Perfect Storm: Race-Baiting and the 2012 Election
Published Oct. 30, 2012 • Read time: 9m
Join the Conversation
0Provisioned with flashlights, canned food, and bottled water, East Coast residents spent Monday hunkered in our homes for a storm that closed schools, canceled work for some, and left hundreds of thousands without public transportation. Even before the "Frankenstorm" arrived, our elected leaders assured us it would cause severe flooding and massive power outages.
The 21st century has been a time of reverse progress. The “Greatest Generation” dimmed the lights in the great cities of this country, but voluntarily, so as to conserve power and ensure our enemies weren’t provided bombing targets. Today, it only takes bad weather to turn the capital of the free world, technologically speaking, into a Third World outpost.
But while it’s reasonable to wonder whether $900 billion in stimulus spending might have bought us buried power lines and trimmed trees, the waning days of the 2012 political campaign have brought a threat more sinister than Hurricane Sandy. This menace, building for a long time this year, is race-baiting. And much of it is coming from people who consider themselves racially sensitive and liberal.
This is the real Frankenstorm.
It started long before Mitt Romney emerged as the Republican Party standard-bearer. In 2010 and 2011, Democrats routinely characterized the tea party movement as “racist,” notwithstanding the fact that its initial target was President Bush, not President Obama -- or that the tea party movement increased representation of African-American, Latino, and Asian-American conservatives in Congress and the governors mansions -- invariably by backing candidates who challenged (white) members of the GOP establishment.
Sanders Seeks Caucus Trifecta Win to Close Delegate Gap
Sanders Fighting Perception He Can't Overcome Clinton Edge
Clinton Targets Trump as Sanders Circles
Sanders, Clinton Differ Sharply at Flint Debate
For much of 2012, another ploy of Democrats and left-leaning media circles has been to accuse Romney and his Republican allies of employing subliminal messages to court the votes of bigots. In the Democrats’ telling, this country is full of people who respond to such “dog whistles,” a cliché that has replaced the “code words” of past campaigns.
One problem is that the “dog whistles” in question usually only can be heard by partisan critics of the Republican Party. Worried that the Obama administration might be weakening the 1996 welfare reform law via Health and Human Services waivers? You’re a racist. Dismayed that poverty has increased since Obama became president? If you had the inelegance to couch your concern by noting that the number of Americans on food stamps has increased in four years, you’re also a racist.
This kind of thing, a staple on MSNBC and in other liberal precincts, can spill over into inadvertent self-parody. Barack Obama plays a lot of golf, and some Republicans have taken -- as Democrats did when Dwight Eisenhower was president -- to gently needle him for working on his golf game while the U.S. economy stagnates. Ah, but even that criticism is racist!
How so, you ask? Ike was white; and anyway, golf is not a pastime most Americans consider an intrinsically African-American activity. True, but Tiger Woods plays golf, you see, and from there we’re off and running.
In a late-August exchange easily confused with a skit on The Onion, MSNBC anchorman Lawrence O’Donnell castigated Republican Sen. Mitch McConnell for a draft of a speech he’d not yet given. In it, the Senate minority leader sardonically chided the president for his time on the links, saying he seemed to be working “to earn a spot on the PGA tour.” Aha! The Kentucky lawmaker’s speechwriters, O’Donnell insisted, were slyly trying to make the connection between Obama and Tiger Woods -- and Woods’ “lifestyle.”
Even fellow MSNBC anchorman Martin Bashir was skeptical, so O’Donnell explained: “These people reach for every single possible racial double entendre they can find in every one of these speeches. . . . But when you get to the Tiger Woods reference, there were people in the speech-writing room -- I know this, without a shadow of a doubt -- who said, ‘Wait a minute, do we really want to go there? Do we really want to go to Tiger Woods?’ And the vote in the room was yes, we do. Mitch McConnell agreed to do it.”
Lawrence O’Donnell, it can be said without much argument, would make a lousy juror. It’s also worth remembering that McConnell never mentioned Tiger Woods, nor alluded to him obliquely. Obviously, only a hyper-partisan would believe a rational voter would infer a comparison between the very-married president and the overly libidinous Woods -- or imagine that it was all racially motivated -- but such talk has gone mainstream.
Late last week, after Colin Powell endorsed Barack Obama over Mitt Romney, a key Romney surrogate, former New Hampshire Gov. John Sununu, sought to deflect the impact of the endorsement by characterizing it as reflecting racial solidarity.
In response, Powell’s former chief of staff Lawrence Wilkerson escalated the rhetoric exponentially. The only real rationale for opposing Obama’s re-election, Wilkerson suggested, is racial antipathy, adding that the Republican Party “is full of racists.”
