An Easter Lesson in Judging Not
Published March 30, 2016 • Read time: 5m
He was sure to annoy me, the restless, demonstrative guy who brought his big family to Easter Sunday Mass. But I expect to be annoyed on Easter and Christmas.
I go to Mass regularly, a lifelong habit instilled in me by my devout mother and 12 years of Catholic education, and reinforced by my equally devout wife. I know to arrive early on Easter and Christmas when the ranks of the faithful are swelled by people who only come to church on those two holidays and for weddings and funerals.
They fill the parking lots and the pews. Even though we make it a point to arrive 30 minutes early, we often can’t find a parking space or a place to sit. This Easter we parked illegally and squeezed into a crowded pew in one of the small lofts above the altar, the only spaces left in the church. I was already simmering at a low boil as we settled in.
Occupying two pews in front of us was an extended family, whose members I deduced were unaccustomed to regular religious devotion. They seemed nice enough, but their unfamiliarity with their surroundings was obvious. The paterfamilias of the clan stood in the aisle a few moments before Mass began, speaking loudly into his cellphone, summoning other relatives to the real estate he had staked a claim to on their behalf. They arrived, some wriggling into the pews with others standing in the back, blocking the stairway.
It was distracting to those of us who were trying to achieve a prayerful state of grace in preparation for the service.
Not all of them stood for the entrance procession. Neither did they get up at later points in the Mass when standing is expected. The father was the only one who seemed to remember the liturgy. He knew the prayers, and when to stand and kneel. I imagined he had been raised in the faith, but no longer formally practiced it and had never imposed his religious traditions on his own family.
At various moments, he held up a laminated card containing the rites and prayers of the Mass, encouraging his people to join him in reciting the penitential rite, the Kyrie eleison and the Nicene Creed. He would look from one to another, to his right and his left and behind him, trying to get their attention, whispering some of their names. Most ignored him, and shot each other amused glances after he had turned back around.
Neither he nor any of his family had dressed for the occasion. I’m not usually a stickler for formality, often wearing casual clothes in church myself. But on Easter, like most people, I bow to convention, button my collar, knot a tie and pull on a sport jacket. It seems the least I can do to observe the anniversary of our Savior’s resurrection. And though I know I shouldn’t, I find fault in those who do not make the same effort.
During the offertory, when the ushers passed the collection basket, he made a modest offering, a few dollars. I took disapproving note of that, too. We’re expected on Easter to part with a substantially larger sum than the usual Sunday donation.
As is obvious, I was too busy judging my neighbors to pay close attention to the Mass. I remember little of it, to be honest, and almost nothing of the priest’s homily. I realized at the time that I wasn’t participating fully in the celebration. I had let myself be diverted. Rather than chastise myself for my pettiness, I resented the cause of my distraction.
When the hosts and wine were consecrated into the body and blood of Christ, I was concentrating on a lapsed Catholic who was taking up space in my church, making a show of his eagerness to introduce his uninterested family to the rituals of his childhood faith, my faith, ignoring the formality of the occasion and unwittingly disregarding the sensibilities of his neighbor, my sensibilities.
I was still resentful when the trespasser approached me with a wide smile on his face during the part of the Mass where the congregants exchange the sign of peace, vigorously pumped my hand and loudly proclaimed, “Peace be with you, friend.”
“Peace be with you,” I muttered in reply, instantly feeling ashamed.
As it is said, the Lord works in mysterious ways. Acting through my neighbor, He had shown me again the essential lesson of my faith that His life and death and resurrection teach the believer. God loves me no less than any other person, and no more.
A man had come back even if only for a day to celebrate the risen Christ in the faith of his fathers, and I resented him for it. God rejoiced, while I felt aggrieved. And He had let me know who had been the better Christian, and who needed another lesson in God’s mercy.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






