
Will Reluctant Paul Ryan Heed Speakership Pleas?
Published Oct. 11, 2015 • Read time: 7m
Paul Ryan has made it perfectly clear he has no interest in becoming speaker of the House of Representatives. But amid turmoil in the Republican conference, looming fiscal deadlines and a wave of fellow party members calling for him to lead, his resistance may not matter.
Five years ago, Ryan was one of the self-proclaimed “young guns,” a trio of youthful lawmakers who were supposed to represent the future of the GOP. The first, Eric Cantor, rose to majority leader and seemed poised to one day become speaker before a shocking primary upset removed him from office. The second, Kevin McCarthy, also rose to majority leader and similarly appeared poised to take over as speaker before his shocking decision last week to drop out of the race moments before ballots were to be cast.
Ryan, after unsuccessfully running to be vice president in 2012, settled into his prized position as the chairman of the Ways and Means Committee, intending to tackle big policy ideas rather than follow his colleagues’ push toward leadership. But now his party is calling on him as a savior and he may have to abandon his own aspirations to fill the void.
To be clear, Ryan insists he is still not a speaker candidate. Anticipating the pleas for him to step up, he put out a statement within 30 minutes of McCarthy’s decision to leave the race, saying he appreciated the support but wouldn’t run. His spokesman, Brendan Buck, echoed that Friday afternoon, saying in a statement, “Chairman Ryan appreciates the support he's getting from his colleagues but is still not running for Speaker."
Where "Obama Republicans" Split With Party
Curbelo Gives Spanish-Language Response to State of the Union
Rep. Bachmann Says She Won't Run For Re-Election
No, We Don't All Sin Like Mark Sanford
But despite those assertions, Ryan’s colleagues are persisting anyway, convinced not just that he is the best -- and possibly the only -- man for the job, but that he will reluctantly step up to the plate.
“Paul Ryan answered the call when he was called by Mitt Romney to consider being vice president and I believe he’s going home this weekend to soul-search with his family about whether or not he can in fact accept this job,” Rep. Darrell Issa said Friday. “A job he doesn’t want, he isn’t seeking, but is seeking him.”
Rep. Fred Upton put the party’s sentiments succinctly: “He needs to do this for the team.”
The calls have come from the highest levels in the Capitol, with the outgoing speaker, John Boehner, privately urging Ryan to succeed him, according to the Washington Post, and McCarthy publicly endorsing the Wisconsin lawmaker. Even Romney, who selected Ryan as his running mate in 2012, has called and urged him to run, Upton told reporters Friday afternoon.
For Ryan, there is more on the line than simply whether he’s being drawn away from a policy objective and towards an undesired leadership role. His political ambitions and his personal life will weigh heavily in his considerations. One of the key reasons Ryan cited in opting out of the speakership race is the workload: The job requires extensive travel to help the party raise money, and Ryan, who has three young children at home in Wisconsin, likes to travel there on weekends to be with his family.
Beyond that, his political future may hang in the balance. He is seen as an intellectual leader of the GOP and there were once calls for him to enter the now-crowded 2016 presidential race, though he ended speculation by removing himself from the campaign before it had even begun.
Still, at age 45 he has a long career remaining, and has said that he doesn’t intend to spend the entirety of his adult life in the House, where he’s already served for nearly 17 years. A post as Treasury secretary in a Republican administration or a future White House run are seen as possible scenarios for him.
But the speakership could be a roadblock to those ambitions. Ryan would have to contend with a fractured party conference that even those urging him to run admit he might not be able to fix. Members of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, eager for Republicans to aggressively push their agenda even if it means triggering government shutdowns or a default on the nation’s debt, wield a tremendous amount of power. They repeatedly bucked Boehner and forced him to work with Democrats to get through must-pass legislation, which only frustrated them further. It’s not clear that even Ryan would be able to change that.
“The bigger challenge is not who we put in the speaker’s chair, the issue is how do we change the underlying political dynamic that got us in this position in the first place. And no matter who we put in that chair is going to have figure out a way to change the political dynamic,” said Rep. Charlie Dent, one of the leading critics of those conservatives. Asked if Ryan can address that issue, Dent said, “I don’t know that anybody can right now. Paul is highly respected by all the members of the conference, but I think Paul’s a very smart guy. He understands this.”
Freedom Caucus members weren’t immediately on board with the idea of a Ryan speakership. They endorsed third-term Republican Rep. Daniel Webster in the race, and most said Friday they were sticking with their choice, at least for the time being. Rep. Tim Huelskamp said the group would want to interview Ryan, as it did with the other speaker candidates, before they could decide whether to back him. And there are some sticking points.
Huelskamp mentioned the 2013 budget deal Ryan crafted with Democratic Sen. Patty Murray, which broke mandatory spending caps, as something he and other conservatives didn’t approve of. If Ryan becomes speaker later this fall, he would immediately be thrust into negotiations with the White House and the rest of congressional leadership to reach a similar deal. It would be a familiar predicament and one he’d be well positioned to negotiate, having been through budget talks with the White House in the past. But the conservative flank of the party may not approve any type of deal that allows spending to increase, and if Ryan and Democrats reach, and pass, such an agreement, he could see backlash similar to what Boehner faced.
But there were some positive signs as well.
“I think that Paul Ryan would be a more acceptable candidate than the current leadership team, primarily because he’s not in the current leadership team,” Rep. Justin Amash said, according to The Hill. “And I believe he’d provide a different approach.”
There are potential upsides to answering the call to lead. Many in the party would see Ryan as a savior at a critical time for Republicans, given their majorities in both chambers of Congress and a crucial presidential election looming. If he successfully unites the conference, his already strong reputation within the party would only increase.
But that remains a big if. For now, Ryan has reiterated time and again that he does not want the job. As the pressure mounts, however, he may be pushed into wielding the gavel.
Rep. Sean Duffy, a fellow Wisconsin Republican, said on MSNBC Friday that it was “amazing” to see Ryan happy where he is and resisting calls for more power.
“I think what’s going to happen to Paul, if you know him, he’s kind of a Boy Scout,” Duffy said. “He wants to do what’s right for the country. If he feels that no one else can take the position, that he’s the only guy left – which I think he prays it’s not the case – I do think he’ll make a decision that’s not just right for his family, his little kids, but also what’s right for the country. My hope is that he will reconsider and take the spot.”

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
