas terrorists, the destruction of the Shi’ite mosque
of the Golden Dome in Samarra by Sunni jihadists, and the subsequent
Shi’ite bloody retaliation, should put to rest Western delusions
about the true nature of Islam. But don’t hold your breath.
Such displays of Islam’s violent intolerance have been coming
thick and fast the last few decades, and can be found on every page
of history going back to the 7th century, when Islam began its expansion
with the blood of several hundred decapitated Jews.
some Westerners, enthralled to their own materialist assumptions
and multicultural “we are the world” sentimentalism,
wave away this evidence and reduce this destructive behavior to
any and every cause except the one that counts: spiritual belief.
So we hear that the violence is caused by a lack of jobs, or a
lack of liberal-democratic institutions, or “frustration”
and insecurity about the dismal backwardness of most Muslim states,
or wounded pride in the face of Western success, or resentment
of Western imperialist and colonialist sins, or oppressive autocrats,
or . . . take your pick. The same therapeutic mentality that thinks
destructive behavior in teens results from a “lack of self-esteem”
reduces the religious values of Muslims to mere “epiphenomena,”
as the Marxists see it, symptoms of some underlying condition
rooted in material deprivation, political impotence, or psychological
with Islam, however, is not a lack of self-esteem but too damned
much. This is a faith fanatically certain of its truth and righteousness,
the culminating vision of God’s relations with humanity,
the ultimate meaning of human existence on every level, including
the social and political. As such, its destiny is to spread over
the whole world until the benefits, both in this life and the
next, of submission to God are bestowed on all humans, and the
dysfunctional man-made values–– including democracy,
materialism, “equal rights,” and freedom––
are swept away. For however alluring, these do not deliver true
happiness or true freedom, but mere hedonism and license that
create misery and degradation in this world, and put the soul
at risk in the next.
you are in possession of this truth that you are absolutely certain
holds the key to universal happiness in this world and the next,
why would you be tolerant of alternatives? Why should you tolerate
a dangerous lie? Why should you “live and let live,”
the credo of the spiritually moribund who stand for everything
because they stand for nothing? And why wouldn’t you kill
in the name of this vision, when the infidel nations work against
God’s will and his beneficent intentions for the human race?
This is precisely
what the jihadists tell us, what fourteen centuries of Islamic
theology and jurisprudence tell us, what the Koran and Hadith
tell us. Yet we smug Westerners, so certain of our own superior
knowledge that human life is really about genes or neuroses or
politics or nutrition, condescendingly look down on the true believer.
Patronizing him like a child, we tell him that he doesn’t
know that his own faith has been “hijacked” by “fundamentalists”
who manipulate his ignorance, that what he thinks he knows about
his faith is a delusion, and that the true explanation is one
that we advanced, sophisticated Westerners understand while the
believer remains mired in superstition and neurotic fantasy.
And of course,
it doesn’t help that the Westernized Islamic apologists
and propagandists, having taken the measure of the West’s
own superstition and fantasy, speak in our terms and manipulate
our materialist causes. So we hear that Western support of autocrats
is really to blame for terrorist discontent — but overthrowing
Saddam Hussein, one of the most brutal murderers of Muslims ever,
and creating for the Iraqi people an inclusive, law-based government,
earn us absolutely nothing other than more hatred and murder.
Ah, but the neo-colonialist Zionists are responsible, we are told.
Yet billions of Western dollars given to the Palestinian Arabs,
decades of obsessive, fawning attention on the part of the Western
media and the U.N. even as millions have suffered and died elsewhere,
have not moved us one inch closer to resolving the crisis or removing
the existential threat to Israel. Give us jobs, we are told, an
excuse echoed recently by Thomas Friedman, and we will be happy.
Yet the terrorists in the main are not poor or dispossessed. Their
leaders are billionaires, surgeons, engineers, and the college
educated. But the West disrespects Islam, they cry, all the while
our apologetic gestures of admiration for Islam do not stop the
persecution and murder of Christians, do not elicit reciprocal
apologies for the vile insults to Judaism that appear in state-run
media throughout the Muslim world.
all our attempts to bolster Muslim self-esteem, our desperate
protestations of respect for their wonderful religion, our groveling
apologies for exercising our own rights and values, our donning
of the hair-shirt of racist, colonialist, or imperialist guilt,
do nothing more than convince the jihadist that his spiritual
superiority is justified. He looks at our appeasement, our fear,
our rationalizations, our self-doubt, our unwillingness to defend
the values we preach to the world, and sees the craven inferiority
of the dhimmi, the conquered infidel who must acknowledge
by his public actions the superiority of Islam, and who must pay
the jizya, the “poll tax” that purchases
his trembling security. Only we call the poll tax “foreign
aid” or “welfare payments,” and the gestures
of submission “respect for diversity.” We think our
submission buys us affection and gratitude and respect for our
interests, but in fact it purchases nothing except more contempt
for our spiritual bankruptcy, more scorn for our belief that money
and material comfort trump spiritual truth.
measure of our failure adequately to respect spiritual motives
can be taken from the Bush administration’s steadfast refusal
to put the crisis with Islam in these terms. The materialist left,
of course, has been taught by Freud and Marx that religion is
an “illusion,” so obviously we can’t expect
them to grasp how powerfully spiritual imperatives can move people.
But when a self-proclaimed born-again Christian either can’t
or won’t see the clash of spiritual goods underlying the
conflict, then we know how thoroughly the materialists have done
their work of marginalizing religion in the West.
best example of this contempt for our spiritual foundations came
when the President apologized for using the word “Crusade.”
The demonization of the Crusades is a historical distortion that
acquiesces in the jihadist rewriting of history in order to exploit
Western self-loathing and spiritual emptiness. Whatever the sordid
or brutal motives and actions of the Crusaders, they were still
for the most part driven by a spiritual imperative to restore
the Holy Land to the Christian civilization that had defined the
Middle East for six centuries before being violently transformed
by the armies of Allah. For the most aggressively imperialistic
culture in the history of the world to whine now about Western
imperialism — and be taken seriously by Westerners —
testifies to the intellectual corruption endemic in the West.
If we continue
down this road of appeasement, apology, and blackmail, then our
outlook is indeed grim. A culturally weaker and ruder Europe turned
back the Islamic tide because it was united by its Christian faith,
the spiritual strength of all those before us who died and killed
so that this prosperous, free world we enjoy could exist. But
what unites the West now, when our credo seems to be that juvenile
sentiment from John Lennon’s “Imagine”: “Nothing
to kill or die for, and no religion too”? Is this the belief
that can resist an enemy who knows with absolute certainty what
is worth killing and dying for?
piece first appeared on Victor
Davis Hanson's Private Papers.