Distracted Driving: America's "Deadly Epidemic"
Published Oct. 7, 2013 • Read time: 11m
Join the Conversation
0At 10:40 a.m. on Nov. 14, 2004, two charter buses driven by experienced drivers were heading south on the George Washington Parkway near Washington, D.C. The passengers were Catholic school kids from Massachusetts en route to tour Mount Vernon, Va.
Both motor coaches, owned by Eyre Bus Service, were 12 feet high. As they approached a stone bridge at Alexandria Avenue, they passed a road sign stating that the clearance in the left lane is 13 feet 4 inches, but the right lane is only 10 feet 2 inches. The lead driver dutifully moved into the left lane. The second driver did not. As his unsuspecting passengers chatted with one another, the roof of the bus suddenly peeled off with a loud and frightening sound.
The passengers were lucky. No one was killed and only one of the injured 11 students was seriously hurt. The driver and the chaperone were unharmed. What the National Transportation Safety Board wanted to know was how the 44-year-old driver, who had traveled the same route only nine days earlier, managed to miss the warning sign.
The short answer is that the man was talking to his sister on a hands-free cellular phone. The longer answer, which extends to professional pilots, boat captains, and train engineers -- as well as operators of motor vehicles -- is known by many names. Aviation experts talk of “situational awareness.” Psychologists parse the concept of “cognitive overload.” University of Utah researcher David Strayer talks of “inattention blindness.” We know it today, largely through the efforts of former Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, under the broad heading of “distracted driving.”
Donald Trump's Useful Idiots
The Campus Affluenza Epidemic
Are Today's Millennials a New Victorian Generation?
A New Voice for Sexual Assault Victims in Uniform
A Crusade Against Car Radios
Long before Ray LaHood came along there was George A. Parker. In 1928, Parker was appointed registrar of motor vehicles in the state of Massachusetts. He may or may not have been an actual technophobe, but he was definitely leery of automobiles -- and mistrustful of drivers. They were just too dangerous.
The year Parker assumed office, the United States had reached a dubious milestone: the annual number of deaths on the nation’s roadways surpassed 25,000. Parker’s office reported that 715 of those fatalities occurred in Massachusetts; the state’s top automotive regulator wanted to lower that number. But how?
Initially, Parker focused on speeding. “It is the swift tempo of our modern life,” he said in 1929, “that is responsible for so many motorist casualties.”
Perusing the newspapers of the day, it’s apparent that George Parker possessed an easier talent for the pithy quote than for building consensus for change. At a time when others were calling for more secure automobiles and safer roadways, Parker’s emphasis was on making it more difficult to obtain (and keep) a driver’s license.
“What a large number of our drivers need today is not better road conditions or better mechanical equipment,” he explained. “What they need is better mental equipment.”
This perception would eventually lead him to become an early activist against drunk driving. First, however, Parker took a quixotic detour: He led an utterly unsuccessful crusade against car radios. Asserting that radios were a menace because they distracted the attention of drivers away from the road, Parker told Bay State newspapers in January 1930 that he planned to order a removal of all car radios in Massachusetts.
“In commenting upon the matter,” noted the Quincy Patriot Ledger, “Parker stated that in his opinion the presence of a radio in an auto represents a distinct hazard to public safety owing to the strong likelihood that the operator of the machine will have his entire attention diverted from handling the wheel in listening to his radio reception.”
Parker openly expressed the hope that he was at the vanguard of a movement that would go national. First, however, he had to contend with a couple of inconvenient details. The registrar of motor vehicles almost certainly lacked the legal authority to rip radios out of privately owned autos in Massachusetts, so he convened a public hearing on the matter hoping to achieve a legislative consensus. It did not go as he’d hoped.
Then, as now, technological innovation had its defenders. Representing the Radio Manufacturers Association, a lobbyist named C.C. Colby noted that insurance companies had no compunction about offering coverage for cars with radios. Other speakers pointed out that the radio had obvious safety components: Drivers could be warned of road hazards and bad weather ahead. Colby added that the music and talk emanating from the radio was less distracting that an “irritating” back-seat driver -- and could be turned off much easier.
Americans took these defenses with a grain of salt (in a 1930s survey by the Auto Club of New York, some 56 percent of respondents classified the car radio as a potentially “dangerous” distraction), but they didn’t like a would-be reformer telling them what they could have in their cars. At the public hearing in Massachusetts, only five hands -- out of more than 100 -- went up in support of George Parker’s prohibition scheme.
The truth was that everyday citizens didn’t really know if the radio helped the cause of safety or impaired it. They only knew they loved cars with radios in them: They were paying upwards of $130 to install them in automobiles that cost about $600. It’s a dilemma we are still wrestling with today. The evidence is strong that some technological tasks -- texting, for example -- trigger cognition distractions in drivers, often with tragic results.
Last week, a 59-year-old man from West Hempstead, N.Y., lost his life when his car veered off the road, crossed into the oncoming lanes, and slammed into a tree. Police said he’d been texting while driving. For the families involved, these events are personal tragedies; and yet they are so commonplace that they rarely make headlines. In one case last year that did make the news, a 21-year-old Indiana man named Chandler Gerber was driving his GM van at 60 miles per hour on a rural highway when he plowed into an Amish buggy.
Three children in the same family were killed in that accident and their mother seriously injured. Gerber admitted to police that he’d been texting while driving. He was not even charged with a crime. That attitude is changing. In July, a Somerset County, N.J., judge sentenced 18-year-old Devin O’Niel to five years in prison after he was found guilty of texting while driving a car that crossed the center line and hit another car head on, killing a woman.
