
The State of Our Politics
Published Jan. 24, 2012 • Read time: 13m
Join the Conversation
0In advance of President Obama's State of the Union address tonight, we conclude our series framing the issues that face the nation.
One year ago, after the shooting and wounding of Arizona Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, many members of Congress put aside their petty animosities -- as well as deeply held philosophical differences -- and sat together for the president’s State of the Union address. Democrats with Republicans, liberals with conservatives.
For the plurality of Americans with independent leanings and moderate impulses, it was a nice gesture. It was also temporal, as was the bipartisan singing of “America the Beautiful” on the steps of the U.S. Capitol steps after the attacks of 9/11.
The level of civility in Washington "is a reflection of what’s going on in the rest of the country that seems to be entertained by reality television programs,” says Diana Banister, a public relations veteran who has worked for several Republican candidates, including Bob Dole. “These shows -- ‘Jersey Shore,’ ‘Real Housewives of Wherever,’ et cetera -- show women and men calling each other names, backstabbing, gossiping and pretty much doing whatever it takes to get ahead or win the guy. The culture is awash in incivility; why would politics be any different?”
But there are reasons across-the-aisle cooperation is needed in American politics, ranging from the advantageousness of a cohesive U.S. foreign policy to the fact that real solutions to the nation’s most intractable problems -- massive federal debt, entitlement reform, health care legislation -- truly take root when both major parties are invested in them.
Kids' Lives Matter Too
In a Corner of Ohio, Lessons of 2016
2016 Presidential Election Could Decide State Legislative Races
McCaskill Says No to Run for Missouri Governor
There are also many reasons why across-the-aisle cooperation in Washington has become so rare. These range from gerrymandered congressional districts, ideologically polarized political parties, the flood of unregulated special interest money into campaigns, the exigencies of base politics, the tactics of political consultants, and the splintering of the media, which has both coarsened political discourse and contributed to increasingly self-segregated audiences.
When it comes to what newspapers and magazines Americans read, what television and radio stations they listen to, what websites and blogs they patronize, and which social media groups they belong to, today’s citizenry is all about reinforcing their own views -- and demonizing those of their opponents. The Internet is often blamed for this trend, but the impetus behind these changes predate social media, the World Wide Web, or even cable television.
Opening up the political process in the 1960s and 1970s produced -- from both the left and the right -- a new ethos: The personal is the political. Everyone from feminists, gay rights activists, evangelical conservatives, and muckraking journalists embraced it. The result? Greater accountability of elected officials, perhaps, and the exposure of hypocrisy. But also: impeachment proceedings against a popular president, and savage news coverage of a vice presidential candidate who came from far outside the power corridors of Washington.
As it turns out, personalizing the nature of policy questions leads naturally to character assassination. This impulse now reinforces itself on platforms such as Twitter and Facebook -- and in the comments sections of the most neutral of news outlets.
The United States of America has always hosted robust political discourse, bare-knuckles election campaigns, and free-wheeling public debates. They can be enlightening, even fun. The question is whether we’ve indulged ourselves so much in name-calling and condemnation that when it’s time to cooperate, negotiate, or legislate, no one knows how anymore.
In the summer of 2010, when Sen. Mitch McConnell told National Journal’s Major Garrett that the Republicans strategy is to ensure that Barack Obama is a one-term president, White House aides figured, “Why bother negotiating with this guy?”
For their part, Republicans concluded something similar about Obama in the first week after his inauguration. On Jan. 27, 2009, Obama visited Republicans on Capitol Hill ostensibly asking for their ideas on the stimulus, while votes were already being cast for this legislation on the House floor.
The two major political parties have been talking past each other ever since, and with a presidential election season upon us, this is not going to get better anytime soon. As part of RCP’s own “state of the union” package, we asked several prominent political players and insightful observers of the scene for their thoughts on the “state of our politics.”
Here are their responses:
David Yepsen: Discourse is not civil in American politics. Everyone knows that. The question is what do we do about it? The single biggest change that could improve the discourse is the establishment of non-partisan redistricting systems in each state to redraw legislative and congressional district lines without regard to the party registrations of citizens or the residency of incumbents.
