Libertarian Authors Discuss "The Declaration of Independents"
Published July 5, 2011 • Read time: 13m
Reason magazine editors Nick Gillespie and Matt Welch, authors of "The Declaration of Independents: How Libertarian Politics Can Fix What's Wrong With America," discuss their ideas in an interview with Heather Wilhelm. You can read her review of the book here.
Heather Wilhelm: Your book is very optimistic about the future, and you mention the word "utopia" several times. One critique of progressivism, at least from a conservative point of view, is that it is based on the assumption that society -- and therefore people -- can be perfected. How would you describe your view of human nature?
Matt Welch: We definitely have a sunny-side-up mentality. It's in the DNA of the magazine -- and I think in the DNA of America as well. We've had people comment on how optimistic we are in the book, which is funny, as we really didn't think about it that way. I guess the fact is we're in a pretty tight spot as a nation, and a lot of people who are receptive to our ideas are feeling pretty apocalyptic right now.
Nick Gillespie: As to the human condition, my view is that it's terminal. I might describe us as libertarian existentialists. Humanity is not perfectible, but our optimism stems from the fact that it's getting harder and harder to control people from the top down. We are running an infinite number of experiments in living all the time.
On a personal level, that's great. From a policy perspective, it's also fantastic, as you can learn from other people's mistakes. It's really an incredible network, where you have decentralized activity all the time and people learning and sharing through failure as well as success.
Welch: If you look at history, it's pretty indisputable that everything is much better than it was in 1971. We aren't locked in a superpower battle against an evil empire -- we won -- and hundreds of millions of people were freed as a result of the end of the Cold War. Hundreds of millions of people have been lifted out of poverty in China and India. So many measures of our personal lives are indisputably better. Things have improved everywhere you look, with one glaring exception: the areas of life where the government has the biggest role. If we can transfer the insights that have led to gains everywhere else in the world to government, we can see real improvements in public policy. And since we're out of money, the appetite for these changes will continue to grow.
Wilhelm: You cite polls that indicate "sizable majorities think the government is doing too much and spending too much." And yet similar polls show sizeable majorities rejecting significant changes to their entitlement programs. How do you explain these contradictory results?
Gillespie: Yeah, we all want ice cream that tastes great and isn't fattening. I think it's part of an educational process. There's no question that people like to get stuff for free. What's been going on over the past few years is that people are realizing that there isn't a free lunch.
Welch: I also think there's a successful politics out there that involves railing against entitlement spending. Rand Paul is a great example of this -- he ran on this issue, took on the GOP, took on Mitch McConnell in his own state, and won. It's not an accident that Paul Ryan is a rising star and many Republicans are scrambling to get on his team. People recognize that this is a key issue.
Wilhelm: If someone held a gun to your head and you had to choose between the Democrats and Republicans, which one would it be?
Gillespie: (Laughs). I think I would wrestle the gun away and blow my own brains out first. Our whole point is that it's the wrong question to be asking. We're always going to have two parties, but they are significantly weaker than they were in the early ‘70s as a controlling apparatus. Party loyalty is down substantially.
The real question is what policies you want and how you can push these parties around. We need the people to be calling the shots more. John Boehner, for instance, is the quintessential big-government conservative. In the past, he never met a big spending bill he didn't like, and now he's singing a different tune. It's independents and tea party people who have held his feet to the fire.
The question, really, is: How can we put the guns on the Democrats and Republicans?
Welch: Look at the tea party. If they had that attitude -- that they had to choose and step in line -- they wouldn't be where they are now. They refused to be rolled by Republicans. At the time, they were constantly criticized for having bad strategy, and we disagree. They no longer respond to the party's dog whistle. Instead, they're organizing their political action around an idea, as opposed to a tribe, and this gets more traction. This is particularly true if your ideas resonate with the American public, which they increasingly do.
The way out is not to accept that gun to your head. I think both Republicans and Democrats are finding that out.
