Interview with White House Advisor Jacob Lew
Published Sept. 19, 2011 • Read time: 7m
KING: More on the president's new $3 trillion deficit reduction plan. Half of that amount would come from tax increases, including big changes for more wealthy Americans. As he announced it in the Rose Garden, the president knew just what the Republicans would say about his approach.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
OBAMA: This is not class warfare. It's math. The money is going to have to come from someplace.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
KING: Let's dig deeper now and just how the president assembled this plan and whether he will compromise with congressional Republicans or fight this one out in the next contain campaign. The Obama budget director Jacob Lew is with us from the White House tonight.
Jack, I want to start on that point. When you are assembling this plan, I know from a policy standpoint, you think these higher taxes on more affluent Americans are the right thing to do. But you know from a political point, it's dead on arrival so, you made the decision to leave it in there. That's more a political calculation than a policy calculation, isn't it?
JACOB LEW, WHITE HOUSE BUDGET DIRECTOR: You know, John, I actually hope that that is not the correct assessment. There's no doubt that there is an almost instinctive reaction on the Republican side to say that, but last summer we saw that there were some openings for a reasonable discussion, and I hope we find that again.
KING: Back in the lame-duck session the president once again agreed to leave the Bush tax cuts in place, so we know back in 2008 he campaigned for president saying he wanted to get rid of the Bush tax cuts for those at $250,000 or above. When he left them in place again in that decision at that time he said, he said look, here's my tough decision. I don't want to raise taxes when the economy might still be in recession or is just barely in recovery. You could make the case the economy is as weak if not weaker now. Why put tax increases on the table?
LEW: Well, we're not talking about raising taxes today or tomorrow. What the president proposed is in two phases, the immediate action is to cut taxes. The American jobs act would reduce payroll taxes for individuals, avoid a tax increase in January, and it would reduce taxes for businesses that hire new workers. So, in the short run he is very concerned, as we all should be, about making sure the economy grows and we create jobs.
As we look out over the horizon at the very difficult choices we have in terms of how to get our fiscal house in order, revenues have to be part of it, and the president's proposals today would take effect in you know in beginning not this year or next year, but after that. I think that if you look at the kind of balance of what the choices Congress faces, in the debt bill that we agreed to together in August, it put in place automatic cuts that would have very deep cuts in defense and in domestic spending that everyone agrees are unacceptable.
The challenge for the joint committee is to come up with a better alternative. What the president said today is we have to raise the bar and do even more because doing the minimum is really not enough. We have to make a statement that we're going to reduce our deficit and our debt as a percentage of the economy so that it is actually helping us to promote long-term growth.
KING: One way you could read this document, and you have been in Washington long enough to know how this works is you know you're not going to get the rate increases, but what the president hopes to do is say go big, number one be as you say, make it a bigger number, and put the pressure on the Republicans since they won't give you the rate increases to actually develop the political will to do comprehensive tax reform and to work with the Democrats on the committee for that so that you lower rates for everybody. You get rid the loopholes and, therefore, you get more money in Washington. That acceptable to the president, forget his rates as long as he gets that in the end, the bottom line? LEW: Well, if the president made clear in the document he sent to Congress today that our goal is tax reform. Our goal is in our principles in tax reform include lowering rates, but we also have to raise revenue while we're doing that. We think that would be the best thing to do for the economy and for the American people and if there's a path there to work together, we should get that accomplished and we should do it as soon as possible.
It is not an acceptable place to go to say that the entire burden for solving our deficit problem should fall on the backs of those who are on Medicare and Medicaid and who are in many ways the least able to absorb it. There has to be a shared burden if this is going to be done fairly, and we can't say that those who get the most benefit out of the tax code and out of the economy are exempt from any impact.
KING: You know full well in the business community a lot of CEOs say well we need more certainty from Washington. We need the bickering to end and what the policy is going to be. Not for the next three to five years. But how about the next three to five years, that would really help us? What the president puts a veto threat out there and, again, you know in your heart you're not going to get those rate increase on more wealthy Americans, do you worry at all that this standoff, if the president holds that line and has to veto something or doesn't get, doesn't even get something and the automatic cuts kick in, that you contribute indirectly to that uncertainty that's hurting the economy and the markets?
LEW: I think that what happened this past summer was a very, very bad thing in terms of the kind of gridlock and kind of dysfunction that the world saw when it looked at government. We need to do better than that. We are now in a place where there is not that threat of immediate default, so one can say that the action forcing event is perhaps less clear, but it's an opportunity for us to work together and show that we can get beyond what that bickering that everyone saw and try to get something important done for the American economy and for our budget.
I think that the notion that taxes are off the table is as much of a nonstarter as any other kind of absolute principle like that might be. So that's not a reasonable, that's not a way of showing leadership. The president I think showed leadership today by saying I'm going to put on the table a host of very difficult policies, reductions in Medicare and Medicaid, reductions in programs from agriculture to federal workers. These are hard policies. The right answer is everything should be on the table. Taxes should be on the table, and we should do this together.
KING: Fascinating and stressful time to be at the White House budget director.
LEW: Certainly is.
KING: Appreciate your time tonight.
LEW: Thanks John.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






