
Could Kelly Ayotte's Rapid Rise Lead to VP?
Published June 8, 2012 • Read time: 10m
In less than two years' time, Kelly Ayotte has gone from obscure New Hampshirite to one of the more visible figures in national politics.
The freshman senator is often photographed alongside Mitt Romney as one of his leading surrogates on the campaign trail (and the most high-profile female surrogate other than his wife), and the Senate Republican leadership trots her out frequently to go before cameras and drive their message on whatever legislation they’re pushing. No wonder Romney has named her publicly as one of about 15 people who might be on his list of potential running mates.
But anyone who dismisses her from the veepstakes chatter because she is an attractive woman in her early forties, who ascended to statewide office in the most recent election -- thereby inviting obvious comparisons to former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin -- would be writing her off unfairly. So, too, would anyone who says such attributes are the only reasons for her rise. At 43, Ayotte is one of the three youngest members of the upper chamber, along with Florida’s Marco Rubio and Utah’s Mike Lee (R) -- both 41 and Republicans -- all of whom were elected in 2010.
She spent five years as the Granite State’s attorney general, prosecuting murder cases and even arguing a case before the Supreme Court, before she entered the Senate. She helped launch her husband’s business, a snowplowing and landscaping company. And in her time in Washington, she’s set herself apart by joining the Armed Services Committee and making the high-profile battle over Guantanamo detainees her pet issue -- key national security credentials that could help bolster the Republican ticket in an area where Romney lacks experience.
As Steve Duprey, Ayotte’s campaign finance chairman in the 2010 election, put it in an interview, “Whenever people tell me she doesn’t have the experience for this, I tell them she has as much or more experience as then-Sen. Obama had to be president when he was running in 2008. So it doesn’t surprise me at all that Governor Romney would be considering her.”
And yet, though some of her Senate colleagues have been cagy regarding their status as potential running mates, Ayotte was perfectly open during an interview in her Senate office Thursday morning.
“I’ve not been contacted, and I certainly don’t have any really . . .” She trailed off before finishing the point, then added, “I’m focused on what I’m doing in the Senate.”
Of course, Duprey’s wife, Susan, travels with Ann Romney on the campaign trail and has become a “close confidante” to the presumptive nominee’s wife, according to the Boston Globe, meaning the Dupreys might have an inkling about whom the Romneys are considering.
Ayotte came to politics in a far different way than Mitt Romney did. She was born and raised in Nashua, N.H., in a military family, left the state for a degree in political science at Penn State, and got a law degree at Villanova, returning to Nashua afterward to become a prosecutor. She married another Nashua native, Joe Daley, who is a veteran of Desert Storm and now runs that landscaping and snowplowing business, Daley Outdoor Services.
That background as well as her husband’s (her closest political adviser) are what helped Ayotte obtain some plum committee assignments in the Senate: The Armed Services Committee, the Budget Committee, the Commerce Committee and the Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee. She’s brought expertise to the table in each of those areas, but emphasizes that she does a considerable amount of homework to get up to speed on specific issues.
Homework is something she says she’s used to doing from her days as attorney general, and it’s an important skill for a politician to have if one needed to prepare on the fly for, say, the presidency. Indeed, her last two high-profile jobs in public service came as something of a surprise -- or perhaps just earlier than she expected -- and she rose to the challenge on both occasions.
Although the first-term senator said in the interview that she had considered herself on track to become attorney general eventually, her predecessor, Peter Heed, resigned the office after being accused by a woman of sexual advances at a conference. Ayotte, the deputy attorney general at the time, was then appointed to the top post while seven months pregnant with her first child, Kate (now 7.)
“I appreciated the opportunity,” she said, adding, “I think my career was heading toward that, but as I said at the time, I could have picked better circumstances.” (Heed, a friend and supporter of Ayotte’s, denied wrongdoing and is now serving as a county attorney in New Hampshire.)
“I literally became attorney general and then had our daughter, Kate.” While in that job she had the couple’s second child, Jacob (now 4). “The people of New Hampshire have seen me at various stages of pregnancy,” she joked.
Of course, that is also part of her appeal.
Duprey suggested: “One of the great hallmarks of Kelly, both as a person and as a senator, is that she is a regular person, who knows what it's like to think about getting kids off to school.” And he noted that even as a Senate candidate, she would take out her husband’s snowplows to help keep their business rolling during famously treacherous New Hampshire snowstorms.
After her appointment by a Republican governor, Ayotte established a strong relationship with the local law enforcement and was twice reappointed to the post by Democratic Gov. John Lynch. Members of the Granite State political class kept their eyes on Ayotte as a future political candidate, but she had never run for office before, and it wasn’t clear how she’d make the leap.
