
How Romney Might Rate the VP Contenders
Published July 17, 2012 • Read time: 9m
Join the Conversation
0I've avoided "veepstakes" pieces this cycle. RCP's Scott Conroy really hit the proverbial nail on the head back in June, when he observed that running-mate predictions tend to miss the mark (this is, for whatever reason, especially true of GOP picks). Ultimately, we’re trying to make a prediction about the actions of a single individual, about whom we really know very little. This makes it very difficult to do.
So rather than make an out-and-out prediction, I thought it would be worthwhile to engage in a bit of a “pre-buttal” to the selection. I’ve created a grid featuring the potential picks I’ve heard the most about, evaluated against 10 factors that probably inform Mitt Romney’s thinking. Those factors are:
1) Socially conservative: Romney’s pick will almost certainly have to tick this box. Social conservatism tends to be a requirement for winning the Republican nomination, but given Romney’s questionable conservative history on social issues, it is probably especially important to him. Given his late flip-flop on abortion, I’ve given pro-choice picks a negative one, as such a selection would probably invite an outright rebellion at the convention.
2) Not scary: At the same time, Romney has to avoid choosing a running mate whose social conservatism would become a lightning rod, and tend to dominate the debate. There are years where a fight over social issues helps the GOP, but this probably isn’t one of them.
3) Swing state: VP selections probably aren’t worth more than a point or two in a given state. That said, in a close election (which most expect this one to be) a point or two can make a big difference.
Lies, Assault and Cover-ups Don't Stop Donald Trump
Trump Stands by His Man; Obama on a Health Scourge; Hayden Interview; Reagan's Courage
Analysis: For Trump, Few Limits to Win-At-Any-Cost Approach
What If Clinton Isn't Indicted?
4) Swing demographic: Similar to swing state -- if a candidate can appeal to a critical swing constituency, especially one disproportionately represented in a key swing state, it can move the dial enough to make a difference. Simply put, if Al Gore hadn’t picked Joe Lieberman as his running mate, Florida probably would not have gone down to a recount.
5) Governor: One of the best things that Romney has going for him is that he hasn’t been in Washington the past few years. Picking someone else from outside the Beltway would be a plus for him. Moreover, “competent executive” is one of Romney’s campaign themes; picking another executive reinforces this argument.
6) No Bush connections: At the same time, Romney doesn’t want to play directly into the Democrats’ arguments. Nothing will be repeated more often than the assertion that electing Romney would mean a return to the policies of George W. Bush. Picking someone who served in Bush’s administration would only reinforce that line of attack.
7) Adequate experience: Call this the “Palin issue.” Romney will want someone who is ready for prime time, and who preferably has served at least a full term in office.
8) “First do no harm”: To be sure, every vice presidential pick opens up new lines of attack, as no politician is without his or her warts. At the same time, some attacks hurt more than others, some politicians would overshadow Romney, and some politicians are particularly gaffe-prone.
9) Excites the base: Romney doesn’t exactly excite conservatives; he’s largely relying upon discontent with President Obama to turn out the base. A vice president who excites the base in the way Palin did in ’08 (without the negatives) would be a substantial asset.
10) Loyalty: All politicians appreciate this trait and want to reward it. This isn’t a year like 1980 for the Republicans or 1960 for the Democrats, where there are obvious benefits to selecting an opponent from a different wing of the party in order to promote party unity or to seek regional advantage. Romney will prefer someone who has been a “Romney guy” all along; I gave credit to anyone who endorsed Romney before February.
Let’s now analyze each factor against each vice presidential choice:
1) Tim Pawlenty. You can see why he tops so many lists. The Minnesota governor really checks off almost all of the boxes: He’s socially conservative, without any unusually socially conservative views; he’s from a state that has moved steadily toward the Republicans over the past few decades (in terms of PVI); and he connects with the coveted blue-collar white demographic. He’s an experienced governor with no significant Bush ties, and he endorsed Romney early on. The only major drawback is that the base would yawn; if he were more exciting, he’d be the obvious choice.
2) Kelly Ayotte. She checks off a lot of the same boxes as Pawlenty, and is something of a stealth conservative. If you take Barack Obama’s 2008 showing in states or districts where Republicans ran competitive races in 2010, Ayotte ran farther ahead of Obama than any other Republican in a competitive race. Her major drawback is that she’s a stiff stump speaker, doesn’t have a wealth of experience, and would probably bore the base. She’d also draw instant Palin comparisons, although this in many ways presents an opportunity for her: If she performs well, the storyline instantly is about how much stronger than Palin she is.
