
Women's Roles: Sizing Up the GOP, Dem Conventions
Published Aug. 25, 2012 • Read time: 12m
In a presidential election in which female voters are expected to play an outsize role in picking the winner, one of the curiosities at the Tampa and Charlotte conventions will be how the parties feature women and contrast their issues at the two heavily scripted events.
Unlike in 2008, there’s no Hillary Clinton hatchet-burying to lend drama among the Democrats (Secretary of State Clinton is not permitted to attend President Obama’s political celebration because of her government position, but Bill Clinton will have a big role).
And the Republicans are poised to embrace a budget wonk steeped in Congress as their bet to deliver a bounce to Mitt Romney. Paul Ryan is a different kind of national surprise than the one engineered by John McCain four years ago, when Sarah Palin and her boffo acceptance speech helped deliver a brief, net 20-point bounce to the ticket among white women, according to one poll.
In Tampa, Condoleezza Rice is considered a celebrity female draw, and Ann Romney, who was scheduled to speak on the first night of the GOP convention, is now expected to do so on Tuesday night instead. (Even before Tropical Storm Isaac forced the cancellation of the opening day schedule, the broadcast networks announced they would cover only one hour of nightly convention programming over three nights in each city.)
On television, nearly 20 million women watched Obama deliver his acceptance speech in Denver last time, and 19.2 million women watched McCain’s speech, according to the Nielsen Co.
The FBI Gained Access; We'd Already Lost Our Privacy
Is Trump Right About NATO?
Arizona's Voting Rights Fire Bell
U.S. Officials Say 2 Americans Died in Brussels Attack
Granted, 2012 has the contours of 2004 more than the history-making ingredients of 2008. And Americans don’t rely on network television for political information the way their parents (or their older siblings) once did. Nevertheless, large broadcast audiences are predicted to tune in to see the nominees’ speeches, and both parties are crafting convention programs to attract viewers. The party insiders get plenty of attention, but TV holds sway.
And in Charlotte, half of the Democratic delegates and alternates, or about 3,000, will be women this year.
The “Akin Effect”?
Republicans insist they will not pander while in Tampa to what they regard as the artifice of gender politics, according to members of the team in charge of the convention next week.
Obama has used the “legitimate rape” comments by Missouri Republican Senate candidate Todd Akin as a way to tie Romney and Ryan firmly to the GOP platform on social issues.
“Ryan is Todd Akin’s ideological twin,” said a senior Obama campaign official during a briefing for political reporters Thursday.
Romney supporters believe most voters will not hold the GOP nominee responsible for Akin’s remarks, especially after Romney denounced what Akin said and urged the candidate to withdraw from his challenge to Sen. Claire McCaskill.
“Todd Akin is a fool and demonstrated terrible judgment,” former Republican National Committee spokeswoman Lisa Miller told RCP. “While I have no doubt that the Democrats will try to paint Republicans with that broad brush, I don't believe his stupid comments will have a lasting impact. Women voters are smart enough to know one dumb comment isn't reflective of an entire political party. And any politician silly enough to use that as a weapon is just as uneducated as Todd Akin was for saying what he said.”
Miller said Republicans will want to see conservative GOP women celebrated in Tampa. “We're going to have to count on the strong roster of accomplished female Republicans who are speaking next week,” she said, adding how “excited” she will be to hear Rice address the gathering, especially in the wake of her admittance to the formerly men-only Augusta National Golf Club.
Democrats are mistaken if they imagine Romney will overhaul his convention program because of sensitivities about Akin’s remarks, said convention spokesman Kyle Downey.
“Democrats want to do anything to distract from Barack Obama’s failed record on the economy,” he told RCP.
Republicans announced Thursday that Nebraska Senate candidate Deb Fischer will speak at the convention, as will Indiana House candidate Jackie Walorski. By comparison, 15 male congressional candidates will speak.