“I get to spend the rest of my life without any parents because of what you did,” the victim’s son told the young driver in a dramatic courtroom confrontation.
The real outburst, however, came from Judge Robert Reed. “Eleven of you will die in this country every day because of texting and driving,” he said while pronouncing the sentence. "For God’s sake, stop it!”
The judge’s math was off: Nine people, not 11, die every day in accidents in which distracted driving is considered the cause, or partial cause. (The designation is an umbrella category that includes talking on the phone, eating, using GPS devices -- that is, not paying attention because of any extraneous technology or concern.)
With some activities -- texting on a handheld device, for example -- a consensus has emerged. Today, some 41 states, plus Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, prohibit texting while driving. But banning an activity is not the same thing as making it go away.
A week ago, Illinois state troopers on the lookout for distracted drivers at two points on Chicago’s Kennedy Expressway issued 135 citations in 2½ hours. Most of them were for texting while driving, although Lt. David Byrd did tell reporters that one man was ticketed for shaving while driving.
Measuring Distraction
Ray LaHood often spoke of distracted driving as a “deadly epidemic.” It’s certainly true that it can sometimes be deadly. It’s also true, as the Chicago checkpoints amply demonstrated, that such activity is commonplace, especially among young drivers. According to the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, cellphones are a factor in 21 percent of the fatal crashes involving drivers under age 20 -- twice the percentage as older drivers.
But competing narratives have emerged over what such statistics signify. For one thing, according to CTIA, the Wireless Association, some 173 billion text messages are sent in this country each year -- and Americans spend a lot of time in cars. For another, the number of highway fatalities has not spiked upward significantly since the onset of texting as a preferred mode of communication among the young. Also, the young drivers more likely to be using cellphones are also the ones less familiar with the dangers of driving itself.
When 16-year-old Savannah Nash was killed recently after pulling in front of a tractor-trailer while trying to make a left turn on a highway near her home, Missouri State Police cited distracted driving as the cause. Their evidence: an unsent text message on her phone. But the text was a long one, and the teen was killed seconds after pulling out of her driveway. What seems more likely was that she tossed the phone on the seat on her way to the store as she got behind the wheel -- and was killed in a "normal" traffic accident at a notoriously dangerous intersection.
There is also no consensus on exactly how the human mind manages to multitask -- or even whether it can. Six years ago, I discussed this phenomenon with Gloria Mark, a professor of interactive and collaborative technologies at the University of California, Irvine. She was studying what happens when human beings are interrupted in a way that causes them to change mental topics in an office setting. Even in that unthreatening environment -- no tractor-trailers are bearing down on them -- the subject’s attention was diverted.
“It's a myth you can do two things at once,” Mark told me. “What you can do is switch from one task to another very rapidly. What causes cognitive overload is switching contexts.”
Several recent studies have charted such effects on drivers. One of the most influential bodies of research was done in 2009 by the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute, which found that truck drivers’ risk of collision was 23 times greater when they were texting, largely because in the five seconds they typically looked at their handheld screens their rigs traveled the length of a football field.
“Texting is in its own universe of risk,” proclaimed Rich Hanowski, who oversaw the study at VTTI. An updated version of the study released this year confirmed those findings and demonstrated that other visual-manual tasks -- including dialing or even reaching for a phone -- contributes to the danger.
Car and Driver magazine conducted a field study of its own that underscored these findings. Its editor rigged up a car with a red light that would instruct a test driver going 70 miles per hour when to hit the brakes. The control group included sober drivers without any electronic distraction. Subjects in two other test categories were driving just over the legal limit for alcohol, and reading email or texting. The results were, well, sobering:
-- Unimpaired: 0.54 seconds to brake
-- Legally drunk: add 4 feet
-- Reading e-mail: add 36 feet
-- Sending a text: add 70 feet
Another influential academic study, this one sponsored by the American Automobile Association and done by researchers under the direction of Professor Strayer at the University of Utah, went about it a different way. The AAA study measured brainwaves, eye and head movements and concluded that the complexity of the mental task being performed may be more significant than the type of hardware in the vehicle.
Activities such as talking to another passenger or listening to the radio ranked as a category “1” level of distraction (take that, George A. Parker!), which was the minimal level of risk. Using a cellphone for simple conversation -- either via a handheld device and hands-free -- produced about the same results, a “2” in the study’s parlance (or moderate risk). But listening and responding to in-vehicle, voice-activated email features corresponded to a “3” rating (indicating an extensive risk), presumably because it increases mental workload and, therefore, the distraction levels of the drivers in the study.
These findings engendered both skepticism and consternation among both carmakers and the technology companies that have been outfitting their autos with the next-generation technology that is supposed to be so much safer. But the University of Utah study is not likely to be the last word on this question, just as Bluetooth won’t be the last technology.
In 1976, British science-fiction writer Arthur C. Clarke wrote a novel called "Imperial Earth" that he described as his birthday present, on the occasion of America’s bicentennial, to the United States. It’s set 500 years in the future, around July 4. And there are still cars on the George Washington Parkway, but no drivers.
One character who lives on Earth hosts a visitor to the capital city. He recommends that this visitor go see Mount Vernon, just as the students on the bus were doing in 2004 when their driver hit that bridge. He also informs his guest with a shudder that motor vehicles once lacked “automatic” steering, adding: “More people were killed on these roads than ever died in warfare -- did you know that?”

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