3) Marco Rubio. He is lot like Ayotte, except that he’d thrill the base, and he endorsed Romney late in the game. Query whether he gets a full point for “swing demographic,” and whether a Cuban-American has as much appeal to other Latinos as many suspect. Also, his Mormon background could potentially bring the “no harm” factor into question under these circumstances.
4) Rob Portman. The Ohio senator brings a lot to the table, though he doesn’t have a lot of swing demographic experience, has never been a governor, and is boring. That said, a lot of smart people think his organization made the difference for Romney in the Ohio primary, and that could prove critical in the fall. Probably the biggest negative for Portman is that he was Bush’s OMB director, which is one of the worst Bush administration positions to have in this race.
5) John Thune. He is kind of the ultimate “do no harm” candidate -- he doesn’t really check off any of the “positive” boxes, but he avoids the negative ones as well.
6) Paul Ryan: The Wisconsin congressman might not have unusually conservative social views, but his economic stance is terrible for a Republican Party that wants to attract blue-collar whites. Romney has endorsed the Ryan budget plan, so maybe his negatives are already built in, and maybe it would be good to have a vice president who could explain that plan well. I doubt that though; in this case the “no harm” category should probably be a “negative one.”
7) Susana Martinez: It’s questionable whether she should be included, given that she’s more or less disqualified herself. New Mexico isn’t really a swing state, she wouldn’t excite the base much, and she hasn’t been particularly enthusiastic about Romney. She could really have problems with the experience question, however -- like Ayotte, she held a fairly obscure position two years ago, but unlike Ayotte, she has not been on the national stage since 2010. On the other hand, she is Mexican-American, and even a moderate shift in the Mexican-American vote toward Romney could make the difference in Nevada and Colorado.
8) Bob McDonnell: Virginia’s efforts to require women to undergo trans-vaginal ultrasounds before getting an abortion has tarnished McDonnell’s vice presidential stock as much as anything. If we agree that Romney wants to avoid a fight over abortion in the general election, McDonnell is probably off the table.
9) Brian Sandoval: He is probably disqualified because of his pro-choice views. But for that, the governor of Nevada and former federal judge would probably be near the top of most lists.
10) Chris Christie: Many would be surprised to see Christie this low. Romney may end up picking him, given that the boost to the base’s morale would be significant. But Christie isn’t really a social conservative, and his support of civil unions could give the religious right heartburn. In addition, I’m not sure that Christie’s “straight talk” would play well outside of New Jersey; Midwesterners in particular could find some his verbiage decidedly unpresidential.
11) Mitch Daniels: I always scratched my head when conservatives seemed to think that Bush’s OMB director -- from the time when Bush’s deficits were the worst -- was the perfect foil for the president. Given his call for a truce on the culture wars -- among other statements -- it isn’t clear how much social conservatives would really consider Daniels to be “one of them.” An overhyped choice.
12) Bobby Jindal: The Jindal buzz is growing but remains puzzling. He’s not from a swing state, doesn’t represent a swing demographic, and endorsed Rick Perry. More importantly, fairly or unfairly, the “college exorcism” story is a huge negative, especially with Romney at the top of the ticket. He has Bush ties (he was an official at HHS), and his youthful looks cut down on the “gravitas” factor.
13) Rick Perry: I don’t hear his name that much, but it does come up some. He doesn’t really connect with a swing demographic or represent a swing state, and his gaffes would dominate the post-veepstakes coverage. And if there were another “oops” moment on the national stage, it would be hard to recover from.
14) Condi Rice: I half chuckled and half shook my head when I heard her name dropped last week. Her “mildly pro-choice” comments are probably disqualifying. She might enhance the ticket’s appeal with women, but beyond that, I don’t think she’d bring much: Her appeal to the African-American community is probably marginal at best, especially with Obama atop the Democratic ticket, and her Bush ties are the opposite of what Romney needs.
It’s ultimately Romney’s choice, of course, and he almost certainly views some of these factors differently than the even-weighting approach I used. That’s what ultimately makes this so unpredictable. Remember also, that people usually vote for president, not vice president. Still, to the extent that vice presidents really matter, this is how I’d rate the various choices.
UPDATE: A few commenters have suggested Mike Huckabee. Failing to include him was an error, and I’ve added him. He checks the social conservative box, the swing demographic box, the no Bush ties, and the experience/governor boxes. On the other hand, his public agreement with a Southern Baptist Convention statement that a wife should submit to her husband would be toxic for a lot of swing voters (regardless of your interpretation of the statement and the Biblical verse). We can debate whether he’d excite the base. I tend to think his rather public opposition to Club for Growth and continued embrace of “compassionate conservatism” are problems with today’s GOP, though perhaps Romney’s strength in these areas offsets them.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