Why? Under the current system, politicians draw safe districts for themselves and their parties and this means we don't have many competitive districts in general elections. Instead, politicians only have to worry about winning primaries and that means courting the zealots and activists that form the base of each party. Democrats have to become more liberal. Republicans more conservative. With more competitive districts, would-be leaders would have to worry about winning voters in the great American middle in general elections. By having to do more than “fire up the base,” our leaders could cool off the rhetoric and opt for a more solution-oriented politics.
(Yepsen is the director of the Paul Simon Public Policy Institute at Southern Illinois University, who previously had a 34-year career with the Des Moines Register, serving as the paper’s chief political writer, political editor and columnist.)
William A. Galston: America’s political parties are more polarized than at any time since the 1890s, obsolete congressional rules produce little except gridlock, and our public discourse is becoming increasingly debased. No wonder problems heap up without being resolved while public trust and confidence in our governing institutions plumbs all-time lows. Political risk analysis is something American analysts used to do about foreign countries; now it’s something foreign analysts do about us.
As happens periodically, the U.S. political system has reached a time of testing. If we can reform Congress, our budgetary process, and the way we structure our elections, the common sense of the American people can once again find expression in our public policies. If not, the fortunes of the middle class will continue to stagnate while our overseas competitors surge ahead.
(Galston was a top domestic policy adviser to President Clinton and is currently at the Brookings Institution doing research that focuses on designing a new social contract and the implications of political polarization.)
Juleanna Glover: The state of our politics is risk-averse and very abashed. Both parties have suffered the lash of public approbation for trying to lead with the principles in which they believe: Democrats with Obamacare and Dodd/Frank and Republicans with efforts to demand that government spend less. As a result, Democrats no longer trumpet their respective legislative successes, and the GOP is tempering its budget demands -- as each pursues their course in the name of winning seats for their jeopardized members.
What the country needs is a Rhett Butler, who once elected, just doesn't give a damn about winning elections and cares solely about implementing the dramatic reforms necessary to spur economic growth. I'm not sure the Republican presidential field has an actor to fit the role. Mitt Romney only looks the part and Newt Gingrich is hardly risk-averse, but has committed his life to winning GOP majorities -- a hard habit to break. And Obama seems too captive to liberalism to be capable of improving U.S. competitiveness. The state of politics is in need of more choices.
(Glover has worked for Vice President Dick Cheney, New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, presidential candidate Steve Forbes, and Sen. John Ashcroft. She advised John McCain in his 2008 presidential bid for the White House, and supported Jon Huntsman this year.)
Edward J. Rollins: Civility in politics today is almost non-existent.
I have been around American politics and government for four decades. I have seen many battles over ideological public policy differences. In the old days sometimes the debate on the House or Senate floor might erupt into angry words in the cloakroom. And more often than not, the battle would get cooled and a compromise or a solution would be found over drinks or dinner in a social environment. People would talk to each other and listen. No more! Now they just yell at each other on cable television. No one listens. If you can’t win in the cable arena, you take it into the gutter of a campaign and attack with negative mail, brutal and dishonest television commercials and social media attacks. Destroy your opponent! Don’t talk or exchange ideas with them.
Today everything starts in the gutter. Today everything is a war!
I grew up and had the privilege of working for Ronald Reagan. Reagan operated under the philosophy of what was called the 11th Commandment: “Thou shalt not speak ill of any fellow Republican,” which was first advocated by Gaylord Parkinson, who was chairman of the California Republican Party when Reagan first ran for governor in 1966.
I thought of that commandment this morning as I read of Mitt Romney’s attack on Newt Gingrich. Instead of congratulating Gingrich on his victory in South Carolina on Saturday and saying, “I look forward to debating you tonight on our ideas,” Romney fired off this attack:
And at the end of four years [as speaker] it was proven that he was a failed leader and he had to resign in disgrace. I don’t know whether you knew that, he actually resigned after four years, in disgrace.
Gingrich could easily fire back, “Speaking of failures, you couldn’t get re-elected governor if you tried; you spent hundreds of days out of the state running unsuccessfully for president in 2008; and your only accomplishment was passing Ted Kennedy’s health care plan that was the model for Obamacare.” And by the way, why don’t you tell us why you have millions of dollars in the same Grand Cayman banks with Columbian and Mexican drug lords?”
All the president has to do to get re-elected is to make our nominee an unacceptable alternative. We are doing it to ourselves. Remember the 11th Commandment. Civility is a winning strategy! Try it!