Organizers of the three-day event hope to keep the spotlight on the ailing economy. Romney’s campaign believes attempts to cater to targeted demographic groups -- or “slicing and dicing” the country among important blocs of voters, including women and Latinos, as Romney says Obama is trying to do -- distract from the objective.
A Segmented Strategy
Republican convention organizers and party officials suggest the GOP nominee’s challenge is to rise above Obama’s strategy of appealing to demographic groups.
Maybe so, but in Iowa this week, Romney returned his focus to women voters in that swing state, much as he did last spring, when he argued that Obama was responsible for elevated unemployment among women compared with men ("92.3 percent of the job losses,” Romney asserted, “has been women who've lost those jobs" -- a reference to federal data that ignored much higher, earlier job losses among men, which typically precede those among women in a recession).
At the time, Romney insisted the president’s “failed” economic policies turned “the clock back 20 years” for women. Obama and Vice President Biden returned fire this summer, suggesting Romney and Ryan would force women to revisit the 1950s because of what they said are “extreme” positions the running mates staked out on abortion, contraception funding, and women’s health.
Ads from the president and his campaign make much of the former Massachusetts governor’s pledge, if elected, to eliminate federal support for Planned Parenthood. The Chicago campaign believes women across the political spectrum -- including independent voters -- support Planned Parenthood as a trusted provider of preventative health services to women of all ages, not just abortions. Indeed, during her husband’s last run for president, Ann Romney confirmed that she donated $150 to Planned Parenthood in 1994.
At the Charlotte convention, Cecile Richards, president of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, will have a speaking role, as will Nancy Keenan, president of NARAL Pro-Choice America.
Obama currently leads Romney among women in Colorado, for example, so the president has made direct appeals to that slice of the electorate while campaigning there earlier this month. Georgetown University law student Sandra Fluke -- who told Congress birth control should be covered by employer-provided health insurance, prompting Rush Limbaugh to call her a “sl*t” -- will have a speaking role in Charlotte. She recently introduced Obama at a Denver campaign event with a rousing speech critical of Romney.
Stories to Tell
Democrats have been eager to tout the party’s rosters of women storytellers who will be part of the program in Charlotte, even if the program has not been set in stone.
In 2008, the moving appearance of the late Sen. Edward Kennedy to discuss health care reform brought audiences to tears. This year, niece Caroline Kennedy Schlossberg will carry the Kennedy legacy into the hall.
Massachusetts Senate candidate Elizabeth Warren, who is campaigning to defeat incumbent Scott Brown, is cast as a warrior for consumer protection. She is credited by Democrats for designing an independent Consumer Financial Protection Board as part of the financial reform law that Republicans say they oppose.
Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius will help Obama narrate his pitch about the Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as “Obamacare.” The president’s advisers believe health care reform remains a powerful inducement to Hispanics to support Obama in November.
And Small Business Administration head Karen Mills will speak about entrepreneurs -- men and women who built their businesses into engines of growth and new hiring. Rep. Tammy Baldwin, who is vying with former Gov. Tommy Thompson for Wisconsin’s open Senate seat, also is set to speak, along with Democratic “women of the U.S. Senate.”
A senior Obama campaign official confirmed that House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi will address the convention as the highest ranking female Democrat in Congress.
Using video, taped presentations, the Web, text messaging, and social media, Democrats intend to raise money and awareness among Obama supporters, and deploy testimonials from Americans who are willing to explain how the president’s policies have benefited them. Speakers in Charlotte are expected to tell personal anecdotes to sketch out contrasts between the two presidential candidates.
“This convention will define the election as a choice between two very different paths for our nation, particularly when it comes to the health and economic security of women and middle-class families,” said Melanie Roussell, spokeswoman for the Democratic National Committee.
The themes designed to interest women are essentially economic ones, Obama’s campaign team believes. Health care and Medicare, pay equity and tax fairness, college affordability and access to education, small business creation and jobs, consumer protection, help for children, and reproductive rights will form a narrative in Charlotte aimed squarely at the economy, the middle class, and what’s at stake if Republicans gain control of the White House.
