Another British Healthcare Horror Story

By Daniel Mitchell, International Liberty - October 16, 2012

Paul Krugman assured us back in 2009 that, "In Britain, the government itself runs the hospitals and employs the doctors. We've all heard scare stories about how that works in practice; these stories are false."Ě

If that’s the case, then the British press is filled with liars who deliberately make up horror stories about their nation’s healthcare system, as you can see here, here, here,¬†here,¬†here,¬†here,¬†here,¬†here,¬†here,¬†here, here and¬†here.

We now have another nightmare to add to this list. Here are some of the horrific details from the UK-based Daily Mail.

An elderly woman died alone after doctors failed to tell relatives they were ending her life on the controversial Liverpool Care Pathway. Olive Goom, 85, passed away with no one by her side after medics neglected to consult with her family about her treatment at Chelsea and Westminster Hospital. …As Miss Goom lay dying alone, staff reassured relatives on the phone just hours before her death that there was no urgent need to visit "“ even though doctors had already removed tubes providing vital food and fluids. Her family discovered that she had died only when her niece went to visit her and found she was already being prepared for the mortuary. They said last night that they will never be able to stop feeling guilty that no one was there in her final hours. The Mail has been contacted by several families who claim that relatives were put on the Liverpool Care Pathway "“ the controversial system designed to ease the suffering of the dying in their final hours "“ without any consultation. Some said they found out that their relatives were on the pathway only after they happened to read their medical notes; and by that time it was too late.

Keep in mind, by the way, that the Liverpool Care Pathway is sort of akin to the IPAB “death panel” in Obamacare.

Defenders of government-run healthcare say that’s nonsense and assert that there won’t be any rationing, denial of care, or requirements for euthanasia. That’s technically true, but the Obamacare death panel will be determining what’s an acceptable treatment and what’s the government-approved payment schedule.

Crushed by Obamacare?

So it’s sort of like holding a rock in your hand, standing over a kitten, letting go of the rock, watching it hit the kitten, but then claiming that you did nothing wrong because gravity caused the rock to fall.

Okay, that’s a morbid example, but you get the point. And my concern isn’t that rationing only exists with a government-run system. Any healthcare system will involve rationing. The real issue is whether individuals are part of a free society so they can make the choice of how to ration.

(h/t: Ben Domenech)

[...] But seriously, read this… [...]

In the absence of facts from the hospital, together with the fact that the Daily Mail provides some of the most sensationalist headlines – (hence why it is the most visited online media in the UK) – I would advise caution in any conclusions you might reach.

Reblogged this on Gds44's Blog.

How hard is for people to understand that the guiding principle is going to be: “The Needs of the Many, Not the Needs of the Few or the One”?

Yeah, Captain Spock said that in the second Star Trek film. That’s still the easiest way to sum up what IPAB is going to be doing. Stark utilitarianism like that is not exactly easy to cope with on a mass social level…

Commenter Mike,

Did you actually read the article from the Daily Mail? A spokeswoman for the hospital admitted that they did, in fact, put the woman on the pathway procedure without advising her family. Additionally, the health secretary Andy Burnham called for an urgent review of the pathway operations.

So there is no absence of facts from the hospital.

Comments RSS

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Notify me of follow-up comments via email.

Read Full Article »

Follow Real Clear Politics

Latest On Twitter

Real Clear Politics Video

More RCP Video Highlights »