In some ways, Colin Powell’s endorsement of the president seemed an unlikely event to precipitate such a tempest. A retired four-star general, Powell has served in Republican and Democratic administrations. He was White House national security adviser during Ronald Reagan’s tenure, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff under both George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton, and Secretary of State for George W. Bush. And although Powell spoke at Republican conventions, four years ago he endorsed Obama for president. In other words, his 2012 presidential endorsement would have only been big news had he not done so again.
Yet Powell’s 2008 endorsement had stuck in the craw of many prominent Republicans. Not content merely to say he admired Obama, Powell went on to say four years ago that the GOP was becoming “narrower and narrower.” This seemed uncharitable to many party stalwarts, especially those who had urged Powell to run himself in the hopes that he -- and not Barack Obama -- would be the first African-American president, and that he’d do it as the standard-bearer of their party.
Apparently, this long-standing frustration bubbled over for Sununu, one of Romney’s most energetic surrogates and a man who served in the first Bush White House with Powell.
“Frankly, when you take a look at Colin Powell, you have to wonder whether that's an endorsement based on issues or whether he’s got a slightly different reason for preferring President Obama,” Sununu told CNN’s Piers Morgan. When pressed on those reasons, Sununu amplified: “Well, I think when you have somebody of your own race that you’re proud of being president of the United States, I applaud Colin for standing with him.”
Evidently, neither Powell nor those in his entourage felt as though they’d been applauded.
“My party, unfortunately, is the bastion of those people -- not all of them, but most of them -- who are still basing their positions on race,” Wilkerson said in an MSNBC appearance. “Let me just be candid: My party is full of racists, and the real reason a considerable portion of my party wants President Obama out of the White House has nothing to do with the content of his character, nothing to do with his competence as commander-in-chief and president, and everything to do with the color of his skin, and that’s despicable.”
That is a harsh accusation, and if you’re a Republican, an ugly one, so it’s worth parsing.
For starters, the “my party” conceit Wilkerson starts with is misleading. He may have once considered himself a Republican, but he’s a career U.S. Army officer with little or no history in GOP electoral politics. He does, however, have a history of bashing George W. Bush and the neoconservatives with whom he clashed inside the Bush administration when Powell was secretary of state. For the past seven years, Wilkerson has asserted that many prisoners held at Guantanamo are innocent, descried “the ruinous foreign policy of George W. Bush,” and asserted that Powell was the “only sane member” of the Bush administration.
In 2006, he endorsed Virginia senatorial candidate James Webb, telling reporters that Sen. George Allen had acted “as a Bush clone.” These are defensible positions, perhaps even courageous ones -- but this is hardly the profile of a person who speaks for the Republican Party.
As for Wilkerson’s larger point that the GOP is “full of racists” who want Obama out of office because of the color of his skin, the logic is circular: This claim, and it’s not a new one, hinges on a perception that Obama has been a terrific president. Ergo, the only reason anyone could have for wanting him out of office is . . . his race.
The speciousness of this position should be obvious. Ideology is mainly what drives voting patterns in our politically polarized country. Obama is too liberal for about half the country, just as Romney is too conservative for the other half. Romney’s real challenge in the 2012 campaign, in fact, has been expanding his support beyond the generic Republican base. In other words, he’s had trouble attracting voters other than those who would back any Republican against any Democratic presidential candidate -- Bill Clinton, for instance.
Moreover, it seems strange that anyone would have to justify a desire to vote against an incumbent president when 23 million Americans are unemployed or underemployed, the federal debt is ballooning by a trillion dollars a year, and homeowners in entire swaths of the country are underwater on their mortgages. Obama, holding his own in job approval rating, and running even or ahead of Romney in the head-to-head matchup is -- by historical standards -- actually out-performing his white predecessors.
The real story of the 2012 campaign, then, is how much support Obama has in this country given the tepid performance of the economy during his tenure in the White House.
Pursuing a line of argumentation that posits the opposite is a tactical stance evidently designed to appeal to white guilt and the ethnic pride of people of color. That’s politics, but it comes with a potentially steep price.
If Democrats prevail in running this kind of campaign, they are going to re-elect a president congressional Republicans will be disinclined to work with -- or even trust. If Romney wins, millions of Americans will never believe his victory was legitimate.
In the latter scenario, one part of this would be Republicans’ own fault, however. Unless it is done very carefully, cracking down on voter fraud, which states controlled by Republican legislatures and governors have been trying to do, will have the effect of curbing minority voter participation on Nov. 6.
You’d hope there would be places the two political parties wouldn’t go to win an election. You’d hope.

Jon Finer’s Old and Dangerous ‘New Approach’ to Israel
Peter Berkowitz • RealClearPolitics
The President Deserves Better
John Ullyot • RealClearPolitics
Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