When Judd Gregg decided in early 2009 not only to decline President Obama’s offer to run the Commerce Department but also to retire from his Senate seat, he and Republicans in Washington and New Hampshire approached Ayotte to run for it.
Asked why he threw his weight behind her when a trio of other Republicans was waiting in the wings, National Republican Senatorial Committee Chairman John Cornyn told RCP this week: “That’s easy. Judd Gregg told me she was the best candidate. So my wife and I flew up to New Hampshire and met with her and Joe. She’s been a rock star.”
Cornyn’s senior staff at the campaign organization may grumble about candidates in certain races from time to time -- as all Washington-based party committees are known to do -- but throughout the 2010 cycle, they were effusive in their praise for Ayotte, often calling her their favorite candidate.
Although Duprey lavished praise on his boss’s willingness to put forth all the effort needed as a candidate (“She was willing to make all the finance calls,” he said, noting that most candidates loathe the fundraising portion of the gig), it wasn’t then that she ascended to rock-star status.
Indeed, she wasn’t known for electrifying speeches the way fellow freshman Rubio was as a candidate in the 2010 midterms. That, in fact, was an area in which she needed some improvement, as she was used to speaking in more intimate settings as attorney general. But she underwent some speech training to overcome what may have been nerves in those bigger settings, which caused her voice to waver at times. And, according to Duprey, “she has come a long, long way.”
Where Ayotte did begin to stand out was in the Senate. So much so that she’s already made her debut on NBC’s “Meet the Press.”
Young Kate and Jacob accompanied her and husband Joe to Washington when she was sworn in in early January 2011. At a reception in the Russell building that day, she held Jake in her left arm, appeasing the shy toddler with juice, while using her right arm to shake hands with the new lobbyists she was about to start hearing from. (Daley and the kids still live in Nashua, where Ayotte says lots of family members help out.)
Soon after, she traveled with colleagues Mitch McConnell, Pat Toomey, Ron Johnson and Rubio to Afghanistan and realized she wanted a slot on the Armed Services Committee, where John McCain serves as the ranking Republican.
Having become close to McCain during her Senate campaign, thanks to an introduction from Duprey (who had traveled with McCain during the 2008 race), Ayotte had a mentor willing to help her onto the panel.
Pointing out that Ayotte had some ease with the committee’s issues based on what she gleaned from her husband’s experience in Desert Storm (and, regarding detainees, from prosecuting cases as an attorney general), McCain said, “It’s really been productive to work with her on a variety issues.”
He added, “She’s been really important in the debate on the floor on detainee issues. She’s also been involved a lot with readiness -- in other words, what we need to keep our planes flying and our ships at sea. And finally she is now progressing towards having a strategic view of America’s role, particularly in the Pacific as we shift militarily to the Pacific region.”
Though acknowledging that fiscal issues trump national security ones politically in this election cycle, Ayotte noted, “Even when it’s not on the top of Americans’ minds, they expect us to be prepared and ready, and they shouldn’t have to worry about those issues. There should be people that are constantly worrying about them. “
When it comes to politics, though, she made a smart gamble in betting on Romney, even though her political advisers had encouraged her to stay out of the presidential primary.
Last summer, rumors were flying from each of the presidential campaigns about whether Ayotte even liked Romney, who chose not to endorse a candidate in the contested Republican Senate primary in her state in 2010, in part because longtime Romney backer Ovide Lamontagne was one of those in the mix.
Asked to address those rumors, she laughed. “If I were Mitt Romney, I wouldn’t have gotten involved in our primary, either. It wouldn’t have made sense. . . . I didn’t think much about that at all, or think anything of it, or have any concerns about it.”
She and her husband met with Mitt and Ann Romney several times throughout the primary process, as they did with the other candidates trekking through the first-in-the-nation primary state. The Romney campaign pushed hard for the endorsement, but it was a November breakfast meeting the two couples had at the Riverwalk Café in Nashua that sealed it for her. And in December, they bonded further during a bus tour of the state.
“Getting to know him on a more personal level, he’s just a good person who’s really sincere,” she said. “On the bus, the more time my husband and I spent with Mitt and Ann Romney, the stronger I felt about my endorsement. I got to see and interact with him and his family. You see how genuine they are and what a close-knit family they are, and you hear the stories about what they’ve done together.”
Romney aides say he genuinely likes Ayotte, too, and sees a lot of potential in her. At the very least, he’s been consulting her about the national security issues she’s focused on.
“Last time I saw him,” she said, “we were talking about foreign policy issues because of some things I’ve been working on on the Senate Armed Services Committee, and so those are issues I care very much about, and he’s very conversant in them, so we had a lot of back and forth on it, and I really enjoyed it.”
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