(Rollins is a veteran GOP consultant and campaign manager of Ronald Reagan’s 1984 re-election campaign.)
Eleanor Clift: It seems to me the sorry state of our politics has moved far beyond a call for civility. For openers, do away with the gentlemanly filibuster. Make every senator who wants to stall a bill do it the old-fashioned way: stay up all night and recite the telephone book. Congress can’t function, and President Obama can’t govern, because a determined minority is holding the country hostage, and the majority of lawmakers are too polite and too worried about a primary challenge to call them out. What’s happening is the equivalent of jury nullification.
Sitting next to a member of the opposition party for the SOTU speech is not going to change that dynamic. Former Senate leader Tom Daschle held hands with Republican Tom Delay on the steps of the Capitol after the 9/11 attacks. It was a nice moment, but nothing more. The voters want leaders who will fight fair and square and out in the open, and not hide behind super PACs. Voters are angry because they think the game is rigged against them, and they’re right.
(Clift is a contributor to Newsweek and longtime television commentator who serves on the board for the Center for Politics and Journalism and the advisory council of the International Women's Media Foundation.)
Mark Salter: The state of our politics is discouraging, to say the least. It’s better than some other rancorous periods in our past, but still, I think, unworthy of the ideals and purposes of our country. And it’s highly unlikely to improve in the immediate future. It’s an election year, which is seldom an occasion for new beginnings. The president has abandoned all pretense of governing through compromise on even small matters like executive appointments. Activists on the right and left have not yet accepted that to succeed politically in a democracy is to choose, and in a divided government to choose less than your heart desires.
I think things will eventually improve, hopefully, in my lifetime. What will change them? Weariness over repeated failure? The disdain of the American people? Maybe. But the American people, God bless them, have chosen the government they disdain, and they can’t fire themselves. Non-partisan redistricting might help -- it’s a longer-term solution than many would like. Perhaps only a severe crisis will motivate Americans and the people they elect to work together and rescue the nation from its follies. That has happened in the past, which gives us some hope it could happen again.
(Salter is the former chief of staff to Sen. John McCain and was a senior adviser to the McCain for President campaign in 2008.)
John Avlon: After the attempted assassination of Gabrielle Giffords one year ago, there was sudden recognition of the costs that can come with the coarsening of civic debate. The shooter was deranged, apolitical -- but his actions began a needed conversation about the way that hate and fear, along with increasingly violent rhetoric, had infiltrated our political conversations. This can create a cycle of incitement, in which extremes inspire equal and opposite reactions -- Bush Derangement Syndrome on the far left is succeeding by Obama Derangement Syndrome on the far right -- taking our nation off-center.
Ultimately, the stability of democracy requires remembering that our political opponents are not our personal enemies. In the last year, we have witnessed considerable slipping back into these ugly old patterns, albeit with new faces. We have seen a recent uptick in “war” rhetoric in our politics -- Rick Perry talking about “Obama’s war on religion” while some Occupiers talk about the GOP's supposed “war on the middle class.”
All this translates to a loss of perspective in our politics -- leading to further breakdown in our ability to self-govern effectively, particularly with divided government. Hyper-partisanship is hurting America because it stops us from solving the serious problems we face. We shouldn't have to wait for an attack to remind us of this most important fact: there is always more that unites us than divides us as Americans.
(Avlon, a Daily Beast columnist and CNN contributor who co-founded the bipartisan group No Labels, is the author of “Independent Nation: How Centrists Can Change American Politics.”
Frank Mankiewicz: I’m not sure the state of our politics is as bad as we’re constantly told. We don’t traditionally “cross the aisle”; we don’t usually compromise or agree -- the majority party usually gets what it wants, and the other one complains and waits for the next election. I think the main trouble now is the 24-hour news cycle, the ability of a new quote or story to “break” every few minutes, and then require learned comment. But mostly it’s -- I think -- the right, the Tea Partiers of the GOP, who have dragged down public discourse, who cheer at the mere mention of executions, sneer at the media, and at coded references like the “food-stamp president“ and “elites in Washington and New York.” New York?
(Mankiewicz, vice chairman of the public relations firm Hill & Knowlton, was Robert F. Kennedy’s press secretary, the director of George McGovern’s 1972 presidential campaign, and the president of National Public Radio.)

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