Gillespie: I think I can summarize this by saying we would have been Democrats when Grover Cleveland was in office and Republicans when Warren G. Harding was striding the earth like a colossus.
Wilhelm: In your opinion, what's the most annoying critique of libertarianism out there?
Gillespie: Well, there are two. One comes from the right, when they say that libertarianism is just libertinism. And that's just wrong. No one I know is saying, "Do unto others -- and then split." Libertarianism is fundamentally focused on both personal autonomy and personal responsibility.
From the left, the accusation is always that you don't care about the poor, or even that you want to use them as cord wood for your winter fires. What's so off base about this is that libertarians are incredibly generous people, and also incredibly focused on people supporting each other. It's actually about connecting.
Welch: I would also add the fact that as soon as Washington changes hands, and the power switches to a new party, the people who were once your best pals now call you shills for the previous regime. When the GOP is in power, you're a sneaky pinko at a cocktail party -- cocktail parties we don't go to -- and then the Democrats are in power and you're a shill for Rupert Murdoch. Also, libertarians are constantly challenged to provide the logical conclusion of our philosophy: "Well, would you have a government sidewalk?" Social conservatives don't get that. Liberal Democrats don't get that. The first wave of libertarians were heavy on the overarching philosophy, so I suppose that might be where it's coming from. I take it as a compliment rather than an insult, but it is rather curious when you think about it.
Gillespie: We define libertarian as more of an adjective than a noun. It's a personal default setting toward more freedom and giving more choice to individual actors. Sometimes, depending on the situation, you'll override that default.
Wilhelm: You celebrate the role of pop culture and its role in breaking down barriers and sparking political change. At the same time, you seem pretty blasé regarding the amazing proliferation of "choice" in online porn or in the "complicated and multilayered" sexual exploits of Tiger Woods. Are you concerned at all about the coarsening of culture that more freedom can bring, and how do you bridge this gap with religious conservatives?
Gillespie: There is no question that there is more graphic and sexual imagery available now than ever before. Some of this stuff wasn't even imaginable in, say, the '60s. But there is also no question that violent crime rates and sexual crime rates are also down. So it is clear as an empirical fact that an increase in the graphic imagery has not had the detrimental effect on behavior that most people worry about.
What this means is that people are able to sort more, which is a good thing. Of course Tiger Woods is not a hero; he has fallen from being a hero because of his behavior. But we do live in a nicer, safer, more respectful world now, even though we have a pop culture that trades freely in vulgar imagery.
Welch: It also comes down to who is imposing what on whom. I have no taste for ultra-violent movies -- maybe "A Clockwork Orange," but when I think about it, I really don't feel like seeing that again soon -- so my solution is that I don't see those movies. No one imposes it on me or removes my ability to see what I want.
You could say that religious expression is in the same way. There is more freedom to express your religious beliefs today, and that makes us as a nation far richer. With freedom, people can choose things that you dislike.
Gillespie: It's really to the shame of America that as the USSR and Cuba were censoring rock music and imprisoning people for playing that music, there were forces in the U.S. with a similar authoritarian impulse -- burning records, etc. Pop culture, high culture and low culture have never been so vibrant as now, and violent crimes and sex crimes are down. We need more punk rock if we really want to make it to utopia.
Wilhelm: Here was my least-favorite part of the book: "The existential threat of communism and the Cold War that underwrote our childhoods is dead and buried, and despite the abject horror of the 9/11 attacks, radical Islamic terrorism is no serious threat to our way of life or even the future of the globe." What if you're wrong, and things like loose nukes, biological warfare, and globalized terror networks are indeed an existential threat to the U.S.?
