
Free-for-All Iowa Debate Highlights Fluid Race
Published Dec. 11, 2011 • Read time: 5m
DES MOINES -- Saturday night's Republican presidential debate was billed as a showdown between front-runners Newt Gingrich and Mitt Romney, but each of the six candidates who took the stage at Drake University embraced the spotlight at various points and reminded a national television audience that the race for the Republican nomination remains deeply unsettled with just over three weeks to go before voting begins.
The debate's most memorable moment came during an exchange between Romney and Rick Perry, who has largely receded from the forefront of the political conversation after a series of stumbles and additional scrutiny left his once surging campaign languishing in the polls.
As Perry and Romney argued about whether a passage in Romney’s most recent book suggested that his Massachusetts health care mandate should be a model for the nation, Romney appeared increasingly agitated.
“Rick, I’ll tell you what,” Romney said, extending his hand toward Perry, who was standing next to him. “10,000 bucks. $10,000 bet?”
Romney continued to hold his hand out, but the Texas governor declined to shake it.
“I'm not in the betting business, but I'll show you the book,” Perry said.
Romney’s unusual offer set off immediate chatter about whether the sight of the multimillionaire candidate offering such a high-priced wager, even in jest, would reinforce perceptions that he is unable to identify with middle-class Americans.
Within minutes, the campaign for Jon Huntsman -- who did not participate in the Iowa debate and instead held a town-hall meeting in New Hampshire as it was taking place -- blasted out an email to reporters that promised to launch a new website domain at 10KBet.com.
National Democrats also appeared to rejoice at the political utility that the moment mighty provide them in the event that Romney becomes the Republican nominee.
“Bet you $10,000 @MittRomney's not going to be happy with this debate performance,” tweeted Democratic National Committee Communications Director Brad Woodhouse.
In one of the debate’s other memorable exchanges, moderator George Stephanopoulos pressed Romney to specify areas in which he disagreed with Gingrich.
“We can start with his idea to have a lunar colony that would mine minerals from the moon,” Romney said. “I'm not in favor of spending that kind of money to do that. He said that he would like to eliminate in some cases the child labor laws so that kids could clean schools. I don't agree with that.”
Romney’s line of attack signaled a new effort on his part to portray Gingrich as an unsteady thinker who lacks basic leadership qualities.
The message did not appear to go over well with the former House speaker.
“The only reason you didn't become a career politician is you lost to Teddy Kennedy in 1994,” Gingrich fired back at Romney, in reference to a previous jab. “Iowa State's doing brilliant things, attracting brilliant students. I want to give them places to go and things to do, and I'm happy to defend the idea that America should be in space and should be there in an aggressive, entrepreneurial way.”
Michele Bachmann, who has retreated to Iowa to make a last-ditch stand here to revitalize her campaign, came prepared to join the fray.
As part of her effort to portray herself as the only true, across-the-board conservative in the race, Bachmann delivered a two-for-one salvo against the two GOP front-runners.
“When you look at Newt Gingrich, for 20 years, he's been advocating for the individual mandate in health care,” Bachmann said. “That's longer than Barack Obama. Or if you look at Mitt Romney as the governor of Massachusetts, he's the only governor that put into place socialized medicine.”
Bachmann next lumped the two competitors together on a range of hot-button issues.
“If you look at Newt/Romney, they were for ObamaCare principles,” she said. "If you look at Newt/Romney, they were for cap and trade. If you look at Newt/Romney, they [were] for the illegal immigration problem. And if you look at Newt/Romney, they were for the $700 billion bailout, and you just heard Newt/Romney is also with Obama on the issue of the payroll extension.”
Ron Paul, who remains a significant challenger to Gingrich in Iowa, also took an assertive approach in hitting the former Georgia congressman on a host of issues.
Paul confronted Gingrich over his past work in earning millions of dollars from mortgage giant Freddie Mac.
“Freddie Mac is bailed out by the taxpayers, so in a way, Newt, I think you probably got some of our taxpayers’ money,” Paul said.
Though he has failed to generate much perceivable momentum in his do-or-die state of Iowa, Rick Santorum received more airtime than he has typically enjoyed in past debates.
Santorum strove to show off his familiarity with Iowa’s geography and political figures in an effort to highlight the amount of time he has spent campaigning in the nation’s first voting state, which has far exceeded that put in by any of his GOP rivals.
“I was just down in Fremont County, which is down in the far southwest corner of the state, and they just lost about a couple hundred jobs at the ConAgra plant down there,” Santorum said. “And Governor Branstad and Lieutenant Governor Reynolds understand -- that's why they asked us to have a forum here in Pella a few weeks ago on manufacturing. They understand that the heartland of America is suffering because the manufacturing economy of this country continues to go down.”
The Republican candidates will have less than a week to adjust to the fallout from Saturday’s debate, as they will meet again on Thursday night in Sioux City, Iowa.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






