It's Not Easy Being Rich
Published May 17, 2012 • Read time: 6m
I don't know about you, but I'm starting to feel kind of bad for rich people. Money, the media repeatedly remind us, is terrible, particularly when it’s in the hands of the fabled 1 percent -- like, say, Mitt Romney, who reportedly has $250 million jangling around in his undoubtedly fancy pants.
Pundits remind us that earning this much money is an obvious sign of sheer, out-of-touch cluelessness. (If Romney were to win, the only president richer than him in the history of the United States would be George Washington, and we all know what an abysmal, slipshod job that guy did.) Even worse, as the Obama campaign insists in a recent ad, was the source of Romney’s millions: Bain Capital, an evil, heartless “vampire” of a corporation, leaving nothing but destruction and sad, jobless steelworkers in its wake.
The hits keep on coming: This week, Edward Conard, described in a New York Times profile as a “spectacularly wealthy guy,” a member of the “0.1 percent” and a former Romney colleague at Bain, hit the media circuit to promote his new book, dedicated to (yes, get ready) the glories of income inequality. Conard claims to want to help the Romney campaign, and he donates accordingly. But meanwhile, he continues to rub salt in one of the media’s favorite wounds: the assertion that rich people like Mitt Romney are hopelessly insensitive to today’s economic woes, cosseted by car elevators, silver-spoon stay-at-home wives, and fancy, head-tossing Massachusetts horses that, like their owners, undoubtedly think they’re better than you.
Free market enthusiasts, it turns out, can sometimes be terrible salesmen. With this in mind, it’s worth exploring Harvard professor Michael J. Sandel’s new book, “What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets.” Sandel’s argument, which cautions against “market triumphalism” and the expanding spheres of market influence, has been gaining an impressive amount of buzz, most recently from a gushing Thomas Friedman in last Sunday’s New York Times. (As The Atlantic’s Conor Friedersdorf amusingly points out, Friedman’s review, headlined “This Column Is Not Sponsored By Anyone,” sits directly below “a Citi/American Airlines credit card” ad on NYTimes.com.)
“What Money Can’t Buy” argues that markets, much like that 350-pound guy sitting next to you in United Airlines coach class, are starting to creep beyond their rightful bounds. Decades of “faith that markets are the primary means for achieving the public good,” Sandel argues, have allowed them to sneak into all spheres of life, not just the economy -- and, he argues, the results aren’t good. “Today,” Sandel writes, “almost everything is up for sale,” including access to high-end doctors; the right to shoot an endangered species ($150,000 for a black rhino); the book-reading frequency of small children (in Dallas, public schools pay kids $2 for each book consumed); and, in extreme cases, your body (a plucky but short-sighted Utah woman, for instance, earned $10,000 to have a casino’s name permanently tattooed on her forehead).
While “What Money Can’t Buy” misses the boat on some big-picture policy solutions (more on that later), hard-core free market enthusiasts would do well to digest some of its larger points. All human action, Sandel asserts, cannot “be understood in the image of a market.” Contrary to the libertarian economic credo, people are not always rational actors who work to maximize their welfare (see Houston, Whitney; Madoff, Bernie; Beverly Hills, Real Housewives of). And yes, even though Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and bloated government bureaucracy played a large role in the recent financial crisis, so did good old-fashioned incompetence and greed.
Free market acolytes will balk at the premise that the market is anything but an efficient, elegant mechanism, solving humanity’s problems one by one. But just like people, markets aren’t always perfect -- and neither are corporations. (JPMorgan, I’m looking at you.) More importantly, Sandel argues, markets can also impact norms and values, and commercialization can corrupt certain goods.
“The more markets extend their reach into noneconomic spheres of life,” the author points out, “the more entangled they become with moral questions.” Would a market for, say, getting out of a civic duty like jury duty, or selling spare body parts, or offering upgraded prison cells be good on a practical level? Perhaps. But they might also fundamentally debase certain values along they way.
Beleaguered libertarians, however, should take heart. While “What Money Can’t Buy” makes worthwhile points on the periphery -- the tawdriness of baseball announcers forced to call each home run a “Bank One Blast,” the creepy rise of life insurance betting markets based on other people’s likelihood to die -- when it comes to solving most of our pressing public policy problems, market-based solutions still appear to be the best way to go.
When Sandel bemoans the increased reach of advertising in public schools, for instance, he fires off this gem: “Rather than raise the public funds we need to educate our children, we choose instead to sell their time and rent their minds to Burger King and Mountain Dew.” This should prompt a major eye-roll from anyone familiar with the real financial problems of government schools, which are mostly caused by lack of, well, markets: near-zero competition, bloated administrative costs, and the iron grip of bureaucratic teachers unions.
Similarly, American health care suffers not from excessive market reach but from an awful hybrid of government regulation mixed with markets -- Karl Marx and Wal-Mart, blended into a nightmarish, chunky stew.
In the end, Sandel calls for increased public discourse on the issues of “ethics, morality and virtue," which is certainly admirable. But after that discourse, one big moral question remains: Who ultimately decides for society? Sandel doesn’t name a market alternative, but one somehow suspects it has to do with government.
Markets can be messy. They certainly don’t merit near-religious, absolutist devotion. But, warts and all, markets have also lifted millions of people out of poverty around the world, encouraged political, religious, and social freedom, and created an American society rich and spoiled enough to spend a large part of April debating whether or not it’s better for a presidential candidate to put a dog on the roof of a car (Romney) or eat one as a child (Obama).
And if that’s not a luxury, I don’t know what is.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