Welch: We could have a loose nuke, dirty bomb, or other nightmare scenario happening somewhere, but for a threat to be existential the idea has to be attractive. And the idea of Islamic radicalism is totally unattractive. Osama lost his battle long before he died. All you have to do is look at the "Arab spring" -- and it's true, we don't know what the result will be, but I think the majority of the action behind it comes from people trying to be more free. Seventh-century jihadist ideology is just not attractive, but for some, decades ago, applied Marxism was. I actually think attempts to compare those two are pretty obscene. Not only because they're wrong, but also because we're not fighting a superpower that has dozens of countries under their wing -- we're fighting a ragtag group of people who are failing at every turn.
Gillespie: As much as I want to disagree with Matt, I think he's right. It's not an existential threat. Al-Qaeda is a tough sell, and they're certainly having trouble recruiting. That's not to say that global terrorism is not a threat, but it's not on the level of the Soviet Union. Islamic terrorism is a much less unified operation. I also think we are more resilient as a society. We're not peaceniks. We believe the U.S. should have a strong and effective military. But we do question whether we should be occupying or bombing multiple countries across the globe.
Wilhelm: Do you think of freedom as more of a means, or an end?
Welch: Yes.
Gillespie: I think it's important not to confuse the map with the territory. I think it can be both. We are not really foundationalist thinkers. It's clear that everyone is a consequentialist on some level. I tend to think that freedom is an end in itself -- but if it led to a mass increase in human misery, you'd obviously have to rethink that. As Matt said earlier, it's in the DNA of the country that we are devoted to freedom as a necessary precondition. The evidence to restrict freedom and liberty should be massive and overwhelming before we move in that direction.
Welch: When Nick says we're not foundationalist thinkers, I think he's talking about me. I don't wake up with deep philosophical thoughts.
That said, I also think it's both. I think it's interesting that of all the things they could choose to pursue in the Declaration of Independence, they chose life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. It certainly wasn't politics. It's beyond the zero-sum dreariness of politics. Wherever a place is more free, it's going to be more prosperous and more interesting. That's the world we want to live in.
Wilhelm: "Contrary to the myths perpetuated by liberals and conservatives alike, the winning and losing of elections is not transformative of what matters most." I couldn't agree with you more -- I think culture is more important. Why do you think people get so hung up on the minutiae of politics?
Gillespie: Two responses. People are evacuating politics. Surveys taken over a 40-year period show that people are abandoning the two parties. This is also a clarifying moment. We're out of money, and this is squeezing down politics to its proper role. Government spending is soaring to soul-strangling levels.
Think about it this way: You can live in a world populated by Lady Gaga and Bill James and Tiger Woods and Herb Kelleher. It's fun, right? Or you can be locked into a room with Newt Gingrich and, say, Robert Byrd. What are you going to pick? Politics can be important, but we need to squeeze them down to a proper role.
Welch: Look at newspapers, which are all shrinking and deal with a world in which people have choices outside of them. So they constantly try to convince the reader that they are crucial for democracy on a life-and-death level.
In politics, it's even more so. Both parties support bailouts, entitlements and blow out budgets on every level. So how do they rally the troops? They totally exaggerate how the other guy is the devil or Hitler. The stories mirror each other, and that should tell people they're being played.
For instance, they asked people in both 2005 and 2009: "Is your government a threat to you?" In 2005, with the GOP in power, 60 percent of Democrats said yes, and 20 percent of the GOP said yes. In 2009, when the Democrats were in power, the numbers flipped. And that's obviously kind of insane, not just because 90 percent of them should have said yes both times, but also because it shows how we're being herded into tribes. It's a dead end, and I think Americans are realizing this. And that's why this spike in independents is going to last. Politics as usual just doesn't speak to us anymore. We're trying to push that process, speed it up, because it's a healthy reaction to this bipartisan misrule.
Wilhelm: Any final comments you'd like to make?
Gillespie: I'd like to say that I've never hated a man more than I hate Matt Welch. I thought it would fade over time, but it intensifies.
Wilhelm: You look pretty chummy in your Reason videos.
Welch: We're pretty good actors.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