Obama has not borrowed or invented ideas to graft onto his convention, his aides insist. Issues that affect women are issues he has discussed in every campaign speech he’s delivered. “We have not shied away from talking about women’s issues,” said a senior campaign official who declined to speak on the record. “These are issues women care about, families care about.”
Slogan of the Day
With Tea Party favorite Ryan as his running mate, Romney has formed “the most radical ticket,” added a campaign official. In so doing, the official said, Romney narrowed his bandwidth among the electorate when many Republicans hoped he could accomplish the opposite against Obama in key battleground states.
“They have no ability to expand their base,” a top member of the president’s campaign told reporters flatly. “It’s difficult to see them get persuadable voters.”
Republicans are not taking that bait. Rather than make direct appeals based on focused issues like women’s health, the Romney campaign and its allies are doubling down on an economic-minded message.
Despite a topsy-turvy primary season, and a campaign that has produced painful reminders about the party’s problems as a result of the nation’s changing demographics, Republicans believe they can topple the president because the economy remains in a trough.
“This convention will bring together Americans from every corner of the country and every walk of life,” Tampa convention CEO William Harris said in a statement. “Whatever their background, wherever they’re from, they know too well that our country faces serious problems. But they also know that the American people have confronted difficult challenges before, and that together, with strong leadership, we can overcome those challenges and secure a better future for generations to come.”
The Republican convention’s theme, “A Better Future,” and nightly programming are expected to underscore the party’s assertion that Romney and his running mate are better for America’s bank account.
On the now-cancelled first night, convention speakers were to repeat the line “We can do better.” On Tuesday, it’s “We built it,” to exploit Obama’s now infamous comment to small business owners that “You didn’t build that.” By Wednesday, it’s back to a slogan almost identical to Monday’s: “We can change it.” Although convention officials have yet to outline many of the details for Thursday, the night Romney accepts his party’s nomination, the standard-bearer is certain to tout the policies he and Ryan support.
Consequently, party officials say there is no reason to alter their convention lineup to try to curry favor with women. That’s the story they stuck to Wednesday as they watched Todd Akin defy Romney’s pressure to withdraw from a race. Akin, who apologized to voters in his state for his “legitimate rape” comment, said he would continue his race against Claire McCaskill. In the background as that drama played out was the GOP platform committee’s decision to oppose abortion in all cases -- including those involving rape and incest.
Republicans with leverage in Washington note, however, that the platform that will be voted on by delegates next week caters to the most conservative activists in the party and is not representative of what elected GOP officials will pursue in office over the next years.
As one convention official put it to RCP, “The platform is just a piece of paper.”
Women on the Podium
The bigger reason for not adapting to the week’s news, they say, is that the roster of speakers already scheduled to appear each night in Tampa includes plenty of women and is generally diverse.
The convention lineup does include women and shows other shades of diversity, but plentiful may not be the most apt description. When RNC Chairman Reince Priebus announced a half-dozen “headliners” for the convention, just one was a woman: New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte, whose name was bandied about earlier this year as part of Romney’s veepstakes. Of course, of the six names on the list, hers appeared first. (Listed just beneath it was former Alabama Rep. Artur Davis, who is black -- and who recently switched parties. Beneath him was Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal. Three white men came next on the list.)
Three women had been slated to appear on Monday night -- Puerto Rican first lady Luce Vela Fortuno, South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley and Washington Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers. Seven men, ranging from House Speaker John Boehner to former presidential hopeful Mike Huckabee, had also been scheduled.
Tuesday night features six women: Utah congressional candidate Mia Love, Delaware lieutenant governor candidate Sher Valenzuela, New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez, Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin, Ayotte and actress Janine Turner. Balancing out the lineup are six male speakers, including convention keynoter Chris Christie.
The presence of women drops off sharply on Wednesday night, when about 10 speakers are set to hit the podium. Just two are women: Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, who was an early supporter of Romney’s, and Rice, who will introduce vice presidential nominee Paul Ryan.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
